Lake Geneva Pie Co

Oh my goodness; the Cherry Crumb pie! Absolutely delicious! I tried my friends' apple crumble pie & that also was incredible. We tried the peanut butter cookies & they were so soft. Incredible place. It is SO cute inside. It has tiny tick tac toe game at the tables. Adorable. The service was incredible! Sweetest staff ever. Good coffee too!

I love all their pies, especially their quiches. They have really great soups and They also sell their pie crusts separately for a very great price so you can make your own pies at home. It's a great little place to go for The whole family!

Cute place. Slow service. Great pie! I would have liked to see prices and pies available by the slice on the chalkboard. Only prices advertised were the beverages and a price on a whole lemon meringue pie. After purchasing 2 slices, I'm guessing it's about $5/slice.

Wonderful friendly staff, amazing assortment of pies to choose from, soups and quiches also available, delicious as they look! A must stop if you are in the area! Best chocolate cream pie I ever had!

Delicious. We had raspberry pie, raspberry orange muffin, chipotle cheese quiche and oatmeal cookie. The quiche and baked items were nice and moist.

An amazing hidden jewel in beautiful Lake Geneva. Super friendly, family run, everything made from scratch, and their award winning pies absolutely live up to the hype. They must make hundreds of pies everyday. The line is usually out the door. So if you want to get your favorite pie come early, or order ahead.

You can tell it’s a “mom and pop shop” local favorite. All you need is a slice of pie, a cold glass of milk, and a bit of country music to give you a lil bit of that ol’ American country morning. Thank you to Lake Geneva Pie Co for giving us a great wake up to celebrate a special day!

I went in for a gluten free pie and they had one! We were going to our cousins for Thanksgiving in Illinois and stumbled across Lake Geneva Pie Company. We were too late to order a pie, so the kind last behind the counter helped us find one! Thank you! We have a lot of gluten free people in the family! The pie was a hit and I’m sure they will be driving up from Illinois to get them from now on! Thanks you!

So glad to find a bakery in the Lake Geneva area with gluten-free options! Their gluten-free options are in the freezer case as a take & bake, at least that's how it was when we visited in the off season of April (maybe they have some gluten-free options baked during the busier tourist season, I'm not sure). You can order ahead with 48-hours notice if you want a gluten-free option baked for you, or a custom order. In the freezer for take & bake they had some gluten-free: pies, loaf cakes, cookies, and quiche. We got a gluten-free Strawberry-Rhubarb Crumble Pie frozen and baked it at home. It was delicious! The guy at the counter was very helpful and friendly, too.

I tried the beef pot pie for the first time and was greatly disappointed. The filling was so salty that after 3 bites we gave up. Also, the beef was tough. For $28 dollars this left us wishing we bought a frozen pot pie from grocery store. We have tried other dessert pies before and most were good. But, we will never do savory again. The last one ended up in the garbage.

Stopped by here on Saturday while I was out in the area. Had lots of people in it, so I thought it must be pretty popular. Went in with the intention of getting two pies, a chocolate pie and a banana cream pie. We pretty quickly found a French Silk pie in the freezer, if done well this is one of the best pies in existence. Wasn't able to find a banana cream pie though even though it lists they have it on their website. Got in line and was a bit confused to see pets wandering around in the store. Considering this is an establishment that sells food, I am not sure if this meets health code or not. Get to the front of the line and ask the girl if we could also have a banana cream pie. I was asked how many pieces I wanted, told her an entire pie. She told me they didn't have banana cream as a full pie, could only buy slices. Told her we would pass on the banana cream, would just take the French silk. She told me at that point the French silk pie would be $50. I was a bit taken aback and asked why it was so expensive. Here is when the entire experience really went down hill for me.. I was told "French Silk is a very difficult pie to make and not many people know how to many them any longer. This is why it costs so much" I make French silk pies all the time, I have been making them for decades. They are one of the easiest pies to make, anyone telling you they are difficult is not being truthful. Curious about this incredibly labor intensive pie by Lake Geneva Pie Company I bought one. Got it home and gave it a try, a few things for people to be aware of. - What they are selling as a French silk pie, tastes more like a chocolate pudding pie. No way near as decadent or rich as a pie like this should taste. - No salt has been added to this recipe, it is way to sweet, definitely not what I would expect from a French silk pie. - They use graham cracker crust, very strange choice for this type of pie. - This is not worth $50 Anyone interested in a French silk pie that they can make for under $10-$15 I have included my favorite recipe below. Do yourselves a favor, don't pay $50 for a pie you can make much better at home yourself. Shame on Lake Geneva Pie company for trying deceive their customers claiming French Silk is a super difficult pie to make. French Silk Pie Recipe - 1 Cup salted butter - 1 1/2 cups sugar - 2 Ounces of unsweetened chocolate, melted and cooled - 2 Teaspoons of vanilla extract (preferably real vanilla extract w/ bourbon) - 4 Eggs Whipped Cream - 1 Cup heavy cream - Teaspoon powdered sugar - 1/4 teaspoon salt - Vanilla extract to taste Pie Directions: Make or bake a pie crust, or take the easy way out and use graham crackers as a crust. Beat sugar & butter until sugar is not grainy (this works easiest with ultra fine cane sugar). Add chocolate & vanilla and mix together. Add eggs, two at a time, beating a couple of minutes after each addition. Pour into cooled pie crust. Chill 2 hours or until firm. Before serving, top with whipped cream and a little grated chocolate. Whipped Cream Directions: - Add all ingredients into a large bowl, beat until thick. Shouldn't take more than a couple of minutes.

Amazing service and delicious food!!! What a lovely place to visit for breakfast or lunch I am delighted with their quiche (asparagus, tomato and mozzarella). It was sooo good! The chai latte was a perfect finish! Don't miss this place

Hands down the best crumb pie in the Midwest. Tell me a better pie.. so good. All do the crumb pies are out of this world.

High prices Wide variety of pies and frozen pastries Friendly service Quiet but spartan place

From fresh homemade pies to the dinner pot pies, everything is delicious. Service is friendly and helpful and I came in around 3pm and enjoyed a slice of strawberry rhubarb pie, my favorite, with a nice hot cup of coffee. The few small tables are quaint and inviting and it was satisfying until a late dinner event that evening.

Great pies generally but the lemon meringue pie is amazing. Sadly, its special order with 48 hours notice required. It was so good im wishing i had another one!! I don't live in Lake Geneva. Im an hour away. Was there for my daughters wedding. I was aware of special order so i ordered a couple days before i was to arrive. Im glad i did. The pie had just the right level of tartness and sweetness and the meringue was light and fluffy and perfect. I should have taken a picture.

Pies are good one day not so good the next. No military or senior discount. No discount period..... I think at 24.00 or 25.00 cost per pie there is room for a discount. Can buy a pie at half the cost and just as good if not better.

Amazing pies Haven't had one I didn't like. Service is still problematic. Even when you order ahead seems to be challenging to get your order correct. But based on pies alone, the pies are all fantastic.

Stopped in for a local lunch choice, ended up picking up dinner for later! Fresh and delicious. Interesting that you can't request a sandwich but choose from what is premade. Not to worry, found a yummy one. The best was the cherry crumb pie. I quess I was too hungry, all that was left for photos!

The best!! My family has been going to LG Pie Co for over 10 years - we love the Lakeshore!

The LGPC says "pies made fresh daily" but strangely enough we've NEVER SEEN anyone mixing, managing, or making any baked goods in this open-style kitchen where everyone can see the entire prep facility area. We've seen them brew coffee, but the pies are probably machine-made and taste factory frozen, as well with the quiche, cookies, and muffins --also assembly-line perfect and identical in appearance, shape, form, and weight. So we take a full PASS on this place. And, again unless you like highly processed white flour, white sugar, fat/oils from questionable sources, meat products that are high in nitrates, and flash frozen tasting junk, STAY AWAY!

Cherry pie had almost no cherries in it. The pie was mostly sugar and water. Don't know what happened used to be a good place to get pies.

Nice bakery and good service! Average pecan pie for the price. Nice unique options for baking toppings as well.

First of all, in no way is this a bad review. I had to do an errand in Lake Geneva, and so I planned to stop here. Or, maybe, I came for the pie and did the errand while I was there. The place is super cute and the staff is wonderful. I had to try a little or everything because of the great reviews. Everything was good, but I was a little underwhelmed. Maybe I set my expectations too high. Maybe my Aunt Toodie's pies are better. Maybe I am bound by my family clan to say Aunt Toodie's are better. This place was good. Just not Aunt Toodie's.

I ordered a pumpkin pie, when I went to pick up the pie the lady pulled the pie out of the case by the front register, I was upset because I had no idea how long the pie had been in the case. When I had brought the pie home I saw that the pie crust had not been cooked. I went to the pie company because I have always had good experiences but after this one I will no longer be a customer.

Yum! My mom makes 2 crust Betty crocker pies with her eyes closed. I make pies with a lot of cursing and they never look as pretty. So when mother's day rolls around, this is my go-to place. Call in advance for holidays, no charge to pre-order. We've tried several fruit pies with pastry crusts, all have been delicious. Pot pies are also good. And their paninis. And coffee.

Judging this as a lunch place. I was hoping this would be so much more because there are hardly any places to eat around there, but was disappointed. They don't make anything on demand so when they're out of stock - that's it. Food was so/so but we didn't have many options. Decor is like like walking into someone's kitchen or a deli.

I truly wanted to love this place but I just couldn't look past the biggest mistake, the pie. For 4.25 per slice it didn't live up to the hype. First the choices, how could you have the same one twice and still not have a apple. There was only 4 flavors to pick from, none apple or a cream. I went with the cherry. The piece was mangled with the juice totally doing away with the bottom crust. You could not tell there was a crust because it almost looked raw. Next they put it on a paper plate. Really you could not have an actual plate. Very cheap looking. And the counter person wasn't the most friendly either. The actual pie was not a big deal. You could tell they were real cherries not some fake filling. That is the only thing that saved them from a 2 rating. Like I said I truly believe in loving this place but no not worth almost $5 for a slice with tax

Stopped here as we were driving back to downtown Lake Geneva. This place is just eh, nothing special. We arrived around 3pm, which was a couple hours before closing. They barely had any pies or slices available. Luckily, they had a slice of pecan pie. I also ordered a couple cookies, and a chocolate/peanut bar, just to taste. The pie was just eh, nothing to write home about. The only pecans were crusted on top. The filling looked like plain custard with no pecan pieces mixed in. The cookies and the bar were bland. Service was eh. The girl at the counter asked if she could help us. My BF asked her the general, "what is most popular?" She was less than enthused, and just wanted to get us on our merry way, which lead to us picking the pecan pie.

Only pre-made sandwiches offered and the roast beef I had was a bit crusty on the edges. After sitting and being re-warmed the bottom was completely oily. We also had french silk and banana cream pie. Um? Maybe it's just me but shouldn't home made pie be...home made? The crust was dry and seemed right out of Wal-Mart's freezer case. The filling was most likely boxed pudding mix. Extremely disappointing for $25 for 2 people for lunch.

Not sure if teenage staff was day one or the training was non-existent. French silk pie lacks chocolate flavor. The selection never indicates a willingness to have variety. When I'm thinking about a pie specialty place I'm thinking not frozen and some opportunity for choice. Third time through and it's hit or miss on what we want to what they have. Sorry for the honesty but I really wanted this place to be awesome.

Whatever you do don't try to get a slice of pie. Each time we have been here the "pies are too warm to cut" per the various employees on duty. This may in fact be a rule set forth by owners. It may even have solid reasoning behind it. However, why set pies for sale by the slice - in the display case - when you *can't yet sell them* it makes absolutely no sense. Keep them in the back until they cool if they are not ready to be sold. If the pie case looks too empty, well then, perhaps you need to rethink your replenishment plan.

Went here for a slice of pie after reading the reviews. Great customer service from the young seasonal workers. The pie was really good. Will be back.

I will not return here. This was my First time there and I was talking to other customers in line and didn't notice that cashier had shorted me 10$ in change for pie I purchased with 20$ paid. I didn't notice until I left store and went to pay for items at another store.I left email to manager and never heard back. Cherry pie was good but not worth $17 paid.

Stopped in while I was waiting for some at Aurora Medical for a cappuccino and I must say it was as good as and made at Starbucks. They have sandwiches as well as pastries and pies. A little gem in the corner of The strip mall.

Great place - makes all their own pies and quiches. Should have added to their name -" And Bakery with sandwiches and salads and cookies! So it doesn't taste 'store made' with all that crud that makes the ingredient list look like a chemistry exam. They have great pre-made sandwiches, individual pieces of pie, nice salads, and a lot of stuff you can grab and pack a picnic lunch with!

Rhubarb strawberry. Incredible. Such a cute little local place. You can tell there's lots of love going in to each pie. Yum

Best pie around! The lake berry pie is fantastic! They also have great homemade sandwiches. Try the pies you will love them!

If you're a fan of Seinfeld, and remember the "Soup Nazi", well, this place has the "Pie Nazi".... EXTREMELY rude customer service.... pie was "ok", nothing special.... I just moved into the area, but will not be returning to this place.

We love PIE. We were in the Lake Geneva area on vacation and this place had advertised in our vacation literature. We purchased the cherry crumb pie to take with us to our hotel room. It was 10:45 a.m., and the pie was still warm. It was the BEST EVER pie we have had. The crust was buttery, a very generous amount of tart cherries throughout and the crumb topping was crunchy. The cost of the pie was $18.50 which seemed high at the time. BUT the quality of the pie was well worth it. We will be back the next time we are in town.

Best pies anywhere, period. I love the mixed berry pie with crumble topping! It's nice that you have the option to buy smaller pies if you don't have a full house

Just a small place in a strip mall but their chicken pot pie is good. I also tried the key lime pie and it was great but can't say i eat lots of dessert pies. Their pie crusts are delicious. Tender, tasty and crisp. I wouldn't make this a destination but if you're in area it is worth a stop.

My wife saw an ad for this place in a local tourist magazine. I love pie. I can dig pot pie. We Yelped it. 5 star average given 4 reviews. We headed over for lunch. It was a Sunday. We find the place...it's a typical storefront in a typical strip mall. We go inside. The "typical" continues. The usual nondescript tables, chairs, a couple of retirees sipping coffee. A large, well-lit kitchen is clearly visible from the our side of the counter. Nobody back there but one older gentleman. It was about noon. We check out the specials written on the board. There's a couple... One about chicken pot pie. We ordered that. The guy behind the counter states that "we don't have pot pie on the weekends. I can make you a sandwich..." Well then how about changing your sign, grandpa? After our disappointment washed over us, we settle on a quiche. The reviews didn't say anything about them, nor did they mention the sandwiches. Just the pot pie. But the pot pie wasn't available on the weekend??!? Because we were hungry and had a schedule to keep, we decided on a slice of quiche. Absolutely meh. The flavors of the fillings were fine. But the crust really looked and tasted like it was pre-made a thousand miles away. And the quiche (and pies) were kept in a very unappealing display case. (As I said we were hungry.) Dunno how he heated these for us, but we got em a few minutes later. Dixie paper plates. No points at all for presentation. We didn't try the fruit or cream pies really because the whole place struck us both as being really kinda spartan. No warmth, no charm, no character. Still, what makes this review a 3 star instead of a 2 star is because we did buy a frozen chicken pot pie--unbaked, and baked it for dinner tonight. Took a while (over 90 minutes in the oven plus 45 minutes to cool and set) but it was tasty. Flaky crust (obviously not the same crust as the crummy quiches), tender chunks of chicken, lots of corn, potatoes, carrots...peppery and not too salty. No gloppy, goopy typical pot pie filling. Just good stuff that tasted good. If we want to take away another frozen pot pie, perhaps we'll go there again. But not to eat there.

Had the chocolate silk pie and it tasted like bakers square not like a fresh made pie. However, I also bought the small berry cherry cobbler and it was really good with some vanilla ice cream. Would definitely recommend that one.

Super good !!! We got the lemon bar which was so good and the cranberry orange muffin , coconut cream pie . And all of it was excellent. Only reason why I'm giving 4 starts out of 5 is because they didn't have what I actually wanted which was banana cream pie . Which was the reason why we were there . But we def liked the other options they had .

Great selection of seasonal pies, they also have a no added sugar option if you preorder. This place is not to missed when in the area. Great customer service. We love bringing one home for friends & family!

Go there all the time the pie is good The lady who runs or owns the place needs lessons on how to treat her customers . The lady who wears glasses and has a thumb ring on has snooty attitude . I Have seen her be very rude . Last time I was in the i didn't like her attitude so I will get my pie else were from now on . She lost a good customer but doesn't even realize it . I will get my pie from Elegant farmer from now on . If a owner or manager is that rude to customers and doesn't realize it she need reality check . I saw her give customer attitude over the customer asking her cut there sandwich in fours instead of in half . She was like you asked me to cut it in half not fours . Stay away from this place this will show her she can't be rude when she doesn't have customers . Elegant farmer has Better pies anyways!!!!!

I don't normally take the time to go out of my way to participate in reviewing dining establishments but in this case I feel I have to due to my overwhelming happiness. In my opinion chicken pot pies are one of the best comfort foods on the planet. Finding one that's even half way decent is almost impossible because most places cheap out on the ingredients or they're so bland I might as well be eating cardboard. When I walked into this place and saw the open kitchen floor plan allowing me to see them making pies in an incredibly clean and organized environment I thought maybe this place has got it going on? I asked one of the ladies making pies if their pot pies were made with love and she said "Everything is made with love!" I bought one and it ROCKED! Stars to the N'th degree:)

Hands down the best pie and one of the best kept secrets in the area. Chocolate Banana Pie, Lakeshore Berry Crumb (rasp, black, straw, & apples), Peach Strawberry and more. Their non-pie items are great too, but c'mon, get some pie! Hint: if you want a perfect slice at home, buy their pie cutter - makes a large perfect slice every time!

Awesome smells and good chicken pot pie! Did not buy any sweets, but if they are as tasty as that pie crust, you will not be disappointed. Odd self-serve, counter service for a decent dining area. That would be an area of improvement for the owners. My latte was surprisingly good

Fantastic quiches and muffins. They have a nice seating area if you want to eat in. The service was prompt and friendly.

The pies here are really delicious, and I'd really like to give them 5 stars... Only problem is, I can rarely get a slice of what I come to get. They have a ridiculous rule where if 6 pies are out and precut, you can't cut a new one. So if you come in and want a specific flavor that is readily available, but they already have 6 pies out, too bad. You either have to buy the entire thing, or hope someone orders from the flavors that are precut until they have space for a new flavor. I have run into this every single time for the last dozen visits. It's incredibly irritating. Especially when I'm making special trips to get something for someone, and come home empty handed for no other reason than the place not being able to cut a bleeping pie...

We tried their apple pie and their cookies several times and were disappointed. The cookies were very dry. The apple pie was just okay. I know that most bakery pies don't compare to homemade and everyone has their own personal taste for pies and desserts, but the crust tasted like "store bought" and the pie was bland. On a more positive note, the service was good and the staff members were friendly, and it was very nice and clean inside.

Just had their Quiche, Light , Fluffy, perfect balance. Went back for a second slice .Now I am re-thinking if I should let my Thanksgiving pies remain untouched.

Great pies! We love the pot pies as well as the quiches and muffins! Great place!! We stock up when we come here!

So.... Stayed in Lake Geneva with dh and and the canine son. As we were driving to the Grand Geneva, I saw the LGPC and I knew I would hit it on my way home! I prepared myself by reading reviews and studying menus. I noticed that there were lots of people that complained about lack of selection so I prepped myself. When I arrived a little before noon, there was very little selection. I had to buy 2 small frozen chicken pot pies for dh and I also bought a raspberry, peach crumble pie. DH said the chicken pp was good and I loved the raspberry, peach crumble. Both were definitely wins. Not bad for a small store in a strip mall. When I get to LG, I'll be back so bake some more pies!

Don't suggest getting a sandwich here. Bread hard and was probably days ago. Disappointed.

Awesome pies! We stop in every time we go to Lake Geneva to bring a pie home. They also have small selection of slices to eat there are take along for later. We've tried almost all of the fruit pies and there isn't a bad one out of the bunch.