gavin
Google
A Fading Star? A Michelin-Starred Experience Falls Short
The allure of a Michelin star is undeniable, promising not just exceptional cuisine but an impeccable dining experience. When a restaurant is newly crowned with this prestigious honor, as was the case for the establishment in question last November, the anticipation is even greater. Unfortunately, a recent visit suggests that this particular star may be losing its luster.
The tasting menu, a showcase of the kitchen’s artistry, was a solid performance. Dishes were well-executed and technically proficient, demonstrating a clear understanding of flavor and texture. However, the meal lacked a certain spark—that "wow" factor that separates the merely good from the truly memorable. The food was good, but it didn't transcend; it failed to leave a lasting impression.
The service, an equally important component of a fine dining experience, was a study in contradictions. While the waitstaff's frequent, almost performative inquiries of "I hope you like our service" felt a bit strange, it was the glaring oversights that truly soured the evening. A simple request—a candle for a friend's birthday dessert, confirmed in advance—was completely forgotten, a bewildering lapse for a restaurant of this caliber.
Adding to the list of missteps were several surprising and frankly, unprofessional, choices. The restaurant charged for bread and butter without any prior notification, a practice almost unheard of in the world of Michelin-starred dining. The stingy pour of wine for a single glass was another detail that, while small, speaks to a broader lack of generosity.
The most baffling moment, however, came at the end of the evening. After the bill was paid and the desserts had been cleared, the chef came out to greet the tables. He stopped at ours and, with a smile, said, "Happy birthday!" This final, ironic gesture was the ultimate confirmation that the message had, in fact, been received by the kitchen. The birthday was known, yet the simple request for a candle was still forgotten. It’s a stunning example of a disconnect between the front of the house and the kitchen, a symptom of management that seems to have its priorities misplaced.
Ultimately, the food was a saving grace, but the overall experience was a letdown. A one-star rating is a hard-earned achievement, a testament to culinary excellence and an expectation of flawless execution. If this restaurant hopes to maintain its place among the gastronomic elite, it needs to work much harder to ensure that its service and attention to detail match the quality of what comes out of its kitchen. Otherwise, that shining star might be at risk of burning out.