Timothy Spencer T.
Yelp
TLDR: Is the cookie good? Yes. Was the ice cream good? It was eventually good when the frozenness allowed some flavor to punch through. Is it worth the money? I'll leave it up to you to decide.
Dark Chocolate Chocolate Chip: The cookie passed the taste and texture test. It was soft, chewy, and it was not too sweet. One weakness of large cookies like this is that they start off amazing then the quality drops off 5 minutes after it leaves the reheating oven. No such issues were found in this cookie. I took my time when eating this one and I can confidently say that the quality held up easily for 15 minutes, and the ice cream essentially masked whatever potential dryness it could have had when I eventually finished it 25-30 minutes in. My problem with this is my willingness to purchase the product. The longer I ate, the more time I had to ponder how much a the cookie cost. Personally, I feel that this cookie gave a vibe of someone bringing a tray of cookies in a pot luck and EVERYONE loved it and said how a business can be made out of this. While I don't disagree with the conclusion of this imagined scenario, I just don't feel comfortable spending money on this cookie as often as the business would like.
Vanilla Bean Ice Cream (Wanderlust): There are times when an ice cream scoop is too frozen, and this was one of those times. The ala mode was served with a wooden spoon, and I swear I tasted more wood than ice cream during my first 2 bites at it. After 5 or so minutes, I finally understood why this partnership was created. The vanilla was good, it wasn't the best, but it's definitely up there. Pairing the ice cream with the cookie creates a vanilla x chocolate sugar explosion that I will never complain about. Much like the cookie, the ice cream was not too sweet. Unfortunately, we have to revisit the problem at hand, is it worth it? The cookie is just north of $5, and throwing in a scoop of ice cream is another $5. Although this is the correct market price, part of me doubts whether this combination is worth $10.
Service: The staff were pleasant and very accommodating.
Ambiance: The place was nice. Most of the store was dedicated to baking cookies, and customers didn't have that much space, but I didn't mind since their product is easily handheld.