Liberty Grille

They serve Bar Pizza at Liberty Grille, which means a thin crust, cooked well, and a little small. Boy, do they do a great job! The South Shore is known for it, and we love the Greek Pizza, but also mix in our concoctions like Pepperoni & Jalapeño or Black Olive & Onion. They are usually backed up in the kitchen a bit, so when you show up "on time," you spend more than a few mins watching some of the regulars bunched together in the super tiny bar downstairs. But they're there to watch the show... Tonight, it was empty and our pizza were stacked for us andc ready to go.

This bar pizza was surprisingly fantastic. Like, exceptionally good. Never heard of this place before stumbling upon it but 10/10 will return!

Liberty Grill has excellent bar pizza Great staff and service easy to deal with

Had many meals there, some good, some OK, but my last and final one in 2016 we got the badly burned pizza you see in the photo. No refund, no apology. They did offer to cook another one, but that would have made us late for the movie at the nearby Loring Hall Cinema. So I paid and left. We left the entire uneaten burned pizza on the table. Yuk.

so devastated to not even receive food, a table, or even any acknowledgment from the staff. especially troubling when “seat yourself” was falsely presented, and there was no available table that had enough seats for the 3 people present and my friends young infant. interestingly enough, the upstairs was “closed” for an empty event! wild and very confusing. no one was visibly an employee, and we stood in-front of the table for about 4 minutes before we left out of embarrassment. horrific. edit: seems as though this is the common experience. this lady needs to just quit i guess.

Welcoming, pleasant staff. Relaxed, quiet, smaller sized tavern. Enjoyed a dram.

First time here. Only 10" bar pizza is served and it's VERY good. The service was warm and friendly, but the atmosphere was awesome since you're eating in a building from the 1600-1700's...lots of warm, chunky wood on windows, doors, floors and low, beamed ceilings. The small bar looked to be very congenial and intimate. There 's a second floor (which I didn't see) but I know it must have a beautiful view of Hingham harbor right across the street. Quaint and cozy; try going during the week when it's quieter and you can enjoy that softly lit "old time'y" ambiance.

Waitress (short brown hair) is in the wrong line of work!! Completely forgot to put our order in and didn’t care! After an hour I asked why others were being served before us her answer was, “I don’t keep track of that”. Keep in mind we were the only ones there before others arrived. Didn’t apologize or anything and acted like she didn’t care. Great pie but horrendous service !!

Living in the New Haven area as, it's hard to find food that can compete with that in CT area. This past weekend I came across the Liberty Grille in Hingham Massachusetts, formerly known as the "Old Mill Grille". As a bar pie enthusiast, I was very eager to try this place as I had only heard great things. We ordered 3 small bar pies one with bacon, another with sausage and finally the good ole cheese bar pie. Right from when I took the first bite I knew this was a great decision by the crew. The bar pies Liberty Grille makes are the closest thing to competing with New Haven pizza. Crust was absolutely perfect. If I wasn't such a selfless person I probably would've eaten all 3 by myself. I'm disappointed I never got to stop into the restaurant but the next time I am in Hingham Massachusetts, I absolutely want to come in to check the place out sit at the bar with the drink and enjoy one more delicious bar pie.

Seriously good bar pizza. Perfectly crisp crust, tasty sauce and just enough so it isn't dry yet also isn't soggy. Very consistent. I have only gotten take out here but when I've gone in to pick it up the staff is always friendly and attentive.

We live nearby and love the bar pizza. Sometimes we eat there and remember when it had a full restaurant menu. That we miss. The takeout pizza is always busy and sometimes you have to give them a half hour to make your order. But the bartender/takeout server is a very cool and likeable character if you are a regular. Sometimes Christian, the owner, is your server and he's a cool guy too.

We walked in , only person working says "only pizza, "ok that's we went there, to try the bar pizza. Told us we could sit anywhere but a six top. I don't think crowds were coming. Not on Tues at 7 PM Pizza was ok. Horrible dry mouth now . Tasted like a frozen crust or a Boboli The guy working was more interested in his bar customers WE CAN SAY WE TRIED IT...end of story. No 2nd visit

Food and service was good and would go back . Ssssssssssssasssssssssssmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmdddddddddddddddddddddd Needed 85 letters

Liberty Grille! Local place with a venue for special events, it doesn't look big from the outside but has lots of space to offer. I guess we didn't expect much but got it all! The bartender is the true heart of this place that reminds of doll house... We sat at the second raw and spying on the other guests behind the curtain, but also didn't get excluded from the annual derby conversation on the bar. Some of the locals even offered us to chip in their bet pool right upon our arrival. I drank home adjusted recipe for an espresso martini made by "Guy" and wasn't disappointed! We didn't try their pizza but hope to come back soon to get one... We felt welcomed in the friendly atmosphere!

What happened to this place? Not same menu as " Pizza only" now. Parked near train station, walked over last September to find it CLOSED.. went to STARS instead. Tried again recently to find a pizza joint. Disappointing.

Well there is a post COVID and pre COVID Liberty. They are two very different places. Pre COVID was full menu, family atmosphere and post bar pizza, chowder and cocktails only. Owning a family run bar during COVID most have been trying for the owner. However newsflash where was everybody during COVID to support this business during that down time. Nowhere to be found. It's a business and Christian the owner sharpened his pencil and found his best customers and profitability model were the local asses at the bar. Not the fluffy families and occasional passers bye who turn around and go to Starz. So I feel they made a decision, cator to the locals, the regulars. Which is fine. It's a business. Here is what you get, great chowder, a top 5 South Shore Bar Pizza if you don't know what that is or don't care to learn just don't. You also get Guy at the bar who makes the Best Bloody Mary between Boson and LA. You get a full bar menu and if you are lucky a seat at the bar where you might meat a real local with deep New England roots, shut your pie hole for a minute and listen. Enjoy your pizza and your beer and relish in the atmosphere of a 17th Century Pub that was serving the Colonists who built this great nation. The pizza is pretty good, the service might not be with a smile, deal with it. Some things change because they have to.

Best pizza around! Classic for our family we've been going here for years and come from Hanover

Pizza was okay. Waitress was surly, and inattentive. Seemed to be a bunch of locals at the bar, so maybe they experience something we didn't. Not worth a send trip.

Pizza was excellent. I came here unexpectedly by myself yesterday after driving by this place several times. The pizza was fabulous. The crust had a nice crips to it. The texture was that incredible bar pizza that you get from the South Shore bar pizza.

Woman is so rude who answers the front. Pizza only! You may want to change your greeter. It was good pizza. Wine selection sucked but good pizza. Not sure why girl is just so mean.

Hostess was beyond rude. We walked in, waited several minutes for the hostess to notice us. We were greeted with a surly "we only have pizza." She walked us to the table, we sat down, and waited several more minutes for her to return. She never did. So we decided to leave. Sorry I can't speak to the quality of the food, but the way we were greeted is all I need to know. I will not be returning.

great pizza, service is horrendous!! After walking in and being the first 2 to be seated, 2 other parties were served before us. keep in mind they only serve pizza. After an hour I asked the waitress about our order and why others were being served before us she said "I don't know when you came in". Then she asked us what we ordered. She definitely looks like she was on some substance. Great pizza, horrible service!!!

Guy(the best bartender ever)is the only reason to go here. The pizza is excellent. The drinks are off the charts. The owner is an amazing cook but sadly since th pandemic isn't interested in cooking. It's a cool and comfortable place to check out. I wish the menu had more than pizza. Maybe someday

This server named bobby in tbe middle of dinner rush just talking on her phone while other tables are waiting for her..very unprofessional..

Bacon and mushroom, so good!! First time ordering a bar pizza from here. It didn't disappoint! Cracker like crust was thin and crunchy. Great cheese to sauce ratio. The bacon was crispy and delicious. Will definitely be back!

First time I tried this place. Went in for dinner. I loved the atmosphere. They were only serving pizza...maybe because of Covis?? We got the Greek pizza. It was very good. I would have given four stars but the woman who served us left much to be desired. She was completely disengaged and looked like she'd rather be anywhere else. Maybe a bad day. I would go back but it until they expand their menu.

I haven't been here for a while and it did not disappoint. Bar pizza doesn't get much better than this and after having this last night, I'd put it up there with Lynwoods or Poopsies. The crust is thinner more like Poopsies though. The chowder and fried seafood is also great here but it's tough to not at least grab a couple of pies to go.

if i could rate this place a 0 star i would. i was with my family and the waitress took down my order of a bbq chicken pizza and i waited atleast an hour for our 2 other pizzas to come out. then i waited another 30 min for the bbq chicken pizza i ordered and it never came to the table. lady also continuted to add it to the check but took it off. also did i mention that the womens bathroom upstairs ( full of drunk adults ) had men walking out of it !

Old musty-and small place. Food took way too long for sandwiches and pot pie. Only 3 tables with people eating and the bar was filled (all 8 or so stools) with regulars. Food was okay and service was slow too. Not going back. Just an average place.

Old school comfort food and solid local seafood. I love this place, again, decor reminiscent of the 1970s. Simple food prepared exceptionally well, and offered at better than reasonable prices. Great and friendly staff, plenty of parking. Good coffee and a full bar. This is the kind of place you should go during the winter and enjoy a good home cooked meal and gaze upon the harbor.

This review is strictly for the pizza as i have not had Any other food yet. The pizza is excellent ! I am very picky about bar pizza and to me Nothing compares to the Lynwood Cafe over in Randolph. That being said... this could very well Be the closest pizza ever to the Lynwood The cheese has a nice cheddar flavor, and the Crust is nice and crispy and very fresh tasting Would def. recommend this pizza if you are a bar pizza fan. It's excellent !

College student, came in here alone for a late lunch. No one else was there except the cook and waitress. The waitress was rude and short. I ordered a cheeseburger, medium. She slaps down the plate, it's just meat and bread - walks away without asking if I need anything. I called after her (keep in mind, the place if very small and was empty) she ignored and kept walking. I get up and asked for some lettuce, ketchup. God forbid I interrupt her conversation. French fries were fried to the point they weren't potato anymore, burger was over welldone. Positives: The bread was toasted nicely. Have not been there before, will not go back.

The hostess was probably one of the rudest people I've ever met. We walk in and the first thing the hostess says is "are you picking up takeout?" We proceed to say no and she goes well we only have pizza. She says find a seat, we sit down she gives us a menu, asks for drinks and immediately ask what we want. The drinks were super flat and did not taste right, but the pizza was very good. Our table was right by the door and we saw every interaction and every interaction was the same as ours but since they don't have the upstairs open they are very limited in seats so she turned many people away. She'd ask if they'd come in for takeout, they said no and again she said well we only have pizza they'd say that's fine and she was like well we have no seats and she'd turn around and walk away. She does not care about the customers or business. As we were leaving a couple came in and she did not acknowledge them whatsoever for at least five minutes. Really disappointing to see such a rude employee and we most likely will not be back again.

Its too bad that the customer service and wait staff are so unprofessional and just plain rude. I have had a bad expierence three times now. The pizza is good but unfortunately I will not be returning.

Pretty good bar pizzas. Def not a swag bag and would def cop these Za's again. They should have a buy 3 get the third free deal though, know what im sayinnn

It's a good place if you want to get a drink. Covid 19 literally killed the family atmosphere of this place. I waited for an hour and a half for my pizza which was literally the only option remaining on the menu. All the while being encouraged to buy alcoholic beverages from the bar unfortunately I do not drink. My friend and her four-year-old daughter were with me. We were told that they lost our order and it would be another 25 minutes at that point we just left. It's a real shame too. I was speaking with a patron sitting beside me and she said that they are making so much money doing the pizza and alcohol that they will not be going back to the old platform for which they were well-known . They had the best steak tips around.

We were exhausted and a bit cranky when we got to the Liberty Grille, but decided to there because it wasn't too busy and we were hungry. The minute we walked in, we were greeted by a friendly host (Will maybe)- a local who made us feel welcome and made suggestions. Go with the steak tips and fried clam bellies!

Great place in downtown Hingham for a pizza and a beer. I went with four friends on a Sunday afternoon and we each got our own custom pizza. The pizzas were each delicious we downed them in 5 minutes. Love this spot!!

This establishment seemed to have a quaint feel from the outside but inside it's small and a bit cramped. It's Wednesday evening and with few quests, the ordering of food was fast but very slow to serve. The menu is very limited with typically bar food with no surprises in taste or quality. I decided on the Reuben with French fries. The first thing I noticed was that the French fries were bland fair, barely warm and got cold quickly. The Reuben was the same. The sauerkraut was lifeless cabbage that lacked texture, taste, and quality; the rest of the ingredients looked liked leftovers. I won't be returning.

I had a very bad experience,the pizza sucked,it was burnt and tasted like shit also the kitchen worker had no mask on along with customers wearing no mask,so much for my birthday having a good bar pizza,I guess I'm on my way to lynnwood!!

Not to shabby. What I liked about it, locals were friendly and interacted with us, good service and decent prices. The food was OK, cod was done well but broccoli was undercooked. My husband is a fan of bar pizza and said it was good but not as good as Poopsies. Would go here again!

Let's start with I am from NY. So when it comes to pizza I know a few things. I literally have 9 pizzerias within a 2 mile radius of my home in Nassau county. So when my host stated we were having pizza from the very best Hingham has to offer I got excited. But that lasted as long as it took for her to unwrapped "the best pizza in Hingham". OMG I've literally have had frozen pizza that is far better than the garbage this place passes as pizza. Seriously try "Tree Tavern" frozen pizza - it's very good. This disgusting meal of what Hingham calls pizza is a down right insult to pizza. Avoid this place at all cost!

if I could give zero stars, I would. both times we tried this place, we both thought it was the worst "bar style" pizza we've ever had. it is close to worst pizza in general. so many better pizza choices around. crust tasted like it was days old. almost no sauce. we will certainly not be going back. how do you do such a bad job on the one thing you serve?

I really don't get what all of the bad reviews are for. I think it's worth keeping in mind that a lot of those reviews are current. I had a nice time. I had their special of Lobster Mac and cheese, it was great. It was cheesy and full of huge chunks of lobster that were perfectly cooked. It was then topped and baked with bread crumbs that added a nice crunch to the Mac. The two people I interacted with, whom I gather are the couple who runs/owns the joint, were friendly and served me well. A lot of their food choices are fried... which I found challenging. But they did have a variety of broiled and non-fried options and pizza. If I were going to be in the area again, I wouldn't hesitate to drop by.

Went there two week ago, our pizza was burned to a crisp. Previous trips there were OK, but this was bad. I can't believe she would bring that out to a table and serve it. Ewwwww. I won't be back. Perhaps the waitress and/or cook was new, this was a solitary experience. The bar is nice, cozy and friendly BTW. We were going to a movie nearby, no time to get anything else; and yes, they charged us full price. I didn't want 'to get worked up', it was a date night and I was out for some fun so I let it slide. We had popcorn at the Loring. UPDATE, June 21, 2017: When Liberty's manager read this review I received a phone call telling me I am banned from there for life. WTF, would not go back anyway.

This is an oddly shaped establishment with mixed reviews. We tried the place because Stars and the Tosca Cafe had 25 and 45 min waits, respectively. It was 7 and we had an 8 PM movie to catch at the Loring Theater. So we walked to the Liberty Grill. The food was OK. I got Baked Stuffed Sole on special, and my friend got Fish and Chips which I had a bite of. It took a while to come out. We missed the first minute of our movie. The staff was OK, but I'm not certain they wanted to be there. I think the menus need to be cleaned. I'd go back and try a pizza.

Have gone to the liberty grill many times but went there last night had the clam strips. I am paying for it now My husband and I ended up in bed with food poisoning. Sorry to say that will be my last time eating here.

This is a hidden gem for bar pizza lovers. A small, intimate, neighborhood tavern with great bar pizza and a nice selection of beer. The night we visited it was just pizza and beer being served but that was what we wanted and it was excellent. Prices better than reasonable. Service was excellent. Our bartender/server, Guy, was personable and attentive. For anyone looking for good bar pizza in the Hingham area this is a hidden gem!

Great pub pizza. Oldest continuously operating restaurant/pub in US. Go there for comfort food, great pizza but not so much for the service.

Great spot - house special is outstanding.

Best bar pizza around. Take out operation during Covid was spot on! Looking forward to sitting at the bar and enjoying a pie soon!

My boyfriend got mysteriously cut off tonight after 3 drinks, which I had a few sips of (beer off tap, and yes I'm over 21 and the bartender saw my ID). Bartender wouldn't say why. Turns out it's because he helped me up the stairs. Well, no one asked, but he helped me up the stairs because I have a chronic illness. My boyfriend eventually let the bartender know about my condition when we found out this was why (by the way, she told other people in our party this was why she cut him off, but she wouldn't tell HIM) but we were so pissed at how this was handled that he closed his tab and left. Like, I get she doesn't want to serve someone who may be so drunk they can't walk, but you could tell *ME* or my boyfriend that instead of gossiping to others in our party, and I would of understood your livelihood may be at stake and ordered a ginger ale instead of sipping off of his drinks. My legs have been in pain for the last week, this has been my first night out in about a month. I sat down in the shower today to shave my legs for this. I sat down in front of the mirror to do my make up for tonight. I'm embarrassed and upset due to this. If I was 60 no one would of thought twice about my difficulty walking, but due to my young age I was judged. I will never come here again next time I visit Hingham.

It pains me to write a bad review in my new town but it has to be done. This is an old place that would make a great pub, if they got the food right. I'm giving this 2 stars as my husband enjoyed the beer and my seak tips were OK. More on that below. I had the steak tip dinner with steak tips, a baked potato and a sad sad sad excuse for salad. (a piece of lettuce and 2 slices of tomato). My steak tips were SORELY undercooked when I asked for medium (I love medium rare and these were WAY too rare for even me) so I ate half of them. The potato was half cooked and very uninspiring. My husband had the fish and chips which looked like it had come out of the freezer. He said the best thing about all of it was the coleslaw, which is the same standard issue restaurant cole slaw that he could get anywhere. This place is in prime location across from Stars and Tosca and Tosca cafe. It needs to REALLY step up it's game to stick around as I even heard some locals commenting on it. It's got charm and if they really offered a decent menu i'm sure it would be better as it is reasonable. We were told to get the pizza, and to be fair they did look good, but i'm off dairy so that wasn't possible. I say go somewhere else.

Owners wife or waitress is insane.. seriously don't go to this place.. Bar staff, and pizza is great, but management needs to review other staffing.. just horrific

I guess we are in the minority...but we found the Liberty Grill to be horrible! First off, our waitress was the rudest I have ever encountered, bordering on downright nasty. Her whole demeanor was just very rude. The second we were seated she asked if we wanted drinks (no sort of beverage menu offered). When my husband asked what was available. She answered very snippy..."We've got lots"...um thanks. After we ordered, she practically dumped our food on the table. Very abrupt, acted like we were an annoyance to her. And the food...yuck. The pizza, I can't understand the raves! It tasted like cardboard with oversalted sauce and greasy toppings. I have nothing against thin crust "bar" style pizza. But this was just horrible tasting. My husband ordered a burger and she did ask him how he wanted it prepared (rare). It arrived literally burnt and beyond "well-done". Why ask a patron how they would like something and then bring something entirely opposite? Even aside from that, he said it was the worst tasting burger...ever. Making Mcdonalds look good! I will say the special I got, the lobster roll, was well prepared. but I was expecting a bit more than a tiny little grilled hot-dog roll size for 19 dollars...are you kidding me??? Never ever ever again. So disappointing.

My husband and I happened upon this place last weekend, after walking away from a 20 minute wait at The Snug and a overwhelming crowd at trendy, Stars. I wanted to try and boost the unfair reviews of this place. Yes, the decor is tired and there are a lot of local's at the tiny bar, what's wrong with that? The food was delicious and I had the best Bloody Mary I've ever tasted! The bar tender came out from behind his post to greet us and was a really upbeat, happy guy. The mussels were perfectly cooked, the garlic bun was reminiscent of Fontaine's( those of you from old Boston would relish). Sometimes "old school"is better and trendy- is just that. I'll be back to the Liberty Grill next time I'm in Hingham

Brought my older parents there today. They like it because it is quiet. The food was mediocre. I've been going to that restaurant since I was a kid back when it was Ye Olde Mill Grille. My dad and I got baked scallops they were slightly over cooked but fine. My mother got shrimp scampi it was dry and tasteless. The service was pretty bad. Our waitress was in her phone a lot of the time. And an older couple waited so long for their check (maybe 15-20 minutes) they made up the amount and left. So cute restaurant, mediocre but fine food, and not great service.