Little Vincent's Pizza

** CASH ONLY ** After Tino’s in Oneonta, this place is marginally better. It’s the thin and crispy crust in my opinion that sets it apart from upstate. Would I come here again for the cold cheese slice? Yup.

My favorite pizza place on long Island. A slice with cold chesse on top is wonderful

Going to Vincent’s with my grandparents when I was younger is still one of my favorite memories. Throughout the years, Pedro has always treated my family with such kindness. He is truly what makes Vincent’s the pinnacle it is. Their memorably thin slices deserve a category all on their own. Their sauce is the perfect balance of sweet and savory! Love it here so much.

My daughter says this is the best pizza on long Island. I don't know, I haven't tried every pizza place on long Island. It is very good. A little oily but the sauce is good, they have been in the same location for over 40 years. It's worth stopping in for lunch if your shopping in Huntington.

Little Vincent’s is the best late night pizza in the area. There are limited pizza spots open past 10pm. Even on weekends. We would travel from massapequa for a slice of cold cheese. Variety of pizza by the slice is limited to cold cheese or no cold cheese late night. Also CASH ONLY. The pizza is good but not my favorite. For after hours it’s the best I’ve found.

Pretty mid. Slices should be bigger at $5 a slice. They give a lot of cold cheese but Town Pizza, Fire Island does $4.75 a cold cheese slice with boom sauce and them slices are phat

It's a little cramped inside and very outdated. Be aware; It's Cash only. They don't serve anything but pizza (and drinks). Which was fine with me! The best crust, but I think the sauce was a little sweet. Certainly not inedible!

Great pizza. Good service. Enjoy the cold pizza slice only if you like that stuff cause the cheese isn’t extra flavorful. The place can seat small parties. ONLY ACCEPTS CASH but if that’s not an issue you Don’t have one.

Local pizza place longstanding for many years. Crisp thin crust with a cracker texture I had pepperoni well done it was super hot in temp which was nice for a quick off street bite to eat during holiday shopping in downtown Huntington

Best pizza on Long Island. Never could go wrong with this place. Ask for the pizza well done makes it 10x better

Going to Vincent's with my grandparents when I was younger is still one of my favorite memories. Throughout the years, Pedro has always treated my family with such kindness. He is truly what makes Vincent's the pinnacle it is. Their memorably thin slices deserve a category all on their own. Their sauce is the perfect balance of sweet and savory! Love it here so much.

My friend and I came here after a late night show at the Paramount and it was quite busy (always a good sign)! We got two regular slices and two slices with the cold mozz on top. The regular slices were good, but the cold mozz was great. I mean it's cheese on top of cheese with different consistencies- what's not to love? All in all, if I ever venture out to Suffolk again (which I highly doubt), I would go back.

Haven't been here in years! We used to come here right after clubbing and order a cheese pie. The cheese slices are always cut in small triangular slices so eating a few doesn't feel too bad. What do they put in the sauce? And the dough is perfection! The service is always pleasant. There's enough benches and tables to accommodate guests. Thank you!

It's the best pizza on Long Island, but make sure you bring cash! They do not accept cards or tap payments. The cheese pie averages around $20.50.

This place is all about the nostalgia of Little Vincent been open since 1972, I've been trying their pizza since 1988 yesterday I visited this famous pizzeria, the inside looks exactly the same. It did 35 years ago the pizza slices have gone smaller and the price is almost 4 dollars a slice. I'm not even sure if they carry anything else but Pizza it is cash only so Buyer beware, the pizza tasted good but the nostalgia taste better

Amazing pizza that's worth the trip to a nice town. Food is great and Prices are reasonable!

Little Vincent's is legendary. They have been around forever for a reason. They make the best plain cheese pizza in Long Island. Not only that, they are open until 3am on Fridays and Saturdays for late night pizza which is rare to find. Highly recommend Little Vincent's if you haven't tried it, I guarantee you won't be disappointed. Also, Little Vs is CASH ONLY.

Quite possibly the best pizza on Long Island. The perfect, but you need to ask for it slightly well done so it's a little crispy. My personal preference of course. One of the few pizzerias that still use semolina on the bottom of the crust for great texture and taste. Service is great, they are a busy establishment and still keep knocking those pies right out. It's a typical NY pizzeria with some tables and bar stool steering. Also open late when you need that slice after you leave the local bars.

This was the NY pizza I was looking for. I haven't been to NY in good while and wanted to get a taste of some really good authentic NY pizza. This is the place. It is not in downtown NYC but on Long Island. The place was small but located in a very eclectic area with lots of shops and eateries. Very small restaurant but have amazing pizza. I had to slices of pepperoni and while it was piping hot, I could not put it down. I can see them preparing the pies and cooking them in the pizza ovens from the counter and seating area. Very clean and the folks working there were very friendly. My group of friends were very pleased. Most highly recommended!!!

Good for late night pizza. Can get very crowded with limited seating. Pizza is ok. Crowd was very noisy.

First time there I had a regular slice and omg what have I been missing in my life! I went back to get a pie half pepperoni quarter sausage and quarter meatball. Amazing!! Crust was thin and crispy holds up nice even with topping! My new favorite pizzeria. Actually I think this will be the only place I order pizza from now on when I'm in LI.

I first heard of cold cheese pizza a few years ago watching the food channel and didn't quite understand the appeal, I heard Little Vincent's serves their own version of it so I had to try it out. Honestly, I still don't understand the appeal of the cold cheese on the pizza, you either get cold pieces of cheese or half melted cheese that tastes like cheese left out at room temp for a while, needless to say I removed the cheese shortly after the first few bites. The real star of the show is the pizza itself, it's noticeably more seasoned as the oregano really comes through and you see it all over the cheese, the crust was also good and crisp. This is a solid slice minus the cold cheese, try it for the novelty though if you insist.

Delicious and cheap meals, great little place to snag a nice lunch for cheaper than any other place in town! I hadn't gone for a while since this past summer, I forgot how delicious their pizza was, The place hasn't changed a bit for years, and that's my favorite part! Would recommend!

We're visiting from Maryland and passed by Little Vincent's and stopped in for lunch. The BEST pizza we've had since the last time we were on the Island. The pizza was delicious, the service was friendly and just a very nice pizza place. Pizza in MD is the worst! So lucky to have found fantastic pizza here!

I've been here before and they've never let me down. Honestly, it would be a problem if they accepted credit card because I'd eat there a lot more often. The pizza is always on point. The sauce has a sweetness but it's not too sweet. The crust is thin and has crispiness. The cheese is amazing. The inside of the restaurant isn't fancy but we're not here for that. We're here for great pizza!

Little Vincent's is always yummy . Get the cold mozzarella on a hot slice you'll love it

Amazing local traditional NY pizza. Sauce, crust, cheese, all completely on point! They only make one kind of pizza to perfection so don't expect pastas or anything fancy

What can I say about this pizza that has not already been said. Huntington staple for over 50 years. Nothing beats a cold cheese slice at 12:30 am. They are opened till 4Am Sat and Sunday. Introduced my son to a cold cheese slice mind blowing he said. Lol. Yeah it's that good . After a show at the paramount it's the first stop I make. Order a few cold cheese slices , you can thank me now.

Pizza- mid. Not a lot of flavor. Skimpy on the sauce & cheese. Our slices were 25% bare crust. Horrible atmosphere, filthy, zero customer service. Oh and cash only!

I went to Vincent's yesterday and I have to honestly say I'm not impressed. I ordered 2 slices of cheese pizza and I ate at the restaurant. It had zero flavor and I had a regular slice which should be on point. Sauce was blah, mozzarella was blah, dough was blah. I really wanted to like it because it looked delicious but it was not delicious. I make pizza at home all the time using fresh simple ingredients and a pizzeria who specializes in pizza should be able to do better than me so I'm not sure how it gets raving reviews with its mediocre at best taste.

Do one thing and do it right they perfect that moto good regular slice is all anyone needs God bless

This is a above average slice good cheese, good crust you can add cold cheese for a treat service a plus parking is a little difficult but worth it

Sorely disappointing, overrated pizza. I ordered a regular pie. Just completely mediocre... Like one level up from Dominos. No zesty sauce, light on cheese, dry, unremarkable crust. Go to Umbertos. Cash only (eyeroll)

Consistently good pizza, and with their BOGO coupons, it's a great deal. Thin crust plenty of cheese and a corn meal touch added underside.

Shockingly good. Fortunately I had cash in my pocket which I rarely do as they don't take cards. Really great thin crunchy crust. Sauce was sweet. May grab another slice tonight after my show at the paramount.

Excellent pizza! Sauce is savory, crust was crispy. It's the quintessential NY slice outside of Brooklyn! They're known for their "cold cheese pizza;" the perfect slice for cheese lovers. They are cash-only, so hit an ATM prior to visiting. However, its perfectly placed in the middle of Huntington Village, and a great place to end the night.

I'm way more naughty than you are INNOCENT And I'm not just talking about that notorious INCIDENT So if you have some meat, then I'll be the one to MINCE IT And if you want Pizza, then come to LITTLE VINCENT I have to settle down before this rap gets too EXPLICIT And I might just date that one Yelp girl cause she is so PERSISTENT I might take her for pizza, but that might just be CONTINGENT On whether she knows great pizza, if so, it's LITTLE VINCENT So if you have some store-bought Kale, I recommend you RINSE IT And if Sam Smith does not like pizza, then you must CONVINCE IT And if you want some pizza whose value is quite INTRINSIC Then there is only one option, it's here from LITTLE VINCENT I've been into girls (a lot) since I was just an INFANT I don't care where they're from, or the religion, or skin PIGMENT I don't mind if they're twins, even better with a TRIPLET And if they all want pizza then we go to LITTLE VINCENT WHAT Do: A cold cheese slice, which is what everyone else gets, so do it. Don't: Let your cold cheese slice go cold. The best pizza on Long Island. One of the top 5 pizzas in the entire NYC metro area. Which means one of the top 5 pizzas in the country, basically, since the best are all in this area. What are you logistically, literally, logically waiting for? Get here. Eat it. Thank me. Repeat. Limerick time: Barbie wows everyone that meets her And a world class New York slice completes her But to get Barbie smiling I bring her to Long Island For the best: Little Vincent's Pizza! This is easily one of the best pizza places in the whole state, the whole country, nay, the world! Little Vincent's is actually some of the best pizza I've ever had in my life. Fresh, cold mozzarella shredded on top of the pizza just to make it extra good, and how it does. With or without the cold cheese though, it's Sublime and divine and very very special. Their alternative slices are all just as stellar. It's easily the best food I've ever had on Long Island, and especially now that Hummus World has closed down, there's no competition. Nothing on the Lwannng Oiland tastes even close to this. And that's a huge compliment (huger than my... oh nm) since Long Island itself would be one of the biggest and most popular populous states if it were a state unto itself. I just used the word unto. Don't hate me. So while in NYC I put Sunnyside Pizza (especially Sicilian or Garlic Bread Slice) and several others at the top of the pile, if I was to include Greater NY Metro, Little Vincent's would *easily* be top five, and very possibly top 3. There's a few hundred world class slices in NYC that I'm positioning it above. So that's the highest praise imaginable. That calls for another limerick. If the best thing you ate is a Skittle And your local pizza crust is brittle Grab your heels and your thong Hit the Island of Long As the taste of Vincent's is not Little. In conclusion then... you simply must come here, and you simply must try Little Vincent's. Let's finish with a little more rap: The first time that I tasted this, I found it REMINISCENT Of all the best pizzas in NYC, whose rules are STRINGENT About the dough and sauce and cheese, to change they are RESISTENT No wonder that the taste is so damn good from LITTLE VINCENT So every competition Vinny enters now, he WINS IT And I heard Tom Hanks loves this pizza more than he loved WILSON And as for Tom Cruise and the couch, my god, what was he THINKING But if the Toms want Pizza they must go to LITTLE VINCENT And I might bring my Ivy League Porn Star, who went to PRINCETON Oh wait, it's Dartmouth, either way though, she's the perfect VIXEN And when she comes, she'll be in heels, as her tanned skin GLISTENS So when she wants some perfect pizza, it's from LITTLE VINCENT WHAT!

Hmm, first of all, CASH ONLY. I heard many great things about this pizza place and having lived on Long Island for more than a decade without trying this place, I felt like I had to redeem myself. I ordered a pie of the regular cheese pizza. Order was $17.50 if I remember correctly. I ended up adding the cold cheese on the side, which they give you in a plastic cup for a total of $21. The real question - is it worth it? Each slice was quite tasty. Slices were thing and had just the right amount of cheese and sauce. The cold cheese, in my honest opinion, is a bit overhyped. However, I'd say it is worth the first experience, but probably not afterwards. I'd love to come here again and hopefully, they can accept more than just cash next time! Am I a true Long Islander now?

Whenever I pass Huntington, I always go in here for a slice. Crisp and deliciously seasoned, it is a work of art.

The best crust Cheese on the pizza is the Bomb diggity An institution Bring casheesh no CCs accepted

God bless Little Vincent's. One of the last original LI NY pizza guys. Love the original decor in that place. Cold cheese slice isn't my thing but I'm glad they offer it. If you need a quick hot slice and a cold sofa, there's no better place. Amen

Little Vincent's is known by every local around. They are taking precautions during covid but even so they are fast with takeout and your orders. They have a perfect crust that isn't floppy but isnt burnt. Not too much grease and just amount of cheese that does not fall off. A bonus is that they give you extra cheese in a large soda cup. Pepperoni and cheese are staple choices. Classic solid NY pizza.

TLDR: Local pizzeria in Huntington Village. No frills, just slices, pies and fountain soda. A plain slice will do you good, one topped with cold cheese will do you even better. This place has been around for a long time, I've been coming here since I was in grade school. I stopped by tonight and the same guy is still here baking pies and serving slices. It's not the cheapest pizza, a regular slice will run you $2.75 and the cold cheese slice is $4.25. For the uninitiated, it's literally a slice with a handful of cold shredded mozzarella cheese on top. As unconventional as it sounds, the contrast between the chilled topping and the hot crust - it's pretty great. That first bite brought back to childhood, the second just made me smile. I don't think it's the greatest pizza in the world but I like it here. The slices could be larger but the crust is done right, crispy and paper thin. If you find yourself in the area, try it out. Just know that it'll get crowded in the later hours.

Stopped in for a quick bite after The Paramount since it's open until 3am. It was my first time & it was packed with friendly chatty customers which was fun. Long line but the guys behind the counter were all on a mission & focused on getting the ppl on line in & out since there's not a lot of room for a line and very few tables. Overall, the pizza was good, not the best or worst I've had but good for 11:30pm. What made it for me was the semolina crust absolutely delicious. Wish more pizzerias would use semolina crust. It just hits differently. I was really surprised of how small the slice was. Never seen a slice that small especially for $3.50 a slice but again it was 11:30pm & didn't care. To be honest, it was just enough to hit the spot for me. Would I go on an ordinary day for lunch, probably not but after The Paramount it's good enough.

Came in last night and had a meatball slice and a pepperoni with onion slice. I now have FOOD POISONING. Not sure if anyone else got sick but please be more careful with your procedures for food safety.

Pizza only, small slices and hardly fresh. I know people rave about it but its marginal at best. While i agree that most pizza tastes better right out of the oven or close to it, when reheated this is not so good... Sorry folks....and dont shoot the messenger...

Not bad for a quick slice, but have had better in Suffolk county and way better as you go into Nassau county. Pluses = 1. Convenient location (near Paramount theater) 2. Not too much red sauce 3. Nice thin crust 4. Offer cold cheese slices (let's just say reminds me of college days) Minuses = 1. Price for a simple plain slice $2.75 :( 2. I get bigger slices with topping for that cost. 3. Not enough cheese on the slice. 4. To get cold cheese slice cost $4+...ridiculous, I'm older but not that much older. I know cost of cheese has risen but, really :/ Cost for a full regular cheese pie $16.50...so totally a bit moderately priced for plain pizza at $2 a slice, not too much of a savings. All in all not bad, but not great. Should have read my fellow #LIYELPers reviews prior. :/

I come through this town a lot whether driving or riding my HD. My g/f and I came to this area to see the tree and take photos. We were in the mood for pizza and didn't realize how pathetic of a slice they serve here. I'm from NYC and this is not a standard-size slice. I was so disappointed, two slices equal a NY pizza. I guess the locals are used to being ripped off by this tiny pizza but this town are well-off people so I'm sure they don't care. The sauce I found had a little more Oregano than I'd like. I thought I was getting school lunch portion. $20 for four tiny slices and a med drink. I'll try the next pizza shop up the street next time.

You might be looking at this a little confused - a hot slice with a mountain of cold cheese on top - but you'll understand it once you try it. My baseball teammates put me onto this slice a few years back and I too was confused at first but simply put, it's delicious. Little Vincent's "Cold Cheese Slice" offers up 3 textures of cheese: hot and melted, warm and beginning to melt and cold unmelted refreshing mozzarella heaven. One bite and it'll become your go to at this Huntington pizzeria.

I have made reviewing pizza a bucket list type thing, so in that I saw Dave Portnoys barstool review of Little Vincent's a couple of years ago. His review rating was low. I disagree with his theory that you don't ask for it well done, if I order a steak I just don't say cook it. I saw the pie he got and it looked very NY Style. What I got was the opposite, thin, light, crispy and a hint of maybe pepper. This has tied my highest ranked slice at 8.6. It's a small pizzeria with very limited seating but it's old school. Cash only. I love the vibe, love the Neon sign in a busy Huntington street. Staff was very aware of customer needs. While I was there I witnessed a mistake on an order whereby these young women ordered 8 pies but the worker thought they only ordered 1. He was like, no worries, we can get this done in 15 minutes and did. If your going to spend a day in Huntington, make sure to make this your lunch or dinner. Awesome pizza.

They should rename Little V's to Drunk Pizza LOLOL JKJK I've been a huge fan of Little V's since I first step foot in at 3am one night some 20 years ago! It's as a part of Huntington Village as town hall. I usually always buy the pie because why not?? Chances are it's 2am...you're drunk and hungry...and this won't be the worst decision you've made tonight LOL The cold cheese is really awesome to toss on the slice...it's pretty good without it but even better with that cold cheese on top! Long live Little V's!!

Good friendly service, this is a pizza restaurant that only accepts cash and is located among all the bars in downtown Huntington, NY!

Great solid slice. The cold cheese slice is unique and different. Very good! Can't go wrong. Worth the drive.

Cash only! $12.75 for the three slices. Haven't been here in over a year and the pizza is still good Coming from someone who actually doesn't like pizza, this is the only spot that I will ALWAYS get a slice from.

Finally got to try this pizza and I was super content. The pizza itself is average, but that cheese on top is life changing. Makes it softer and saltier and SO delicious.

I tried the cold Pizza. It was good. A regular slice of pizza but when it comes out of the oven they dump a pile of cold mozz on it. I liked it and would have it again.

This is your basic no frills pizza slice that hits the spot, its not artisanal. If you want elevated pizza, this is not the spot. If you're looking for Nostalgia, and grew up on this style. It's the best. Above average and easy to eat