Jessi C.
Yelp
Longfellow is the anti-hipster OTR bar and I'm HERE FOR IT. This neighborhood spot is the every man's (and woman's) watering hole...You can expect to find local OTR natives, UC students, and your 65 year old aunt Shelly here. Longfellow is unpretentious and bare bones, and that's what I love about it.
First off, the bartenders here are really nice and know what they're doing behind the bar. The cocktail list here is very inventive...I went with the Spruce Goose ($11; gin, honey, lime, angostura, tonic) and my friend got the Slim Pickens ($10; bourbon, thai basil, coffee bitters). Both cocktails were DELICIOUS, but I really really loved the Spruce Goose. It was vaguely grapefruit-tasting...Citrus-y and sour, a little sweet, with bubbles. It was fun to drink, and frankly I wish we were staying longer so that I could have ordered another one. Slim Pickens was also perfect, the coffee bitters were a great pairing with the bourbon. All of our cocktails were well-balanced and well-made.
Another bonus is that this place has a yummy looking food menu. We didn't get to try anything because we had just eaten, but I'll be coming back for those pierogies.
The final thing I really love about Longfellow is the "pay it forward" list. Basically, you can pay for your buddy's drink ahead of time, put it on the board, and then when they come in to redeem it, they cross your name off. On the board as of last Friday, someone named "drunk a**hole Steve" had purchased 2 OG Painkiller cocktails for "hungover Steve", and I like that this bar is the kind of place where that can happen.
Longfellow is definitely one of my top favorite OTR bars, and I can't wait to come back!