Mabella's | Italian Steakhouse

This is definitely a high end dining experience in Columbus. Expect to spend around $50 at least per person for a meal, drink and app or dessert. The fresh bread is delicious and they will bring you oil and vinegar upon request. I had the mushroom ravioli with 4oz filet that was cooked to perfection and was very tender. The cream sauce was incredible and the portion size is filling. It also comes with a salad as a starter. My husband got the chicken Parmesan and it has a spicy kick to it which was a good surprise. We ordered the cheesecake to go and it was 10/10. We also each got a cocktail which we enjoyed. Our waitress Raquel (apologize if spelled incorrectly) was amazing.

We celebrated my birthday here and had a great time. The food and wine were delicious and we had the best cheesecake ever. My husband had the land chops and they were very tender. The Mabella filet was cooked perfectly and the Chef’s board was a nice starter.

Really enjoyed the ambiance, service, and food. The steak was cooked to perfection! We enjoyed the espresso martini style cocktail as well. Recommend the calamari as an appetizer. It tasted very fresh and crispy. I also enjoyed the wedge salad and broccolini. We shared a delicious tiramisu for dessert. Would come here again!

I had an excellent experience at Ma Bella’s and it easily ranks as one of the best meals I’ve had in the area. From the moment we walked in, the service was attentive, friendly, and genuinely welcoming without feeling overbearing. Our server checked on us at just the right times, made great menu recommendations, and kept drinks filled without us having to ask. We started with the calamari, and it was outstanding. Lightly breaded, perfectly fried, and not greasy at all. The texture was spot on—tender inside with a crisp coating—and the marinara served with it had great flavor and balance. It set the tone for the rest of the meal. For the entrée, I ordered the chicken parmigiana, and it did not disappoint. The portion size was generous, the chicken was cooked perfectly, and the breading held up well under the sauce and melted cheese. The pasta was cooked al dente and the sauce tasted fresh and house-made, not something poured out of a jar. You can tell they take pride in their food. The atmosphere was comfortable and clean, making it a great place for either a casual dinner or a special night out. Combined with the attentive service and high-quality food, it made for a really enjoyable dining experience. I’ll definitely be coming back and would highly recommend Ma Bella’s to anyone looking for great Italian food and top-notch service in Columbus.

Okay, the ambiance is beautiful and the food is good... Except my only issue was the bread. I've been here in the past and I know my food could've been better. Our bread was SUPER BURNT! I gave them a 3 because of the service we received from the waiter. He was very unwelcoming and I honestly think he prejudged us, like maybe we don't tip. It was a guy who used to serve us and we always tipped between 20-40 dollars because he'd go above and beyond. This guy last night had to be reminded to bring drinks/refills ( they were not packed after 10) He made it obvious he didn't want to serve us with his body language. Outside of the bread and the service we received the food is excellent and I highly recommend giving them a try

The food, service, and atmosphere were all phenomenal! Every steak was cooked to order and our server was very informative. We came to celebrate a birthday and a graduation! We couldn't ask for a better experience. When we come back to Columbus, it will definitely be a place we revisit!

Our son treated us to dinner while we were visiting him and celebrating his birthday. He made reservations as suggested and we were seated right away. The atmosphere was classy rustic, and the restaurant was much larger than it appears from outside. The menu is quite varied so there is definitely something for everyone, and our server was very helpful answering our questions. My husband and son chose steak and I the salmon. We haven’t stopped talking about how much we enjoyed them yet. Unlike many upscale restaurants the portions were perfect. We opted to not get dessert because our dinners were filling without making us feel stuffed. Marbella’s is definitely worth the visit if you are in Columbus.

Well, I used to love this place. Ordered a to go meal. Ordered the mushroom ravioli with the 4 oz filet (had this meal sooo many times)…. Clearly since it was a to go order they thought I wouldn’t care. 2.8 ounces of a steak (if that’s what you can call it) for $38. What a bummer and rip off.