Mabella's | Italian Steakhouse

Really enjoyed the ambiance, service, and food. The steak was cooked to perfection! We enjoyed the espresso martini style cocktail as well. Recommend the calamari as an appetizer. It tasted very fresh and crispy. I also enjoyed the wedge salad and broccolini. We shared a delicious tiramisu for dessert. Would come here again!

We celebrated my birthday here and had a great time. The food and wine were delicious and we had the best cheesecake ever. My husband had the land chops and they were very tender. The Mabella filet was cooked perfectly and the Chef’s board was a nice starter.

The food, service, and atmosphere were all phenomenal! Every steak was cooked to order and our server was very informative. We came to celebrate a birthday and a graduation! We couldn't ask for a better experience. When we come back to Columbus, it will definitely be a place we revisit!

Okay, the ambiance is beautiful and the food is good... Except my only issue was the bread. I've been here in the past and I know my food could've been better. Our bread was SUPER BURNT! I gave them a 3 because of the service we received from the waiter. He was very unwelcoming and I honestly think he prejudged us, like maybe we don't tip. It was a guy who used to serve us and we always tipped between 20-40 dollars because he'd go above and beyond. This guy last night had to be reminded to bring drinks/refills ( they were not packed after 10) He made it obvious he didn't want to serve us with his body language. Outside of the bread and the service we received the food is excellent and I highly recommend giving them a try

Very good service. We have been here many times before but this time we walked in without a reservation. We ended up sitting at the bar and the experience was one of the best we have had so far. The staff were attentive and the food was delicious. We had the NY Strip and Spaghetti and giant meatballs. Recommend Frito Misto for app and lots of cocktails to choose from. Spicy vodka Chicken Parmesan is a beast of a meal and very delicious. Also finished dinner with Mama Kay’s Cheesecake with caramel and strawberries.

My first time going to Mabella's with my partner, and here's my first time review. Mabella's is a cute, quaint place with lots of atmosphere and servers that are dressed in that typical all black attire that really give you that "fancy" restaurant sort of vibe. The menu was simplistic and yet it felt like there were plenty of options to chose from. Our waiter, Walker, was a delightful and helpful server. He filled our drinks and brought out garlic bread for an appetizer. The garlic bread was okay, it was a bit hard and tough, but it served it's purpose. The waiter helped me decide on a main meal of lasagna with a side of cesar salad. The lasagna was alright- the presentation could have been better, and it was a little bland for my tastes. However, the lasagna was still good, just not my favorite part. I loved the salad, it was well presented, full of flavor, and the croutons had a nice smokey flavor with a lot of crunch. Finally I had the dessert and I went with the server's recommendation of cherries as a topping. The cheesecake was off the chain! Full of flavor, delightfully sweet and airy, and I ate every last bite even though I was full from the main course. All in all, I would definitely recommend!

We went here last year and I said I would do a review but forgot, so here we are. We were in town visiting our kiddo graduating from a school at Benning. We got the mussels (excellent), the New York Strip was exceptional, perfectly cooked and the toppings were like something I had not experienced. It was one of the best steaks I’ve eaten and I’ve eaten way too many steaks around the world. The fries/frites were top notch and as good as any I’ve had. My wife got the mushroom ravioli and a filet and it too was perfect. Lastly the ambience out back on the deck was beautiful and the staff were all outstanding. From the hostesses to our server. They were all professionals, polite and made great recommendations. I don’t know when I’ll be back in Columbus but I guarantee you I’ll be making a reservation Mabella’s. 5/5 and I am super petty 😂 so if I say 5/5 I mean it. Keep setting the standard guys. Thanks for the great dinner.

We really enjoyed our dinner here! We felt welcomed with our 4 year old, while still enjoying what felt like a super fancy date night dinner. And their kids menu is top tier, one of the best we've seen! It has fantastic prices, selections, and adult menu quality. The French fries are so good. Chicken marsala was great! We prefer to try new places versus going back, but we will definitely be back here. The entrance is also photo worthy! We were able to walk in and be seated almost immediately, but it sounded like reservations were greatly encouraged! They were busy and full! Their affogato with biscotti was shockingly good!