Sara N.
Yelp
Simply not impressed. My mistake was thinking that I should get a lobster roll here. It was a last-minute decision to eat here because everywhere else was booked solid, and you think if a place is on the water, it should have some decent seafood, right? Boy was I wrong. If I could rewind time and not spend money at this place, I would.
Let's start with the good, the tofu bowl was large and flavorful. That is about it.
Now for the bad, the shrimp tacos had two pieces of shrimp in them, they were mainly lettuce and were not seasoned. 1/5 stars.
The lobster roll. When my New Englander friends saw this roll, they laughed, apologized, and insisted that I go somewhere else to try a real lobster roll. I was between the lobster roll and a burrito, but since this place was on the water, I wanted to go with the seafood option that wasn't fried. I have now learned from this mistake. The lobster was rubbery, as mentioned in a different review. Lackluster in presentation, and the bun was soggy by the time I got it.
Total wait time: 25 mins for the lobster roll, closer to 45 mins for the fish taco and tofu bowl. Mind you, this was on a Saturday night, so I understand that they were probably busy. But their pick up station is so disorganized and hectic, they are shouting numbers from the window, and you have to fight to the front of other guest waiting in order to pick up your food.
Long story short, if you are in Wellfleet, save your time and money and do not visit this place. There is hardly anywhere to sit, and the service and food were very subpar. I would mention the ambience, but there was none. We were there at Sunset so that was a plus. But even after my $32 lobster roll, I was still hungry.