Joe L.
Yelp
My partner and I came to Mac's Tavern as part of our anniversary trip to Philly. We are big fans of Always Sunny however we didn't have any expectations about it being themed like the show. There are some photos of some of the cast which was nice, but don't expect anything to be Paddy's themed. It doesn't take away from the bar itself though - the decor is pretty nice!
On a Saturday night it was mostly empty and we had come for food and some drinks. The bartenders were very nice and welcoming, however the service was slow considering how many people were there. They had a good selection of beers however when I ordered a drink from the show (Caribbean Paradise) the bartender told me they do not have coconut rum or blue caracao. I'm not sure if that's a normal thing or they had just run out - but it was disappointing and surprising considering how many cocktails use those ingredients.
We ordered a handful of food items:
Mediterranean salad - we could barely eat this because it was totally drenched in oil. We ate the cucumbers out of it and left the rest.
Cheesesteak pierogis - this was an interesting idea but did not seem like any pierogi we'd had ever eaten. They were so overcooked that they were dark brown and crunchy, more like a fried ravioli. The filling was soft steak and it wasn't anything special.
Fried mozzarella triangles - these were OK. They were not fried to be crispy and gooey. Breading was not fully on and tasted like they were fried in old oil that needed to be changed (they had that aftertaste). I didn't know fried cheese could be done wrong.
Mac's Mac n Cheese - probably the best dish we had here, although it wasn't that impressive. It looked nice and had crunchy breadcrumbs on top, but barely any cheese. And the cheese it did have - had no flavor. It probably could have used some sharp cheddar, because it was basically wet noodles in a flavorless cream sauce.
Roasted Pork Sandwich - this was too salty and soggy. It wasn't bad, however the broccoli rabe was so overpowering that the pork itself had no flavor. I've heard this criticism of roasted pork sandwiches from Philly before, but this was our first time trying the famous classic. My partner liked the sandwich but I didn't.
The menu is limited but that is honestly ok with me - I just think the execution was below average. The food would be better if the recipes were revamped. I could see this being a nice place to get a drink and hang out but I don't think the food is worth it.
We had queued some songs up in the digital jukebox, however our songs never played. Another review said the jukebox isn't connected to their speakers - I don't know if this is true but we didn't hear our songs after 1hr+ stay. The TouchTunes app said our songs were playing but they didn't actually play.
This was pretty disappointing since we had our Philly trip planned for a couple months, I'm a big fan of Rob McElhenney and Kaitlin Olson's work, and they put a lot of expertise and attention into their other projects. I am open to visiting again to give them another chance since I am a huge fan of Rob and Kaitlin, however I wouldn't come back here if it weren't for that fact. The experience gave a lackluster feel to our last night in Philly.