Macy’s Place Pizzeria

Two years ago we stumbled across Macy’s on our trip to see family in Buffalo. I had heard about it on Twitter and convinced my wife to give it a try. What we experienced was some of our favorite pizza we’ve ever had. Fast forward to present day and another trip to Buffalo. We knew Macy’s would be a spot but hoped we hadn’t romanticized it too much over the last two years. Nope, we hadn’t. It was just as good as the first time. Excellent pizza. We also went with a cookies and cream dessert pizza. It was pure sugar bliss. I can’t recommend this place enough. Side note: they forgot to cut the dessert pizza which initially was a problem but allowed me to cut a piece as big as I wanted which had positives… and negatives. 🤣

Some people call me Maurice.... Just kidding this pizza is called the space cowboy. It came down from heaven itself and was the most delicious. I want to make a point also that the staff are amazing. They understand they have a huge menu and will seriously talk through your order if you are new. I always stop when I am in town.

Second or third time ordering from this location. I love their sauce. Not super sweet but just sweet enough. Love the sauce. The great amount of cheese. The pepperoni were great. Not cup char but it worked well. Soft bite no tear which is how I prefer my pizza. Ordered 20 wings med. also loved the sauce/flavor. Cooked crispy. Very good. Large cheese pepperoni 20 wings on a Monday cost $44 thank you

1st time ever getting a pizza from them. Went to williamsville location. Had the steak and ring pizza. Was not disappointed! Great pie perfectly cooked and delicious. Highly recommend.

I have always loved the innovation on the menu but thought they were going quantity over quality. However I just had some of the best made pizza and wings ever. The Macy’s Day Parade pizza is a must if it’s the season. The idea of it is genius but the fact that they make it crispy (not soggy at all), with an amazing crust is nothing short of a miracle. Also, I highly recommend the Wu Tang wings. Spot on

Macy’s place came highly recommended as a place to check out when touring around Buffalo for the best pizza. The shop itself is very cool looking, it’s got retro 1980’s esque vibes about it with the sign and paint job of the place. The pizza itself was fantastic. We ordered a large pepperoni pizza with basil, shredded parmesan and hot honey drizzled over it and it was absolutely delicious. The crust was the right amount of crispy, the sauce and cheese were great and the addition of the hot honey, the basil and the shredded parm were a great addition. Definitely a 10/10- check this place out.

Ordered pizza and wings, pizza was burnt underneath. Called to let them know, the person on the phone was very understanding and said to bring back for a new pizza. 2nd was burnt as well. Not coming back for burnt pizza at their high prices. Too many other choices in our area.

Wow! Really good pizza. Crust was superb! Nice thickness and texture. Sauce is slightly sweet and there are a few pepper flakes to give it a touch of warmth. Loaded with pepperoni and golden brown. I will absolutely come back to Buffalo just to have this pizza again. Seriously, some of the best that I've had.