Lydia C.
Yelp
Disappointingly not worth the price tag - or even the trek to Seaport.
I've been to the sister location, Matsunori, which is in Fenway. That's a slightly less expensive and higher quality meal with improved service over the new location.
Though Mai is small, the setting was the highlight of our visit. It definitely feels like a pricey cocktail bar, with dim lighting casting a glowing blue, romantic ambiance over the handful of tables. However, we noticed a string of labubus hung up around the store, which were... odd.
We eschewed the apps and each ordered 3 or 4 handrolls, which are the specialty. I was intrigued by the toro tea cups, but was turned off by the $19 price tag for, you guessed it, a single bite.
Unlike Matsunori, table service at Mai was lacking, as all the handrolls came out together. That meant that even the second handroll I ate was soggy.
I first tried the salmon gravalax, which the server lauded as a highlight and an incredibly unique dish with bold, innovative flavors paired together in a new way. In fact, it felt like a plain, albeit satisfyingly thick, slice of salmon wrapped in nori. I couldn't taste the "beet cured salmon" and there was absolutely no kick from wasabi at all. I wouldn't recommend it if you're hoping for a new experience.
Similarly, the eel handroll was served with a solid slice of avocado, but was also frustratingly average. I ordered the miso butter cod because I tried and loved it at Matsunori, but I certainly remember it being better. Finally, the toro had a good amount of tuna, but otherwise did not knock my socks off.
Overall, I would not recommend Mai, especially not for the price tag.