Kelly N.
Yelp
I didn't have high hopes for this place because a lot of people seem to complain about their portion sizes in proportion to their prices. Now that I've been, I have to agree with them, not to even mention a few other issues I experienced.
The LOBSTER BISQUE was decent, not great. It was a little salty, which builds with each bite. If you're sensitive to salt, you might not like it or be able to finish it. There were a few chunks of lobster, which felt fresh like in the rolls, but I don't think it was worth $12 for a cup.
My party got 3 REGULAR LOBSTER ROLLS for $17.50 each. They each came with a piece of taffy, which was a surprise. I think the lobster rolls were overpriced, but they were decent. I was scared there wouldn't be enough meat, because some reviews even complained about the extra meat option not having enough meat, but it was an okay amount and there were some nice, large lobster chunks. The lobster portions seemed a little inconsistent (I think I had a little less than the other two rolls), but it was still better than I expected. I would've liked more meat, of course, but I thought the price was already expensive for what it was, and an extra $6 for a little more meat didn't seem worth it.
I think a big problem is that the bread was too thick for the regular amount of lobster. I felt like most of my bites consisted of more bread than lobster, which contributes to feeling like there wasn't enough lobster. They should use a thinner bread for regular portions of lobster meat and the thick bread for the extra meat option.
Also, I would've liked for it to be more saucy and more seasoned. The lobster felt fresh, but was a little lacking in flavor. The bread was nice and buttered though! And the sides were toasted, so it had a tiny bit of crunch to it, which everyone really enjoyed.
I'm used to homemade lobster rolls that are loaded up and full of flavor, so my bar was set pretty high. I knew I'd be somewhat disappointed unless I got a perfect lobster roll, and I was right. I guess this is a fine option if you don't want to put in the effort to make lobster rolls, but I think making them yourself would be much cheaper and satisfying than getting one here, unfortunately.