Chris D.
Yelp
Mainlander seriously rocks! We went there last night for our anniversary, and this was probably the best restaurant I've visited in the US in the last five years.
When we walked in we were by Gordon, a co-owner and maître d'. Gordon is just fantastic. He makes you feel super welcome and has some insane energy that really ups the experience. Also he's the first person I've met that's given a wine description that I actually enjoyed (usually it's just someone droning on -- with Gordon's style, you listen, try it, and it makes the wine into its own experience, almost like a story. The wines had some serious complexity that normally I'd overlook (I tend to avoid complex wines like a pinot and go toward simpler, bold flavors like a cab -- this was the first time I really kind of "got it" and enjoyed the complex wines.).
Chef Blake delivers food to your table that I describe as, "it punches you in the face." That's always my litmus test for the top tier (and, coincidentally, Gordon used the same phrase to describe the last wine served - which was on point). (Which was another cool thing - the chef and the bartender both delivered the food/drinks they made -- bartender also made a killer "Mainlander" cocktail that was like a mai tai, another drink with some delicious complexity that tasted fantastic. Also bartender had a cool vibe.).
The restaurant is like stepping back in time, but in a cool and comfy way. I thought of it like knowing you're going to a top restaurant like a michelin-esque one, except I immediately felt comfortable, nothing stuffy, etc. The music, the art, even the unique wooden glasses for the free rum punch - every detail is on point. To avoid sounding too gushy, we initially thought the tables might be a bit too close, but we didn't hear a peep from other tables and had conversation at a normal volume the whole night -- so it wasn't a problem whatsoever.
In short, Mainlander is hands-down the best place I've tried in ages. And is probably the first restaurant I've reviewed in 3-5 years. Great wine, great food, great atmosphere. You're in for a treat!