Kate S.
Yelp
I've been to Manna a handful of times over the years. The first time was a pretty magical experience, around a decade ago. The second was a bit more disappointing - went for Valentine's Day and the food wasn't what I would have expected for the price point (then again, Valentine's dinners often aren't). I've been for a few special events, as well, which I enjoyed.
I hadn't gone in several years, but recently went for Beggars Can't Be Choosers. In theory, this is something I would love. There's a menu of plate types (veggie, meat, sweets, etc) with listed prices and then you get what you get - whatever the kitchen wants to make. Same goes for drinks - there was a full bar menu but you could also order a "keg" (apparently actually just a small glass) of mystery beer or a mystery cocktail. I like the idea of a surprise meal, so I was excited to book a reservation.
The restaurant was beautifully decorated for winter/holidays and sitting at the bar felt so cozy. We ordered the mystery cocktail, which was really tasty but a pretty small pour.
I'm a vegetarian and ordered two of the veggie dishes. My mistake for assuming a veggie plate would be vegetarian, especially when I ordered two of them (I would think someone who ate meat would order the veggie and something else if ordering multiple items, but who knows), but I ended up with a salad with bacon which I had to awkwardly send back. My friend ordered two plates and one was the incorrect one but she didn't realize it until she'd eaten it. The manager offered to bring the correct item, as well, but my friend didn't want a third plate - I'm not sure why the wrong item wasn't just comped and instead there was no "fix" - just a wrong item paid for.
It's entirely possible there's a sign somewhere that I missed, but I was really surprised when gratuity was added and that feels borderline tacky to me. As someone who's a pretty generous tipper - as I would hope most people who go out for fine dining are - it leaves a bad taste in my mouth when 20% is automatically added to my check.
With that said, my food was solid. The salad (once there was no longer bacon) was refreshing, beautifully-plated, and delicious. The risotto was really tasty. The dessert was a nice finish to the meal. But for $140 (5 small plates, four drinks), the meal left room for improvement.
I'd try Manna again, both for Beggars or a standard night, but would come more prepared.