Lana J.
Yelp
We have been eating here since I was in my 20's. I am now 62. The place is wonderful. It turned out just like the owner Gigi said it would. We loved the atmosphere.
Started with an old-fashioned it was delicious, with the nice large cube ice as an old-fashioned should have. But extremely small for $14, same with the Lemoncello sour cocktail it was also delicious, yet mostly the large ice cube $12.
I'm not sure why she went back to the 1950s menu because there is no one living that ate the 1950s menu.
We all loved the original menu that we have been eating say for the last 40 years.
Garlic bread (slices) $5 for 4 ir 5 small pieces (no garlic bread does not come with dinner), was not impressed at all. 4 adults, needed 2 orders of bread. Didn't care for the finely grated parmesan on top. Loved the old Margie's bread that was a small loaf sliced in half served in a little bag. The bread was not worth $10. Gigi please bring the original bread back.
You no longer get a salad with your entrée, if you want a salad they range in price from $8 to $12.
Don't order the vinaigrette dressing on your salad. It was thick and tasted like blended up kale and had a ginger taste, greenish black looking. We told the server and she immediately brought another salad with ranch dressing. $8 is too much for a salad with dinner.
The pasta sauce was kind of bland, for ANY Italian restaurant.
The shrimp scampi had huge delicious shrimp, however, the shrimp sat on a extremely small portion of Angel hair pasta, It was good and $26.
The chicken Parmesan $24, and the eggplant Parmesan $18 were equally delicious, however the pasta sauce was very bland.
Service was great! We waited right at an hour for a table on a Saturday night.
It's just not the wonderful food it has been in the past. The menu is very small, which I understand if you want to downsize the menu. But you should definitely bring back the original bread, and I will gladly pay $5.
Nothing I enjoyed in the past was on the new menu, the spicy shrimp deavlo to name one.
Guess I'll give the pizza a try next time. So all in all, it was very expensive. In my humble opinion bring back the original bread and don't charge $8-$12 for a salad that goes with your entree, ps the salad served in the COLD silver bowls were delicious in the past! And perhaps have the drinks with a little more drink in it, or charge less.