Mario's Pizzeria

$2.75 a slice ($3.50 for fancy slices)! For hand made pizza! I cannot believe I only paid $6.50 for dinner this good. This place is so unassuming but it’s worth seeking out if you want really good pizza. The shop is casual and divey and un-gentrified so I am rating this 5 stars for what it is- a delicious local pizza shop (this is not 5 stars for the ambience or fanciness). I stopped by randomly because I saw the guy scraping dough through the window and thought this is probably going to be good… And it was. The crusts are both chewy and crispy at the same time. The dollops of ricotta on the white pizza are generous and creamy while not too rich. The plain slice was a really good slice but the white pizza was really a standout. I ate everything so fast I forgot to take a photo until I was almost done. If you want good pizza and live in ft. Greene area, stop by Mario’s (also, apparently they do free delivery)

Pretty good pizza as good as jersey. I only had 2 slices but the sauce was perfect.

This is our favorite pizza place in the neighborhood and I've been here for 24 years! No frills just good hot pizza with a good crust and cheese to sauce ratio. They could probably do a little reno on the looks of the establishment but pizza wise, it's the best in the hood

Old fashioned NY pizza. Truly a throwback to a time before the neighborhood was gentrified. Great pizza at a great price! Much better than the overpriced pizza in the area

Great vibe. Friendly. Quick and courteous service. Great pizza. Fabulous price.

2 slices for $7.50 seems a bit ridiculous for the quality and cleanliness of this place. Also the pizza looks like ass… it all has to have been sitting out for hours no doubt. Nothing seems fresh.

Excellent pizza - freshly made, super flavourful.

Really great pizza! 🍕