Mario's Pizzeria of Oyster Bay

I love this pizza place I can't say enough good things about the food, management and employees. the pizza is excellent Do you know how to make nice and crust with above average delicious sauce and high quality generous portions of mozzarella (taste like Grande brand, but I never asked). On top of that, it's probably the best enlargest comfortable sit down dining room that doesn't require waiter service that you have to tip for.

The vodka pizza is what makes me drive damn near 40 minutes to get. Easy to order over the phone everything was ready when I got there. Love their white pizza. Plain and pepperoni are always good but all the speciality pizzas of theirs I’ve had so far are really good.

This pizzeria always has a ton of staff and provides quick and friendly service. The pizza is very good.

Nice and easy pizzeria in the area :) I step in at quite night, self order and they bring our food to the table. This is just my test and my own opinion. I don't like the food at all but nothing wrong with the food and how they prepare it. My Italian husband love the food, he actually brings my order home and finish it later. I get shrimp in garlic oil and when the food comes, it isn't like I expect at all. So, all I want to say is I just like food that is not in thick flour and not too oily. Order I get, maybe it is an Italian style and that is how they prepare the food. Anyway, service is good, friendly and very family style.

My.pizza that was just delivered here in Oyster Bay, NY was the worst I've ever had. I order there food once a week, 200$ a month. It was burnt on bottom, cold, (and there less than a mile away from me) and so soggy and oily. What a waist of a pizza, I have to find another place, been here since 2021 and order from the them, but honestly it's gotten worse and worse. i’ve been in the restaurant and I see when the orders come in they give you that pizza that’s sitting outside for hours and hours like slop. Two bites I threw it all out. With tip almost $40.00. I ate a bowl of cereal instead. That's Mario Pizza in Oyster Bay, New York. I'm a resident in area but ill Never ordering here again!!!!

A small family owned chain throughout Long Island. Very nice menu . A little on the pricey side. I ordered the Cold Italian Special Hero, different meats and provolone cheese with lettuce and tomato, just fair. My wife tried the Eggplant Parmigiana Hero, which she enjoyed. We have had pizza previously which was very good.

We come here at least twice a month and the pizza is always fresh and made to order. A pie only comes in one size that easily feeds two. Call ahead on a Friday-Saturday evening, they get slammed for orders and delivery may take a little longer.

Real New York authentic pizza. $30 for a large margarita old-style, and it tastes worth it. You wont be disappointed. Constantine works there, great guy, knows his history!

Amazing pizza and service love the variants and the vibes plenty of places to sit it is amazing.

I'm incredibly frustrated with well-established pizzerias that can't seem to master the simple task of heating a slice of pizza properly. I visited on a bustling Friday night, and there were 18 employees behind the counter. I specifically asked for my slice to be heated up really hot, not burnt, since I had no way to warm it up afterward and planned to eat it on the go. After waiting 10 minutes for just one slice, I finally left, only to find that it was cold by the time I took my third bite. I was so annoyed that I seriously considered turning around to return it. It's just absurd that, with that many people working, not a single one could manage to heat up a slice correctly, resulting in me walking away with a cold pizza. Second time this happened.

Stopped in for Mondays 15% off deal. Got 2 pies, one pepperoni and one plain for $45. Pizza isn't cheap anymore. At least this was fresh and hot. The staff greets you as soon as you walk in. The restaurant is beige with lots of tables. It's clean and there were a lot of people around 1pm. The pizza was ok. Nothing spectacular to be honest. The dough was thin and a bit chewy. The sauce didn't stand out to me maybe because there wasn't much of it. To be honest I'd pay more for a stand out pizza

2-16-25. Stopped in for lunch because I had an errand to run in the immediate area. Ordered a chicken Marsala slice and a regular slice. Both were very good. My friend had a Sicilian slice and said it was excellent. Plenty of seating in a comfortable and casual atmosphere. Staff was very friendly and they had quite a large selection of specialty pizzas. Prices were reasonable.

We have been eating here for 30 years but in the last 6 months or so it seems like something changed..Pizza is hit or miss, Eggplant dish that my wife usually orders was inedible last time and tonight I had a calzone that I threw away halfway through. Zero taste and the crust was like wood. Sadly after all this time we won't be back.

This place is out of this world! The menu at first glance seems a little on the "pricey" side for a pizza shop but Mario's is a cut above the rest and when you get your first order, you will be pleasantly surprised. The portions are MASSIVE, pizza, subs, salads and sides! All huge portions. Every single thing I have ordered from here has been nothing less than delicious. I ordered the meatball tonight and a fry and the meatballs were SO BIG it was almost too big to eat, something I consider a positive. They never skimp out on anything they go for gold! The sauce is perfect and the meatballs tasted fresh. This place is fantastic and you should absolutely order from here any chance you get. Great job Mario's.

Frank (the younger one) serves up the best pizza at Mario's! I highly recommend the grandma sicilian pizza. Their pastas are delicious as well. Please be warned.. If you've never been to Mario's and are ordering through DoorDash/grubhub/ubereats, be careful how much food you order! The portion sizes are colossal sized! I learned this the hard way. Well, throughout the years, I've never walked in, I've always ordered delivery. One day, I decided to walk in the restaurant with my friends who are visiting from out of the country. Frank and everyone was so kind and patient with taking our order. There are plenty of seating indoors and there aren't any outdoor seating here. The restaurant is very clean and they're always cleaning. The staffing handling the food orders can be seen and I haven't seen anything that would concern my gut health. I'm honestly going to always be a fan of Mario's and if I'm craving for some pizza, I'm driving myself to Oyster Bay to dine in. Service is fantastic. My family and I are always going to be their customer!

Pizza was really good Espically with their ice tea, was definitely one of the better pizza around and there isn't to many. Service was good I do think it's a little more on the pricey side but overall I do think the taste of the pizza outweighs the cost

Nice and easy pizzeria in the area :) I step in at quite night, self order and they bring our food to the table. This is just my test and my own opinion. I don't like the food at all but nothing wrong with the food and how they prepare it. My Italian husband love the food, he actually brings my order home and finish it later. I get shrimp in garlic oil and when the food comes, it isn't like I expect at all. So, all I want to say is I just like food that is not in thick flour and not too oily. Order I get, maybe it is an Italian style and that is how they prepare the food. Anyway, service is good, friendly and very family style.

Definitely best pizza in the area. Rapid and courteous delivery. Great taste. Try the cheese pie.

Come here for lunch when I'm in the area they have the best slices and calzones everything always taste delicious highly recommend getting one of their salads everything is always so fresh love this location!

A small family owned chain throughout Long Island. Very nice menu . A little on the pricey side. I ordered the Cold Italian Special Hero, different meats and provolone cheese with lettuce and tomato, just fair. My wife tried the Eggplant Parmigiana Hero, which she enjoyed. We have had pizza previously which was very good.

Just moved to the area & this is my go to for a slice or 2! Always quick & satisfying whether it's delivery or take out. Happy I found my new favorite pizzeria in my new neighborhood!

Been eating here as long as I can remember. Lived in Oyster Bay my entire life and this was always the spot to go. Over the past 3 years or so, Mario's has gone WAY down hill. I noticed it one day when they changed their BBQ chicken slice sauce. The new one is much worse. Next was the Sicilian. Flat, soggy, and gross. Finally, the plain pie. Absolutely horrific. The cheese slides right off of the soggy crust. I haven't had a crispy pie in years. Oh and I cant forget about the worst item on the menu. Ceasar salad? COVERED. And I mean COVERED in garlic, salt and pepper. Who the fuck would ever put that much garlic on a Ceasar salad? I threw it away after 2 bites. Im officially done giving Marios another chance time and time again. After 20+ years of eating Marios, I am officially done. This place sucks!

In all honesty the pizza was mediocre not enough cheese on my pizza. We were going to the beach and craving pizza for the beach.

This place was really, really, good. Try a side of meatballs with what ever you eat. Trust me. That's a pic of the meatball after the fact. Sorry couldn't control myself.

It's Mario's. It's consistent as long as you don't order off-hours. Then it's anything goes. Order during lunch or dinner rush and you're getting great dishes and pizza. (My only complaint is that they don't put enough cheese on top of their rigatoni ala vodka pizza as a binder, so that all the pasta falls right off the crust; we no longer order it from them after many requests for them to do so.). Otherwise they're the best OB has to offer even with some new sand well-known additions to the area.

amazing service and even better food. MUST TRY ceaser slice. great spot and lots of seating options

many choices of pizza , garlic knots were underwhelming , sauce could use a make over , kind of bland and lifeless , maybe full red or 711 right out of can ???

It's not Nino's, but pretty good. Their prices have gone up though. Can get an entree cheaper at Cafe Al Dente, and it comes with a salad!

I have ordered from Mario's a few times now , honestly their pizza is good, what I am looking for in a pizza order/ delivery that's convenient. I had one bad delivery experience which I won't let tarnish the rest of my orders but I will just say it was odd that everyone at the store kept telling me the delivery guy left or should be here / left 45 min ago (I live 7 min from the store) and it still took him 90 min to get me my very cold pizza Again don't want one bad delivery to tarnish a good thing but , hopefully that was the last time Buffalo chicken Sicilian is BY far the spiciest tastiest thing I've had in ages outside of a regular slice!!

The food is nothing to talk about, what really irks me is that the two times I've ordered here, there is always hair in the pizza. It's disgusting. It's always the same short black hair. Not giving this place another chance.

This pizza place is the go to spot in Oyster bay. The quality of the food is incredible impressive. Everything is fresh and this place only serves food with top quality ingredients. In the pictures I got the buffalo chicken calzone which is my favorite and they serve it to you with real blue cheese chunks and all. The Gorgonzola salad was delicious and I got garlic knots which are arguably some of the best garlic knots I have ever had. If you are looking for a pizza place in oyster bay that you can rely on for quality pizza and Italian dishes look no further just go here.

Mario's was my pizza place hangout when I was growing up. Video games out front and what I've since learned was a "head shop" next door. Whenever my Mom and Dad didn't want to cook, we would pick up a pizza from here. Back then, it was classic New York - a massive slice of plain cheese with a thin doughy crust. Mmmm.. that's the way pizza should be. The "Mario" of those days was actually a Greek dude named Dimitri, if memory serves. In the 20 years since I was here last, Mario's had upgraded and changed a bit. The awning out front is fancier, the booths are more comfortable and there's a big glass case at the counter with the pizza. It's not plain cheese any more - it's now all sorts of artisan toppings and interesting stuffings. And I would bet that my Greek friend Dimitri is long gone. The video games are also gone and the shop next door sells Verizon. But for tradition's sake, I had a slice of their pizza anyway. I wasn't disappointed. Still a thin crust, but topped with fresh mozzarella and sliced Roma tomatoes and roasted peppers. Really good, though not the same as what I remember from the old days. If you're in Oyster Bay and looking for a good slice, you won't go wrong with Mario's.

Went for the Sicilian or grandma but the slices looked dried out and overcooked crust. So went with a slice of regular just out of oven and it was a good slice. The BEST thing were the garlic knots. I think better than my favorite place in the Bronx, and that's saying a lot. Such a soft texture with perfect garlic flavor and not too greasy. One worker wearing mask under their chin... I know it is hard work baking pizza (I used to work in a pizza shop and even in a/c it gets hot), but please wear masks correctly to keep us all safe during pandemic!

Loved the artichoke pizzette. It was awesome. Thank you for delivering to Bayville! And the delivery guy on Tuesdays is very nice.

CALL ME A GLUTTON FOR PUNISHMENT! It doesn't matter who's paying, the pasta dishes and pizza is awful! WHERE''S THE SAUC??? This isn't the Mario's I remember as a kid! We got a pie with extra cheese, half peppers & half grilled chicken... well most of the chicken was hard & tasted like would & there was barely no sauce! UNACCEPTABLE

Mario's pizzeria is the real deal! The staff is great, and the food is unbelievable! So friendly and very happy how they handle the safety of everyone wit making sure everyone who walks in wears a mask. My son mateo loves there pizza! As so does my entire family! Super happy

We ordered a pizza and a ceaser salad for take out. Pizza was OK. The ceaser salad was good but only had 3 croutons!!! 3 croutons for a $9.75 salad!!! Note to self, find new pizza restaurant that has good food and value for my money.

My husband and I love coming here. The food is always fresh, a great selection, quick and friendly service. The price is average. I came here the other night with my husband and my mother-in-law. I heard the fettuccine Alfredo with chopped chicken cutlet, I forgot to take a picture. . They had a vodka flies, grandma Slason, and broccoli Rabb slices. Everything came out piping hot it was absolutely delicious. Come to think of it, I've never had a bad experience here. The only down part is that sometimes on the weekend to get some packed I wish I had more seating.

I love this joint everything is excellent the pizza is the best I've had on LI and I'm from Brooklyn the place for the worlds best pizza shit I've been eating pizza my entire life and I'm in my 50's. The stuffed pizza is great their garlic knots are wicked good a regular pie is delicious and their pecan salad is the best. The people are fantastic and the service is outstanding.

Pizza is so fresh here and such a large selection. Don't you hate it when you walk into a pizzeria and it looks like all the slices have been sitting out there all day long. That won't happen here! This is the only place I've ever been where I've seen with my own eyes new pizza rolls being made from scratch in the middle of the afternoon - that's how you know it's fresh.

Be very careful using your Credit or Debit. Not only has this happen to me once by phone for take out but also once while eating in the restaurant. In addition it's happened to several others living in the neighborhood. BEWARE

Some real down-home good cooking at this pizza restaurant. Tonight I just went with slices, a regular and a barbeque chicken. Both tasting fantastic. The combination of the marinara with the barbeque sauce and some small crispy nuggets of chicken throughout made the specialty slice extra special. And of course I try a regular slice at every New joint I patronize. At Mario's they have excellent sauce the right cheese crust is pretty perfect and it all comes together because the chefs there know how to cook a slice well done and crispy, without having to be told. Mangia!

Wtf zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz chicken bacon ranch? Where is the chicken where is the bacon but tons of ranch!

It was a long day and what better idea than to forego the cooking and get some takeout? We'd not tried Mario's yet so we called and I was greeted by Kyle, who was courteous and pleasant while I placed our order for sauteed calamari with whole wheat pasta and a pie with sausage and onions, with a side of mozzarella sticks. He promised us the food within a half hour and kept their promise. Although, it was not inexpensive; we are getting used to that in oyster bay. And didnt mind because the food was really very good. The pizza was as good as most you would expect in the city, and how hard can mozzarella sticks be? The reason for the extra star was for the very good service and the calamari dish was a step above. Well done! We certainly would recommend this restaurant to others, and when we finally make it to the restaurant itself for a sitdown meal, i'll augment this review.

Part of a chain of pizza restaurants, Mario's serves up middle of the road pizza at the cost of your firstborn male child- ok, well maybe not that much, but he ain't cheap. They'll deliver but you can forget that if you are single because you'll have to order a lot to hit the minimum delivery fee. There are way better pizza joints around -

I've only ever had the food from Mario's Great Neck location, which I was never a fan of...the pizza was always soggy and the food was mediocre at best. HOWEVER, this past weekend I was at a party that catered from the Oyster Bay location and Oyster Bay FTW! They had baked ziti (which I didn't try), fettuccine alfredo, baked ravioli, and eggplant parmesan. I haven't had an alfredo dish in years because alfredo sauce is always my dietary demise, but theirs was not overly creamy and perfectly tasty. The baked ravioli was standard. I only had one ravioli because they were huge, but it was good and stuffed with plenty of cheese, which is always a plus in my book. The star of the meal though was the eggplant parm. I love eggplant, but was never a fan of it in parm form until this past weekend, when I helped myself to two platefuls. I may need eggplant detox. Bravo, Mr. Mario, bravo!

Please stop repeating the full card number with expiration date and CVC code out loud when ordering over the phone

I have frequented this establishment for nearly 20 years multiple times a week. Today, my husband was treated like a thief for a simple misunderstanding. Whenever I order, I typically pay with a card over the phone. Well today I was ordering food and working from home and didn't pay over the phone. When my husband came to the establishment he was under the assumption that the food was paid for as that's the typical routine. Steve points out the order, my husband proceeds to walk out and Steve comes out behind him and says that's not paid for, snatched the food out of his hand while simultaneously saying I'll take that and proceeded to tell my husband he speed out like a BANDIT. My husband was obviously offended by the implication, that he was trying to steal the food, not only because it was rude and nasty, especially a misunderstanding that could have been handled with more tact and people skills but also because he's a black man and all the cultural implications that sort of statement and behavior holds. My husband trying to be calm followed him in and paid for the food and explained that he was under the assumption that it was paid for as that's what we typically do. To add insult to injury, when I came in to speak with the manager, the owner, Steve Spanos, excused his culturally insensitive and nasty behavior and followed it up with excuses rather than genuinely trying to understand what a 20 year customer was trying to explain. He even double down when speaking with me with the same disgusting tone and attitude. And when I pointed it out he then tried to claim that wasn't the tone he took or the way he responded to my husband. I only Went in to complain because I was in disbelief that anyone in the establishment, let alone the owner would behave in such a manner. Not only providing horrendous customer service but not even trying to understand what kind of statement he was making that was completely tone deaf and disturbing. I WILL NEVER SPEND ANOTHER DIME THERE!

I am housebound due to chronic health issues, too ill to cook, and they really help me out by delivering to me... I get deliveries several times a week. They go above and beyond to accommodate me and my crazy restricted diet, letting me customize dishes. They always take my allergies into consideration and make delicious dishes for me. The gluten free pizza, cauliflower pizza, gluten free pasta, and salads, all customized for my difficult diet, all amazing. And everyone there is SO friendly. And they have been SO amazing, continuing to deliver with the coronavirus craziness... 100 stars!

Cannot recommend this place enough! Best pizza I have ever eaten in New York! Staff is courteous and professional

Fast service, good pizza! Can't go wrong making a stop here! Grandma slice is must have! So many options of slices I have yet to try!

Great food, best pizzeria that delivers to Bayville! Way better customer service then Ralph's pizzeria in Bayville

Can't complain. Consistency, great food,late delivery. They have great items to choose from and all my experience has been filled with good moments. Pasta and Pizza is my favorite thing to order from them, they have a reputation for being one of the best Italian food places around the area. I'm telling you, it's legit.

So dank! I drive 2 towns over for their pizza, very fresh and the restaurant always kept clean

Best spot on the North Shore. You can not compare to any of the other Mario's around Long Island. The others don't even measure up. The food here is consistently delicious, regardless of what you get.

I would give no stars, this food is disgusting. I ordered a few times, higher end dishes as shrimp francese (not so hard to figure out), chicken verde, both dishes were drowned in some kind of disgusting broccoli sauce--even when I pulled the protein out it was inedible and it all went in the garbage. Thankfully it was thru a delivery service and I got my money back, there pizza sucks too, so greasy, even when you just stop in for a slice. I assume nothing is fresh so they cut corners and hide it with these sauces. I know they are basically the only gig in this dump of a town, but they have no idea what they are doing with Italian food. Basically negative stars.

Great pizza and chicken parm. I've been a regular customer since around 2000. Highly recommended for eat in, dine in or take out!