Ronald Y.
Yelp
Sorry to say but Mario's has seen its glory days and is now a just so-so restaurant living on its past reputation. Before I get to criticizing the food, I would like to commend Mario's on excellent service, lots of attention to our party of thirteen on a slow Wednesday night. Staff was friendly & congenital and made us feel welcomed. Now to the food. First of all, most dishes were way too salty or bland. Dinners included antipasto tray with small shrimp, olives, salami, etc-a nice touch, then minestrone soup, house salad, a side of spaghetti & bread. The minestrone soup was salty & was unusually thick, like it was pureed, house salad was good, fresh with homemade Italian dressing. The side of spaghetti had a funny color brown sauce which almost tasted like chili, not tomato sauce. Dinner portions were good size, but they were either too salty or too bland. Three of us had the seafood pasta which had a small portion of seafood for $49-had about 4 small/medium shrimp, a few small scallops & tiny bits of tasteless lobster-all three of us were disappointed. I think this dish was not cooked properly. I believe the seafood was blanched, pasta cooked separately, then mixed with the marinara sauce and plated. If I were cooking this dish, I would sauté the seafood with garlic & butter, add seasoning, then add the pasta & sauce in the same pan and cooked to serve. The shrimp scampi was too salty & cooked differently than expected. Usually the shrimp scampi would be sautéed with garlic & butter. Mario's shrimp scampi was lightly coated with a flour or corn starch & deep fried. Broiled lamb chops & the porterhouse steak were large portions but the sauce with the lamb was also too salty, and the porterhouse was tough. On a positive note the broiled sea bass was excellent, not salty, fresh and cooked to perfection. We all had desserts which were very good and delicious. In general, any "cooked" food was below par, except for the sea bass. The dining room was a little dark, with lots of dark paneling & even a dark ceiling, decorated with lighted garland-a little Christmasy. When eating out, it's always how the food tastes, how good is the service and the decor. Unfortunately, food at Mario's is not as it used to be, way below the standards of a quality restaurant, and a little redecorating wouldn't hurt.