Maroni Southold

Maroni's is such a gem in the middle of Southold. The Sushi Tuesdays are INCREDIBLE and the truffle grilled cheese is to absolutely DIE for. Kristen & Amber are 2 of the best on the North Fork and if you've not had their meatball pot yet I IMPLORE you to do so. And this is coming from someone who doesnt eat meatballs outside her Nonna's kitchen. I can not express this enough but make reservations and enjoy the fact that the place deals in cash/check/zelle only and that the prices on the menu reflect tax & tip so you can know exactly what you're spending in advance.

Was there with my brother for the first time. And we go to a lot of restaurants. This is by FAR one of our favorites!! From just walking in and being greeted like you came to a relatives house to the whole experience. The food is absolutely the best I’ve had. I can’t wait to go back. Thank you so much for an incredible experience !!!

This is a very small restaurant that I guess would be the sister restaurant to the Maroni in Northport. Do not bother coming here without a reservation unless you are getting take out (which in the summer, you can eat at one of the tables out back). The restaurant is spotless, including the bathroom. The staff is very friendly and took the time to explain everything on the menu. I tried the Korean Style BBQ Ribs with Gummi Bear Garnish as my appetizer. If you like ribs, these will not disappoint in any way! We also had the Gagootz Parmesan, which was amazing. For dinner, I had the Chicken Parmesan and the charred green beans. The dinners come with nothing, and if you want a side of pasta to go with it, your only choice is to order Penne Ala Vodka, which you would pay $27 dollars for since its a separate meal choice. The portions were very large and filling. We did have room for dessert so we went with the chocolate mousse and the chipwich. Both were great choices. It is worth noting that this is a hospitality included restaurant, meaning that the gratuity is included. You do not leave a tip. There is parking out back, but I imagine that it fills up rather quickly in the summer. Botom line-great restaurant and worth the trip.

If I could give this place 6 stars I would. The Northport location is great but Southhold might be the best restaurant on Long Island. Everything in the menu is amazing, and the vibes and ambiance of this location might be the happiest place in New York State. Definitely make a reservation in advance because it’s always booked up. Also cash only (no tip- all included) so stop by an ATM on the way. Everyone should try this restaurant once in their life. Let me put it this way- when you go to a restaurant that only has 3 entrees on the menu, you know each one is going to be absolutely next level.

Just making the reservation was pleasant and informative. Their website explains why the prices include the tip and why they do not take credit cards. They have an outside deck, a large picnic area, ample parking, and most of all, a beautiful interior decore. Everyone was friendly and accommodating to our requests. Both of our dishes were delicious, and I am sure their deserts are as well. On the oitside picnic tables, there are red pots, which I believe are for taking your meal home to warm or perhaps for eating outside in their spacious yard.

I would consider myself a Chicken Parm connoisseur, and Maroni is up at the tippy top of my list. Absolutely delicious!! 10/10! Sat at the bar, great energy, nice people, not to be missed!

I took the ferry from New London to Orient Point to attend a wake and needed lunch. Google led me to Maroni’s. Everything about it was fabulous. A very sweet, accommodating, and attentive staff, delicious sushi with a side of chicken parm and this crazy good marshmallow chocolate dessert made the visit complete. Loved the vibe and you can tell it’s jammed with patrons at night. If you’re in Southhold, NY, make sure you save your appetite for a wonderful meal and atmosphere. Thank you, Kristina and staff for a memorable experience.

I wanted to share my recent dining experience at Maroni in Southold, NY. It's safe to say that this place left a lasting impression on me. From the get-go, the staff at Maroni were incredible. Their friendly and attentive service made me feel right at home. They knew their stuff and were more than willing to offer recommendations, adding a personal touch to the dining experience. Now, let's talk about the food – wow! The dishes I tried were nothing short of exceptional. Each plate was bursting with flavors that took my taste buds on a journey. From start to finish, I was thoroughly impressed by the quality and creativity of the dishes. One thing that caught my attention was the unique payment system – it's cash only and includes the tip. This streamlined approach eliminated any guesswork and made the whole experience hassle-free. The ambiance at Maroni is cozy and inviting, creating a relaxed atmosphere that complements the culinary journey. Here's something cool: Maroni also has a Northport location that I'm looking forward to checking out soon. If it's anything like my experience in Southold, I'm definitely excited to see what they have to offer. In a world of dining options, Maroni stands out for its excellent food, attentive service, and relaxed ambiance. If you're in the mood for a memorable culinary adventure, give Maroni a try – you won't be disappointed.