Mary's Pizza Shack

I really wanted to like the food… the bruschetta was delicious it was just missing the balsamic vinaigrette. The Calzone was not good.

Wonderful food, outstanding service, reasonable prices and good atmosphere! We thoroughly enjoyed our dinner last night and feel this restaurant is a "hidden gem". Definitely an affordable place to take the family. I highly recommend it and urge you to take advantage of a "home town spot".

We celebrated my husband's 70th birthday with a surprise party in the enclosed banquet/party room at Mary's Pizza, Napa on Friday December 20, 2024 at 6 PM. Maya the manager and all of her staff were 100% over the top accommodating to our 30 guests. I was able to decorate the room the night before and also put the pie and cake in their refrigerator the morning of the party. Our server Mayra did an excellent job refilling pitchers of drinks and replacing empty pizza trays as needed. When the party was over at 8:30 PM all we had to do was packup pur belongings and the staff took care of the rest of the cleanup and removal of balloons, disposable tablecloths, and paper and plastic products. You might want to know how much it costs to reserve the party room. Amazingly, it was absolutely free of charge!! I can't thank Maya, Mayra, and everyone else for making this surprise party perfect and much less expensive by far than anywhere else!! Thank you again, Karen Smith

Mary’s- this is a message for your team. You’re all awesome! Please make your ranch available to order ‘separately’ on DoorDash. Give it its own category. You have the best ranch in napa valley! And the salads are excellent. (Pizzas used to be the best but have been undercooked the past few years so other places became better options). Would order from here more if the ranch was a guaranteed dish of its own!

There are new owners who try hard to make it nice. We got the Marys salad and soup with warm French bread. Yummy! We love the salads.

The Large pizza we ordered was $40 delivered and was TINY!!!! Most places would have called their large, a SMALL. It was not enough to feed the 3 people i had with me. They charged $3.30 to add Green Peppers. Highly disappointing.

Everyone involved at our event was great. Adela was fantastic as out server. I couldn't have asked for more. I truly recommend this place for food and special events.

Entrance in the back and easy to miss from Jefferson. Once you get over that, a feast awaits, so many types and varieties of delicious main and side dishes. Oh did I mention the pizza is also excellent? Rounded out with desserts and family deals and you will get over any traffic difficulties quickly. Enjoy.

This is a bit late, but I had to get a review on here. My family came to this place for years. Every time we would come, we were greeted promptly by staff, and seated pretty quickly. The waitresses were always nice and helpful. We would always get a pepperoni pizza with the house salad. I absolutely LOVE the ranch that is in this salad! My mouth waters thinking about it. This place brings me so many good memories of time with family. I would definitely say's this place was always a family joint!

Haven't been here since they re-opened this location, but we were scrolling through the Toast app to see what was available in the area and saw "MPS" and tried it. Speaking of MPS, I think they should rename it to the actual name (Mary's Pizza Shack) in the Toast app instead of it showing up as "MPS - NAPA" so people can find it easier. I didn't know what it was until I tapped on it. That said, Toast is one of my favorite food ordering platforms and I'm glad Mary's is on there. Anyway, about the pizza - it was good. It was crispy, not soggy, which I greatly appreciate. Everything appeared and tasted fresh and quality. Not the best pizza I've ever had in my life, but definitely one of the best pizza places in Napa, and I think I've tried at least 80% of them. The large hawaiian pizza was $33.50. Expensive, but given the area and todays pricing, I'm not going to complain. Worth noting the large is definitely the best value. Medium is about $4 less, so not sure why you would bother ordering anything but large? Our order was ready in less time than originally quoted and when I went in to pick up the order, the staff were friendly and the restaurant appeared very clean. We'll be back!

I came in today to get some minestrone soup for my mom, and found out that there is more than one kind. The one with meat has ham in it, and the other one has no meat. People were kind and gracious and helpful.

I would love to write a great review because of their history. Unfortunately I am at home sick and was craving some spaghetti with marinara sauce. They charged almost 19.00 on DoorDash plus all the fees and by the time I was done it was about 30.00 that didn't bother me. What bothered me were the noodles were way overcooked and mushy the sauce was very oily and had no flavor. I told my dad the next day please let's get some jarred pasta sauce and make spaghetti because I've been craving it and I threw away 30.00 of pasta. Sadly the jarred pasta sauce at the grocery store has more flavor and doesn't leave my mouth feeling oily.

I've moved around the bay area for years, always returned to Mary's. Something about their sauce and toppings. The quality is always good. The service vary but that's because of the kids that need jobs. Not the company's fault so much. I will complain about the Napa branch and the inconsistency of their pizza sizes. I understand prices going up and tip matching that. If I am going to continue to pay the highest price pizza in Napa I would like to have some consistency. I feel robbed when I pay so much for a large pizza and get the size of a medium. Atleast have your staff be smarter if the order has one large pizza and one medium to not make them the same size. Has happened too many times. Also, when I ask for half and half pizzas, don't give me less of the half im paying full price for.

I really wanted to give them a chance after they for a new owner and reopened it but today was the last day I'll be going back. My server Stephanie was the sweetest but the food..... When I got my salad it just smelled off. I couldn't put my finger on it until I tasted it. The shredded cheese on it was sour. It was really old cheese and I just couldn't. Then I moved on to my buffalo wrap and same. Something in there was spoiled I just could r get past the 2nd bite. A few months back I had ordered take out so my husband picked it up exactly at the time they told us. We're a 5 min drive from them and when he got back the pizza was cold. That order of pizza was definitely meant for somebody else who didn't pick it up and they just gave it to us. There's no way that a pizza out of the oven could have been that cold that fast.

I stoped by for dinner on 12/12/23. Pizza was good, probably even better than before they closed for business earlier this year! Salad was great and fresh. We got a GREAT server (too bad it was this guy last day at this place) I am glad they open again. Ambiance was ok, place can use a few TVs.

Just having arrived in Napa and hungry for lunch we were pleasantly surprised to find a Mary's Pizza Shack not far from our hotel. We had been big fans of Mary's Walnut Creek location, but that was a Pandemic casualty, and we had wondered if the whole chain had perished. Fortunately that wasn't the case! We were pleased to see their indoor dining layout was spread out with booths, so we felt safe despite Omicron. Cady, our server, was both efficient and quite friendly, adding to the atmosphere and experience. After some deliberation we settled on the medium Tuscan Pizza, which was delicious, and we had leftovers sufficient for another meal. The thick crust we chose was amazing, typical for Mary's, and always one of their high points. For dessert we split a mud pie, good, but not up to the standard of their pizzas. Wish there was a Mary's closer to us, but at least they still exist!

Our first time here, after noticing MPS, was open for business, we pulled in. First, the lentil soup.. pretty darn good. The lasanga was a really amazing, tasty, super flavorful, beautiful, authentic treat. The chicken parm and fettuccine.. Oh, wee. This spot and these entrées are going to become our faves to frequent. This is the salad nicely plated but came out warm, no chill or crunch, but the dressing made it ok~ish. Our next date night out here will be with MPS. Our waitress and her service were great she was very, sweet, and patient in helping us decide and recommending entrées.

Gross overpriced 'pizza' if that's what they call it. Barely any sauce, just thick hard crust. I'm upset I paid for this! And they kiosk wants a tip for pick up, what a joke!

I have been eating at Mary's Pizza Shack well over 30 years, the food has always been pretty good. I decided to order a pizza & a salad for pick up. I called them, placed my order & the girl taking my order said it would be ready in 20-30 minutes. I was already there in the parking lot, it was raining so I just hung out in my car for about 20 min. I went in, they were getting ready to close, I stood at the counter for a few minutes then I guy comes to the register, I say I have a pick up order, he rings me up $43.00 ????? Plus I tipped. When I placed my order I asked for my pizza to be crispy it was not it was soggy and gross. There was no flavor. Salad 95% lettuce very little topping. Medium pizza $30.00 Salad $8.95 + tax. I won't be back, over priced and the quality was not good. I waited another 15 minutes for my pizza, that I was told was still in the oven, yet when I get it it's not even hot warm at best & soggy.

Wow! Of course all the food here is incredible but this review is going to be about Evette... What an incredible server! We came here last Sunday with about 30 people! She handled all of us with such ease, grace and kindness...I wonder if anything ever rattles this girl! She was just so kind and patient which is just unbelievable for such a large group! I was embarrassed to even admit this, that we had so many separate checks, and how she handled that was unbelievable as well! I gave her a huge tip, I just hope my friends followed suit... Hopefully, this yelp review will give her some recognition that is well deserved! Thanks again, sweet girl!!

We haven't been here for awhile and man it was great!!! Heather is super sweet and gave us great service, we will be back soon!

Hit or miss pizza when ordering takeout. I just ordered a pizza, which was slightly undercooked. It's hard to tell but you'll notice there's no char around the pepperoni and every bite was slightly "doughy." Person taking the order over the phone also forgot my side order ranch dressing that I explicitly asked for when I arrived to pick up my order. Food is much better when dining in.

First time here. Cute, clean & our server Stephanie was friendly & efficient. But, I'm sorry to say that the quality of the food for the price was disappointing. Way too many better choices for pizza & Italian food in the Napa Valley. We probably will not return. $44 for a small pizza, salad & 1 non alcoholic drink.

Mediocre food. Absolutely nothing special. For Italian food, this is not the place to eat.

After being seated at a table at the "new" Mary's restaurant in Napa, I sat for over 25 minutes, without anybody even acknowledging my presence! NOT the way for a business to reopen!

The service is great. Positive friendly staff. Jeff the train-e was great also he did better at maintaining our drinks till after we paid. I don't like to have to ask for my drink to be filled I want the staff to fill it when less than half full or ask at that point. If I'm looking for staff and I'm holding my hands up hoping for xtra paper towels don't give an astounding look when I ask for more. The food - I felt like there was a good amount of toppings. We got a Toto's xlg, it was un- edible but hey I'm up for a challenge. I was soggy with oil for most of a slice almost to the crust but not just for one slice but for the entire pizza. I have never in my life even as a child eaten a pizza with a fork and knife. Since I couldn't pick it up , as it would tear due to the sogginess. I manned up and got the fork and knife. What a joy soggy not fully cooked veggie but the meat was a little burnt so even if I were to send it back it would have been burnt. Skip this place and go to target and get a frozen pizza for a fraction of the price. You will have a better quality pizza and fully cooked. Or take a better route and go to Phillipies grato across from the oxbow in town and have the best meat pizza of your life. And for about the same price. So we like a good refrigerator cold next day take out pizza. Seriously have the slice was still soggy after the box soaked up as much as it could lol wow way to represent the pie.

So many people have told us how good the pizza is here but we have never eaten here. We went with a group of people and I was very impressed with the menu. So many choices! And lots of gluten-free choices. I ordered the chicken Alfred with gluten-free noodles. It was delicious, and came with Mary's yummy side salad. I saw some huge great looking salads! My husband had double pepperoni pizza which was delicious! We will definitely be back!!

Hard to understand all the haters on here, we had a really pleasant experience. The place is very clean and the staff was attentive. The biggest downside is it's across the street from a carwash so outdoor seating is loud. But we enjoyed a nice sturdy clean picnic table in the shade. It's a pretty typical pizza and pasta place--the checker table cloths, big plastic soda cups, large portions, etc. and considering the price of everywhere else in Napa this place is a bargain. Nothing fancy, but certainly decent. Just note that there are different styles of pizza and crusts and someone who loves pizza napolitana or sicilian style deep dish, for example, will not enjoy the pizza here. If you like NY style big slices that you can fold, that's closer to what you'll get. Hard to dislike any place that brings me warm bread and butter without asking and offers free refills. Our pizza had a crisp bottom crust and a chewy doughy edge. It was not soggy at all. Kind of a perfect classic NY style crust. Mozzarella cheese could be saltier, but crust and tomato sauce were solid. We'd go again. And tip your servers if you do go! They even brought out water for our pup.

The lady I had serving my girls and myself was very friendly & very patient. The atmosphere was family friendly. Food was alright, but for almost $100 for a few kids pizza's & spaghetti, half lasagna, salad & bread that wasn't the best I would've expected more taste that we got. The garlic/cheese bread wasn't there at all, the kids pizzas were just okay nothing exciting, kid's spaghetti taste like what I can make at home, my half lasagna had bay leaves in it & the salad was good. I will definitely give this place another shot, though I won't get the bread again. I would recommend.

We really enjoyed our dinner here earlier this week. Mary's Combo pizza was delicious and a must have with that collection of meats. The dough they use for the pizza and breadsticks was great. I don't recall our servers name but she was great and very attentive with our non-alcoholic drinks. The only odd thing we encountered was a very low supply of alcohol. They literally had one Corona in stock, and no other beers but they did have White Claw's. This is a good option for those looking for a good dining experience from a longtime local business.

Absolutely disgusting.... Every time I've been here it's been bad... I have family that always wants to "try it one more time" no thanks.... This was the last time. Puke

We ate dinner at Mary's Pizza (Jefferson St.) last night and were very pleased! The food, including the salads, was great and with good-sized portions. The service was also excellent. We plan to eat there frequently in the future. Highly recommended.

I went in about 7:15 and was told I can't order because they are closing at 8. Then they said I could order. They thought it was funny. I walked out! There needs to be adults there because they are losing business. Really not good customer service

Having been away from NYC for a few months (i.e., forever and a day in Napa-time), I could only fight the craving for pizza for so long. I knew it wouldn't be anything special, but I had no idea it would be THIS mediocre. Nearly $40 for a small "large" pizza. The crust was undercooked bread dough. Sauce was over-seasoned. Cheese was flavorless & super stingy.

Just left having dinner here. My husband and I were craving Italian so we thought we would try this place. That was a mistake. The inside of the restaurant is clean, incredibly cute and looked like a perfect place to grab some good pizza or pasta. The food was DISGUSTING. The minestrone soup either comes with just vegetables the other option is pork. The soup was more like a chili texture, it was thick and cold. Foul. The garlic bread with cheese (pictured) literally came to our table also cold, the cheese was hard not melted but looked like it had previously been heated then sat out and was served again. It was hard and chewy covered in paprika. Also foul. Lastly, the spaghetti with the "giant" meatball. The meatball is small, nothing giant about it. Which turned out to be a good thing considering it tasted like Alpo smells if that makes sense. Dinner cost us $55, with tip. (For the pictures shown and 2 sodas.) Save your money, I already feel nauseas and full of regret but still hungry.

We want to thank Heather for wonderful service she provided our family..... it was a pleasure! My son wanted to thank you again for the delicious cookie!

Don't rely on curbside pickup: if it's busy, no-one will answer the phone and you'll have to go inside anyway. And then, if your experience is anything like mine, your pizza won't be ready for 45 minutes after your online order confirmation says it would be. Decent pizza though.

Thank you for all the years Mary's ,all the good meals ,all the good times,lots of good memories . You will be missed 2023. PS momma MARY maybe in about 5 years when things get better, come back to the valley ,you always have place in are hearts .

Should've given no Stars. We went for a late lunch around 2:00p after the lunch rush. There were only 4 tables occupied. Hostess sat us down and said our "server would be here soon." 20m went by and no server!! She managed to go to another table but completely ignored us. 5 more minutes, still no server. Decided to get up and leave, figured if it takes that long for the server to come, it would take longer for the food. Asked to speak with the manager to let him know that we were ignored. He was standing around with 3 other girls doing absolutely nothing. All he said was "thank you for letting me know" WTF!!! I guess, it's not his personal business so why bother to work... what a leader!!!! Don't waste your time. Sad to say this, but service sucked, we've been going to Mary's for over 10yrs and sad to see what it's come down to. I know it's probably due to the pandemic, but if your going to try to keep your business doors open, train your staff well, so that your doors stay open!!!! Wouldn't be surprised if they go out of business

This place is very unprofessional and racist. Me and my friend waited over an hour for our food and it never came so we decided to leave. We ordered two sodas and two pizzas. As we told the lady we were leaving because the food was taken to long and we will just pay for the sodas she said dont worry you dont owe anything. She didnt say nothing about the food we was waiting for. Beware do not go here if you are brown....( african american, indian etc)

I used to be such a huge fan of Mary's pizza shack years ago... it seems the quality has gone down significantly. Last night, I decided to give them another chance because a couple months prior I had the WORST experience but the manager was kind and offered me my next pizza free and a free entree to make up for the mess up that happened with my meal at Mary's last time. I called in and made my order and the girl who took the order was sweet. She had a kind demeanor and when I told her about the discount, she had put me on hold for 10 minutes. It's the dinner time and there were some people in the dining room so I let it slide and came in there and I came up looking for my order and it had got put in "5 minutes ago" so I quietly waited.. I got my food about 12 minutes later and it was definitely fresh which I can appreciate.. I put it on the table and I ate a bite of the meat ball and it was cold... then I proceeded to having a slice of pizza and that was nice and hot but they don't use good quality mozzarella, this cheese they use is too creamy and didn't sit well with me... it was like eating cream cheese on a pizza.. it didn't stretch .. nada... I ordered a medium and received a small pizza... salad I requested no beets, no mushrooms and no tomatoes.... There was mushrooms on my salad. I took them off myself but wasn't too excited about this. My dad said his sandwich was warm but not hot... (we live about 7 minutes from Mary's on Jefferson)... when I was on the phone with the person taking the order, she didn't give me a free pizza or free entree, she discounted my order 50% and that was nice but , the food was terrible. All in all, I was once again not happy with Mary's pizza shack and I hope the one here in Napa steps up their game and gets better cheese and make sure their food is to the correct temperature when being served. The quality has gone down hill. Upsetting for such an iconic north bay pizza chain.

I would recommend Mary's pizza for pizza alone this is the second time I've ordered something other than pizza I have to say I'm really sadly disappointed.. My lasagna was equivalent to a lean cuisine. My boyfriends chicken Parm and noodles were was tasteless. I had a better lasagne in a 2.00 lean cuisine. My lasagne had frozen spinach some kind of funk marinara a tiny bit Of hamburger. It just tasted like something you pull out of your freezer. For $18 I was really expecting something better. Mary's is known for the pizzaa stick with the pizza

This is our second trip here and we love it! The pizza is amazing, the service is stellar and on point! Both times not a bad experience at all! In fact we will be back and we visit Napa often for camping. We always order too much but we are so glad to have the leftovers! Thank you Mary's for your wonderful staff, amazing sauce recipe and the crust is to die for! Not too overloaded or heavy. Just really damn good pizza!

Garden ranch pizza is the best ! Please keep on your menu Wish Santa Rosa had it Pasta Primavera also excellent. Great presentation.

Got our coupon in the mail and decided to take advantage of it. Ordered online and was supposed to get a confirmation email but it didn't come through. Called to verify and was told my order was in process. The nice gentleman I spoke with said he'd double check the pickup time and was told it was right on. Hubby picked up with no problems. Our Toto combination was delicious! Mary's isn't where we usually get our pizza but we'll definitely be back. Also, the small garden salad was just enough to split and fresh as can be with lots of "stuff" in it.

Unbelievable. Called and made the order. All information already in the system. Money deducted from the account. Then just ok call. No delivery. Talk about incompetence. No call. Don't waste your time.

Only 6 pieces of sausage and very little bell pepper. It's been this way last 3 times. $32 for a medium.. Not acceptable :(

This was a tough call. I was greeted by a friendly young man and grabbed a seat. He continued to act as my server for the next 15-20 mins: water, beer, food order. Then the "server" stopped by and said she was sorry she couldn't stop by earlier. Huh? This gentleman that really served me even had to come by and tell me they burned my pizza and it would be 15 more minutes. They took care of the pizza which was cool and this is where it would be a 5 rating. But the lady server who is my server walks by and i ask for a menu to order a to go pizza for a friend. She says she'll be right back. 5 mins later after lackluster deliveries to other tables she comes by after i remind her i need to order so i don't have wait long.... Anyway. The first gent was great and she ranked the experience. I'll tip her a bit but gonna slide him some cash on the way out. Not cool

I used to eat here many years ago and I ordered food out tonight. I'm confused. Is fettuccine Alfredo supposed to be plain noodles with no sauce or did I get screwed? I paid like $19 for plain pasta with chunks of chicken. I don't know if this is a usual thing for this place but I won't be trying again. Too weird.

During our stay at the Napa Elks Lodge we got dinner from Mary's Pizza shack. They are open and seem to be doing a brisk business. We ordered a large two topping pizza and the large Mary's salad which was more than enough anti-pasta for two. The pizza and salad were both wonderful, although we got the food to go the service was prompt. This will be on our list When we come back in the area.

I tried something new which was 1/2 wedge salad and it was perfect. I will definitely order it again next time. One of our party had the wedge salad with Mary's vinaigrette which I will try next time. We were there for two birthday celebrations and they sang and gave out desserts. We started with the pesto breadsticks and they were very good especially dipped in ranch. The fried calamari was equally good. One of the Birthday boys (10 years old) made his own pizza. That means they bring the pizza dough and toppings and you make it at the table and they take it away to bake. I wish they had this when our kids were younger!

Got a door dash delivery and was not impressed. Ordered chicken wings and minestrone soup. The "chicken wings" were just breaded pieces of boneless chicken. Not crispy but mushy. Sauce was OK but just made them mushier. The minestrone soup was loaded with pork. Very smokey taste. I wish they noted on the menu that it had meat in it. Most minestrone soups I have had do not have meat. The garlic bread was OK. I should have just ordered pizza to see how that was.

The beer was icy cold. The salad was fantastic, really. Gnocchi was exactly the way I asked for it. Server Amber J was attentive and on target with necessary items she brought to the table. AND, the bread could be listed as a dessert. That is how tasty it was. I like Mary's in Napa and come here every time I am visiting. Bravo!

We love taking our family here. Delicious food and great family atmosphere with amazing service. Victor is so attentive in making sure our orders are always correct. Thank you for the great service.

If you are a fan of consistently undercooked pizzas, this is your jam. If they cooked a bit longer, this place would be a solid 3 star joint, but I've ordered several times (delivery) and they are consistently dough-y. When I get a pizza, I don't want to have to turn the oven to 425 so it can pre-heat while the delivery driver drvies. Hard pass until they get this resolved.

The service was worth 5 stars. But the problem was with the bottom crust of the large Toto pizza we ordered was still raw to the point we had to use forks and knives to eat 2/3a of each slice. We felt jaded for the price point and the fact this is Napa we could get way better food for that price point. We didn't complain because the servers Sierra and trainee Jack were amazing and didn't need to take the wrath the kitchen help should be getting for sending out half baked pizza. When cutting the pizza you can tell the difference between cooked and not cooked or semi cooked crust. We spent close to $60 and we could of gotten the same customer service and a fully loaded pizza with tons of cheese fully cooked from Fallipi's pizza on first street. We won't be coming back. It's a shame because we've been trying to find good back up places to host 30+ gatherings on a monthly basis.

*Walk in - sit down only review. Have not ordered take out or delivery.* I have been here twice in the last two months with my boyfriend and both times were quite lovely. Staff (5/5): Both times the waitresses were very attentive and nice. On the second visit, I asked our waitress if I could have a small bowl of spaghetti on the side and she gave it to me for free. She also came back with ranch, hot sauce, the take out box, and the check in a timely manner. Food (4.6~): Pizza (5/5): BBQ Chicken was amazing, just would add more jalapenos personally. Toto's Combo pizza was heavenly, the cheese was the perfect consistency and just *muwah* so much meat and veggies~. The slices were also well sized. Drinks (4.5/5): Ordered a Moscow Mule twice, first time it was so sweet and good, second time it was still good but a tad spicy. Spaghetti (4/5): Ordered a side of spaghetti and it was good just a tad bit too watery and the taste was a bit tangy. Free bread (5/5): Warm and soft~ Ambiance/decor/cleanliness (5/5): Something about this spot is very quaint. It has a very homey/family-welcoming vibe but there is also TVs with sports and they also sell beer, wine, and some cocktails so it also has somewhat of a sports-like vibe as well. We came here on a Monday and a Tuesday evenings and both days there was a good share of people, not too lonely and not too loud. The tables and booths were in good condition and the place was clean, including the window seals (didn't check out the bathroom). Price worth (4/5): For a dine in pizza spot, the prices are pretty average, but I don't know if a medium (8 slice) pizza is worth $25, maybe $18-20 for the size.' Overall (4.7): A very welcoming and family friendly pizza joint that has delicious pizza and good staff. Will come again. Just be prepared to pay a little bit more.