Paul H.
Yelp
Mel-O-Dee is a great venue for people wanting to have a fun time throwing back a couple of drinks and belting out a few tunes. If you have an open mind, don't mind a being a bit crowded, this place is tons of fun. I was introduced to this place over 5 years ago, and I have since become a regular.
Pros:
Large song selection. This is one of the original KJs that had bought the long song sets back in the day. They have many songs other people cannot get anymore.
Friendly staff. Always aim to please
Friendly regulars. Mel-O-Dee has allot of Karaoke OGs.
Cheap drinks. Fun drink specials. Strong but not too strong. Nothing super fancy, but for $7 a drink or $4 a beer, you are getting more than what you paid for, poured correctly, and well balanced.
You can submit a new song every time you sing, so if you get there early, you will end up singing allot. (People who come in late grumble about how others got to sing multiple songs, but it's their fault for coming in late.)
Hole-in-the-wall old-style décor that is campy, fun, and comfortable: Crushed red velvet wall paper, saloon doors to the restrooms, old style pleather lounge seats, etc.
They do party reservations.
Popular place, so allot of good singers. Some do not sing so great, but they put their heart into it, so its always fun. Others are spectacular and will make your jaw drop.
If the song queue is closed, which happens from time to time, wait it out. Towards the end, especially on weekdays, people start bailing early. IF enough people bail on their songs, you can then (Politely) ask the KJ if you might be able to squeeze a song in. (Don't forget to tip!)
Cons:
Sound system turned up too LOUD. Easily compensated by ear protection, or a bit of cocktail napkin.
Small venue that gets crowded quickly. If someone has a party going on, be prepared to have to squeeze though people and only get to sing once or twice.
If you get there late, especially on the weekend, the song queue can get filled for the night. (This is understandable, as there allot of people who come here).
Limited seating. On a crowded night, be prepared to stand.
Overall the cons are minor, and are easily overcome. This is a REALLY fun place for Karaoke... unless you are a self-entitled priss or wannabe baller who likes bling and status more than fun... then you best move on to the expensive, overpriced, private room karaoke parlors with over-priced, watered down drinks with fancy colors, fancy glass, & fancy garnishes (I mean, as long as they look fancy, you don't mind their quality, right? Dumb-ass.)
Now about the few bad reviews for this place...
I actually took the time to read through all the one star and two star reviews for this place, which are very few, and I can honestly say that almost all of the bad reviews were fluffed up bull by unreasonable people wanting more than they did not deserve for less than they should pay, were people who were jerks who had a personal problem, or happened to hit the place on that once in a blue moon off-night.
Let's face facts... there is only 1 Karaoke system set-up at this venue. If you come after 12:00 on a weekend, hand the KJ a first full of songs, don't tip, act like a jerk, and are already a bit drunk... you probably won't get to sing.
ALSO: Anyone who complains that any karaoke venue doesn't have the songs you like, or not enough of the newest songs, they need to understand that US laws with licensing and copy write for songs and lyrics have a ton of red tape. New songs are extremely difficult to make and acquire in the US. Sound Choice (now Phoenix Entertainment Partners) have been suing people who have moved their songs from CD to digital format, left and right, causing allot of road blocks for KJs to legally use the songs they have already purchased. The songs online for sale and download from the UK are mostly not legal to use at all (let alone commercially) in the USA. SO CUT THE KJs SOME SLACK, PLEASE!!!!
https://www.digitalmusicnews.com/2013/07/12/karaoke/
https://www.imaginelaw.com/top-myths-about-karaoke-cd-g-users-legal-rights.html