Vikki T.
Google
I’ve been a Mellow Mushroom fan since the 1980s — back when the Sandy Springs location at Johnson Ferry and Roswell Road was my go-to spot. So it pains me to write this. I placed a takeout order from this location for a large pizza (sausage, black olives, half mushrooms), two orders of beer cheese, and a lil’ Greek salad — just under $50 total.
To say we were disappointed is an understatement. The pizza was undercooked, the crust doughy, and there was very little sauce. About 90% of the sausage ended up on just two slices, and the mushrooms were burnt and sad-looking. The beer cheese was inedible — gritty and off-tasting. The only thing we actually finished was the salad, which was fresh and tasty.
We ended up throwing out the pizza and beer cheese, which was really disheartening. This isn’t the first time we’ve had a disappointing experience at this location, so I’ve made a mental note to stick with other locations — like the newer one in Sandy Springs — when I’m craving that classic Mellow Mushroom flavor I used to love.