Sophie B.
Yelp
This is always going to be one of my must-visits when I come to Williamsburg. I have loved this joint ever since I was a kid, and am always pleased.
That said, I haven't been to the actual restaurant in many, many years. We were NOT disappointed. We came around 4:15 pm, and the wait to be seated inside was 45 minutes - so we sat outside, which had no wait. (Keep in mind, we came on the 4th of July.) The outside area is really lovely, with plenty of fans whirling that kept us cool.
Moving on to drinks and food, I had two of the lavender groove lemonades, spiked, per the recommendation of our lovely waitress.
We split a lil' Greek salad, pretzel bites with the spicy beer cheese, and then two small half & half pies - one with buffalo chicken and funky Q, and then one with half the Marley and half Holy Shitaake.
The only pizza that was new to me was the Marley - a jerk chicken pizza. It was incredible. The rest of them are ones I had before- but I was introducing my partner to the deliciousness that is Mellow Mushroom, hence all the half & halfs. In my opinion, the Holy Shitaake reigns supreme but the Marley was a close second.
I would skip the pretzel bites next time as they filled us up a bit before the pizzas, leaving us less room for pizza. We had plenty of leftovers.
Service was great - our waitress was attentive and just really lovely, despite how busy it was. I appreciated her recommendations and everything went great.
The wait times may seem intimidating, but I promise it's worth it.