Sandi H.
Yelp
I have very mixed feelings about my experience with MelroseMac--because ultimately, I got what I wanted (data recovery). They were successful. But it was an incredibly stressful experience.
I really liked the Melrose Avenue storefront atmosphere and didn't have to wait very long to see someone at the counter. I explained what I needed for my MacBook laptop and it appeared to be no problem. I gave them my existing backup drive and told them they could just delete any old backups to make room on it if they needed to. I asked how long it would take, and the counter rep said, "Eh, 2/3 days. Maybe tomorrow."
That was on August 23, 2021. I just got my data recovery back today, October 6.
On August 26, I called to check status. They said he's working on it. On August 27, I called to check status. They said he's working on it. I asked if they could check and see exactly what's happening, and they called me back to say the technician was still working on it and they didn't know if he would get to it that day or the following Monday but they would reach out when it was completed.
On August 31, they called to tell me my backup drive was full and asked if I would authorize the purchase of a new one from them. I said yes, and I waited.
On September 2, I called to check status and they said he's working on it. I begged them for more information, telling them that it had been 8 days. I was on the verge of tears on the phone, and they just said they'd call if there was a problem.
On September 3 before the Labor Day holiday weekend, I went into the store and asked to talk to a manager. Fortunately, the manager was right there (I think her name was Veronica?), so I was able to tell her that I was just looking for a straight answer as to what was going on with my computer, as it was Day 9 at that point. She looked up my account and told me that the data recovery job was beyond their capabilities at that location but that they could transfer it to their Burbank location if I authorized them to do so and paid $100 deposit. I gave them the go-ahead and paid the deposit, but the manager advised me that their transport wouldn't be able to bring my laptop to Burbank until the following Tuesday, September 7 and that it would take Burbank at least 3-4 weeks just for diagnostics.
I'll write a separate review for my experience with the Burbank location as my Melrose location experience pretty much ended there (other than confirming by phone on Sept 9 that the laptop had indeed been transferred to Burbank). But here are some final thoughts.
I went to MelroseMac because it was an authorized Mac repair shop, but the whole process felt shady like I went to some back alley computer repair place. I think they need to work on managing expectations much better -- had I known how long it was going to take (and how much money it ended up being in the end), I might've taken it elsewhere or tried to sled the hard drive myself. I get the impression that every time they told me the service tech was working on it, he wasn't really working on it -- and that just ramped up my anxiety.
I also don't 100% trust that the data recovery actually WAS that complicated or required as much money as I ended up paying. But because it feels like I was lied to -- and definitely kept in the dark -- they never really earned my trust in the first place.
I wonder how long it would've taken them to call me with the update I got when I walked into the store in person. When were they planning to tell me they needed to transfer to Burbank? So much for calling if there was a problem.
If time isn't important, and you don't suffer from anxiety, MelroseMac is probably OK. I'd already done an online support session directly with Apple and had taken my laptop to the Genius Bar, so I felt like I'd exhausted my other options. And I am happy with the final result. But it's been a rollercoaster ride and over 6 weeks of misery (and A LOT of money).