Ryan M.
Yelp
I am disappointed to see that Mezquite -- arguably one of the finest Mexican restaurants in San Antonio -- has received such a mixed response on Yelp and Google. Many of the one-star reviews I read in preparation for my review are laughable (e.g., "There were flies buzzing around!" "My server wouldn't give me endless refills of soda, waaaaaaaaa!!!"). I mention all of this because I humbly ask you, Dear Reader, to take Mezquite's middling 3.5-star average with a huge grain of salt. In fact, take it with a snow shovel of salt. If you trust only one person on this site, let it be me! After all, I probably dine out more than anyone else in San Antonio. I'm also a rare breed on Yelp in that I possess both the culinary insight and the expressive ability to compose a review that's readable, engaging, and reflective of a true gourmand! When I tell you, Dear Reader, that Mezquite is worth your patronage, you should heed my recommendation with haste! I shall now tantalize you with a few choice items from my recent visit. Enjoy!
Chips and salsa (5.0/5.0): As with everything at Mezquite, the chips and salsa are made from scratch on the premises. The chips were crispy, thick, warm, and seasoned liberally with sea salt. Of the two salsas (served in cute little squeeze bottles), I preferred the acidic punch and piquancy of the green tomatillo salsa. The orange-yellow salsa came across like more of an emulsion of mayonnaise, chipotle, and lime. Though tasty on its own, the orange-tinted salsa sprang to life when mixed with the green salsa. Try it and impress your tablemates that you took Ryan M.'s advice!
Nachos (5.0/5.0): These were unequivocally the best nachos I've ever eaten. That speaks volumes coming from me, a true connoisseur of the humble nacho! The thick corn tortilla chips (same as the ones served with salsa) held up under a mountain of creamy white queso, pinto bean sauce, pico de gallo, and a generous portion of tender Wagyu carne asada. Like every restaurant at The Pullman Market, the meat is sourced locally and butchered on site. One reviewer complained that the carne asada was tough, which is absolute hogwash. Every morsel comprised equal parts lime-based marinade and char from the mesquite grill. If you order only one dish as Mezquite, let it be these nachos.
Pollo a la parrilla (5.0/5.0): Though not mentioned on the menu, the organic free-range chicken is sourced locally, butchered on site, and grilled over mesquite, imparting a rich smokiness that permeated every piece, even the breast. The skin on the thigh was rendered crispy, resulting in an umami bomb of charred fat, acid, salt, and smoke. The accompanying pipian rojo consisted of pureed pumpkin seeds and dried red chilis. The pumpkin seeds imparted a subtle nuttiness to the dish, while the red chilis contributed a subtle dry heat.
Chocolfan (5.0/5.0): Most flans have a tendency to be cloyingly sweet, but this iteration cut the sweetness with plenty of high-quality dark chocolate and a subtle smokiness from guajillo peppers. A crown of crumbled queso fresco added touch of salt and a welcome textural contrast. If this description strikes you as familiar, then you probably noticed that my photo of the chocoflan is the featured photo (as of June 24, 2024) on Mezquite's Yelp page.
Several one-star reviews mention poor service, but that again is total baloney; I experienced nothing but friendly, ingratiating, attentive service from the moment I approached the hostess station until the time I walked out of the building.
I cannot recommend Mezquite highly enough. Before you visit The Pullman Market, read my review and plan your own little culinary adventure. Take it from someone who has sampled a wide variety of items from every restaurant -- both full-service and casual -- at The Pullman: you will not be disappointed!