Mi Estrella Bakery

I called to order a cake she told me to send her a picture of the cake I wanted. When we spoke on the phone I told her I want the $60 cake. When I sent her the picture she changed the price and I told her that I wanted just the color of the cake like that and that I wanted a regular size cake. After that, she never replied to me, I ask her nicely to let me know anything because it was late already and I need the cake for the next day. She never had the courtesy to give me an answer. Bad customer service.I hope the owner looks into this.

One word. Delicious. Went on a late Friday night for an end of the week treat and it sure delivered. The staff was sweet and accommodating. I decided to try the vanilla tres leches slice which was more than reasonably priced at 5$ Wanted to try their chocolate strawberry but they were sold out. Well there’s always next time.

One of my favorite Mexican Bakery, in the area. Their cake are great! I buy oreo 3 leches, pineapple topped with coconut flakes, cake and Strawberry 3 leches as well. So creamy, and fresh! Great prices! I recommend!

Excellent bakery! Cash only. They wrote things on the cake at no cost. The cake I got was $30 which is very affordable for the quality of the cake and I got it last minute. Everyone talked about how great the cake tasted. I have not used this place for custom made cakes but I only assume it will be awesome.

This bakery’s cake is really good but the service is really bad there are these two lady’s that give attitude for no reason and they charge you extra for a inspo cake you may want or they just will tell you that they do not know that character or won’t do it for you. I went to that bakery and I was in a very happy mood to just buy a simple cake for my nieces as a welcome back. But the service is really bad the 2 lady’s that are there. Although the cakes are delicious.

This tres leches cake was BOMB. Great texture and was delicious! The cake itself is a sponge that was perfect, just a bit too sweet for my likeing. The top cake needed to be soked a bit longer but the bottom cake made up for it. Would have liked a bit more strawberries... But a definite repurchase 👍🏼 Don't even get me started with the flan...repurchase!

You guys sell 2/3/4 layers cake without the Box That’s crazy How you say it’s good an fresh with open cake That’s rough Business Thanks

This Bakery is one of my favorite places.... They make an amazing tres leches cake and I get most of my case if not all of them from this place my family and friends always ask me to get them cakes from here. I have send them numerous new customers that have taste their cake and fall in love with it, just like I did. If you are looking for a delicious, soft and creamy tres leches or even a quadruple leches cake this is the place. And their customers service is amazing.... they made a super special cake for our wedding everyone gave us compliments on how tasty the cake was. Muchas gracias por un trabajo excepcional y delicioso.

the best tres leches cake in all of Brooklyn!! Made my birthday so special with their kindness and you can tell they truly have a love and passion for making their desserts!

Might be the best tres leches / secret gem in NYC - their cakes are super moist and just enough level of sweetness

Came here to get their flan. W flan fr it had me creaming all over the place. I highly recommend will come back again

We were so happy with our birthday cake for our son's first birthday. It was exactly as we ordered it and it tasted DELICIOUS. Also, the staff was super nice. Can't wait to order another one. Nos encantó! Muchísimas gracias! :)

I've randomly tasked myself with finding the best tres leches in my neighborhood, and this bakery was highly recommended to me by someone who has lived here for 25 years. Firstly, the staff is super nice and the first time I walked in (I've been here three times in the last week), the guy at the counter said that whoever recommended me is probably a frequent visitor because once you try the cakes, it's hard to quit (where is the lie?). Anyway, like I said, I've been back multiple times because now I want to try ALL their flavors. So far, I've had their vanilla, guava, peach, chocoflan, and oreo. All were delicious, although I definitely favor the vanilla cake based ones more, as they seem to soak up the milks better. Additionally, the portions are HUGE for the price. Most slices are about $4 (Cash only by the way) and can easily be shared between 2-3 people. There's not much else to this bakery besides tres leches (i think they make flan), which means they are pretty damn good at making it. I definitely recommend.

Went one week in advance to order a cake for my birthday , it was a simple cake that I saw on display . It was nothing customized . They gave me the wrong design cake . Same flavor I wanted and the correct name but not at all the design that I picked out. They would not give me a refund .

Great tasting cake... tres leches is the way to go. Nice and moist and great customer service

This spot is a lifesaver! They have a large supply of tresleche cakes in many flavors. Found myself in a pinch for a party and walked in and I was pleasantly surprised...... And the cake was delicious

Came by from a recommendation from another baker for a tres leches cake. Super quaint family business. Took a risk for my wife's birthday cake and we were all super impressed. Will shop here again!

Yum their tres leches was phenominal bought 2 in a month will be going back for a third

The best bakery on Wyckoff Avenue! I always order my cakes from them. They have the best cakes! They make your vision come true. Great service! Very efficient & would recommend them to anyone!