Keith Carey
Google
Mike’s American Restaurant
Started the night with shrimp and crab fritters — only three of them, but each one was a knockout. Crispy, flavorful, paired with corn salsa and sauce, and plated beautifully. That dish really set the tone for what I expected to be a high-end meal, and it didn’t disappoint on presentation.
For my entrée, I went with the pecan-crusted trout. The two fillets were cooked perfectly, and the flavor was spot on. The grilled broccolini that came with it was fresh and tasty, but here’s the catch: that’s all that came with it. For the price, I expected a little more substance on the plate. A starch — wild rice, roasted potatoes, something hearty — would have rounded the dish out. As it stood, I left the table still hungry, even with the appetizer.
The service, though, was impeccable. My server, Raimun, was outstanding — attentive without hovering, knew the menu inside and out, and even had an iced tea in front of me before I thought to ask. That kind of detail really stood out.
The atmosphere was polished and upscale, fitting for the style of restaurant. The only real drawback outside of portion size was the location of the restrooms. Being on the third floor meant a trip to the basement via elevator (or stairs, if you’re feeling ambitious) anytime nature called. Not the most convenient setup.
All that said, I’d go back. The food quality and service were excellent, the ambiance was nice, and with a little more balance on the plate, this would’ve been a home run.