Milk N Cookies

Stopped in tonight to grab some cookies and had such a great experience! I didn’t catch the young gentleman’s name, but he was incredibly kind, knowledgeable, and communicative. You could tell he really cared about making the customer experience a great one. The cookies were absolutely delicious, but his friendly attitude made the whole visit even better. Give that kid a raise!

The store guy, Jimmy, was super cool and friendly when my friend and I asked questions about the cookies and milkshakes they offered. We liked our order a lot. My friend likes things that aren't overtly sweet and was recommended the cookie: oatmeal apple pie. She loved it! I got the cookie: Red velvet. That has white chocochip and has a filling of cream cheese icing. It was good! And the cookies were still warm. Yummy!

Really tasty! The stuffed red velvet cookie was the perfect level of sweetness. I honestly expected a sugar bomb but that wasn’t the case at all. The cheesecake stuffed filling was chewy and soft, but the cookie completely maintained its crispiness on the outside. Also the cookies and cream milkshake was liquid Oreo. 10/10. Highly recommended.

My boyfriend and I have been here so many weekends since they first opened and have enjoyed our orders every single time!! Their cookies are warm and so sweet and their ice cream, with and without the cereal mix, is so good! The staff are always so warm and inviting and very knowledgeable in all the cookies. We can't wait to come back soon for our cookie fix!

We stopped by here after dinner, as we've been meaning to try this place since they opened. We were welcomed by friendly staff, and the place was spacious and clean with several tables you can sit at. We tried the S'mores, Funfetti, Cookie Monster, and Churro with caramel. They were still nice and warm, with a soft middle/inside and crunchy outside. It went well with a scoop of creamy vanilla bean ice cream at home. Definitely a must-try and great addition to local dessert places to visit.

Stopped by this location as we visited Jersey and did not disappoint! Arya answered every question of ours as we did have a lot (lol) but definitely made suggestions and assured us the cookies were all very good and we believed him! Thank you for the customer service!

Let me first start by saying the apple pie cookie was very tasty topped with vanilla ice cream and a raspberry drizzle. My only caveat was that the outer parts of the cookie were very hard, almost impossible to break apart and enjoy with the plastic spoon provided. The middle was very soft and easier to break away while enjoying my cookie and ice cream.

We are so glad this opened up so close!!! Went in for the first time and loved it, even had a glass of milk which I got scared and thought they didnt have but the moment you ask they keep it in the back and not in the fridge up front. They have lots of cookies, cant wait to try the marshmallow one yummmm, they also have a whole cereal bar plus milkshakes. Def recommended!! Favorite was Oreo Cheesecake & Smores, not very fond of the churro ones I guess I thought it would be more of a churro texture, it's more like a sugar cookie. Overall delicious!!!