MilkMade Tasting Room

Ice cream shop · Carroll Gardens

MilkMade Tasting Room

Ice cream shop · Carroll Gardens

1

204 Sackett St, Brooklyn, NY 11231

Photos

MilkMade Tasting Room by null
MilkMade Tasting Room by null
MilkMade Tasting Room by null
MilkMade Tasting Room by null
MilkMade Tasting Room by null
MilkMade Tasting Room by null
MilkMade Tasting Room by null
MilkMade Tasting Room by null
MilkMade Tasting Room by null
MilkMade Tasting Room by null
MilkMade Tasting Room by null
MilkMade Tasting Room by null
MilkMade Tasting Room by null
MilkMade Tasting Room by null
MilkMade Tasting Room by null
MilkMade Tasting Room by null
MilkMade Tasting Room by null
MilkMade Tasting Room by null
MilkMade Tasting Room by null
MilkMade Tasting Room by null

Highlights

MilkMade is a cozy gem dishing out unique, artisanal ice cream flavors that keep locals coming back for more, including delightful seasonal options.  

Featured in Eater
Placeholder
Placeholder

204 Sackett St, Brooklyn, NY 11231 Get directions

milkmadeicecream.com

$$

Information

Static Map

204 Sackett St, Brooklyn, NY 11231 Get directions

milkmadeicecream.com

$$

Features

Tap to pay

Last updated

Jul 11, 2025

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2025 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@eater

"A place where Steve Cuozzo enjoyed the vanilla ice cream." - Kayla Kumari Upadhyaya

Mario Batali-Backed Suburban Grocery Market Will Close Thursday - Eater NY
View Postcard for MilkMade Tasting Room

Camille Sanches

Google
Edit: I’ve gone to MilkMade multiple times since my first review and each time it’s a hit! I am never disappointed and love going back to try the new flavors. My fridge is also home to many MilkMade magnets. MilkMade is amazing! I can't stop going back. All of their s'mores flavors with summer were incredible, the ice cream itself is such great quality. My only complaint is that the coffee cookie dough ice cream didn't have enough cookie dough for my taste. Definitely would recommend.

Erin Lee

Google
Visit 3: I came back again because today I was greeted by not 1 but 2 dairy-free flavors! A tasty Vegan Chocolate Coconut Blizzard and a mind-blowing Apple Cider Sorbet! Almost wish the month wouldn’t end so I could eat this one all the time...even though I can’t wait to try what’s up next! Upping my review to 5 stars! — Visit 2: I just stopped by last night and they didn’t have any sorbetto flavours to my chagrin. It sounded like they had consistency issues and decided against serving inferior product. A little sad since I was looking forward to a treat. — Visit 1: As good as gelato get's outside Italy. I'm dairy free but thankfully they always have at least one sorbetto available! The seasonal quince flavor was delightful - it's an unusual fruit that is reminiscent of honey.

Karisma Nelson

Google
The ice cream I had was one of the best tasting ice creams I ever had! It was the Pumpkin stracciatella hazelnut flavor that is seasonal and I definitely need to go back before it goes away. I loved their flavored cones too. This place is definitely on my list of faves now!

Doraemon

Google
Strawberry curd - so fruity and creamy! I also tried April flavor Yuzu, fleshing and citrus. Friend got chocolate with five spice, very interesting and creative. The flavor is quite complex. Their colorful cones make the ice cream even more cute and tempting!

Eric Morris

Google
Delicious ice cream, will be back to try new flavors. Coconut was amazing, as well as the prospect perk and the caramel. Packed with locals and a long line but worth the wait. Will be visiting here instead of other similarly priced ice cream shops in the future! Loyalty card a nice touch and service was great.

Gabriel Flores (Gabo)

Google
The place has artesanal icecream. Different flavours and combinations. Small cozy place. It is kind of pricy but I think it is okay because the artesanal approach and the variety of flavours combination.

Ming Zhang

Google
The ice cream here was amazing! Came with the girlfriend and ordered the tasting flight because we couldn't decide what we wanted. Turned out to be a great decision! The cones are all different flavors and the ice cream (they change flavors every so often) were all delicious! Will definitely be making a stop here again!

Isabella Burke

Google
Best ice cream ever! I go to milk made practically every week! I used to think ice cream was OK but milk made brought by love of the treat to another level. Favorite flavors: Brooklyn Ambrosia, Gotham Basil Chip, Cookie Dough, and China town chocolate. The cones are also very good. Unique flavors and kind staff. Please support this wonderful business and eat lots of ice cream!