Kimberly K.
Yelp
This not a Country Club at all. There is no elite membership. There is no tennis. There is no pool. There is no golf. There is no dress code. There is no gift shop. It IS pricey, but hey, who comes to a place called "Country Club" expecting "inexpensive"? Please, don't be that moron.
Plain and simple, this is a meat PALACE where the entertainment and the appeal is YOU cooking your enormous meat at a grill surrounded by friends and family. Sure, you could be doing this at home, but you are probably on vacation in Beaver Creek or Vail, so you are far, far away from your own grill. Besides, how many times have you let friends and family cook on YOUR grill. (We all know that you have "one hottt grill".)
So, to recap, it IS pricey AND you cook it yourself. Get over it. Who comes to a place where everyone KNOWS you cook it yourself and then complains that they have to cook it themselves? Please, don't be that moron.
I dined at the Minturn Country Club. Ten of us, 5 adults and 5 kiddos - two 5-year olds and three 10-year olds. Potential train wreck. One five- year old spilled a large trough of ketchup on the floor and then crawled through it. One ten-year old took a picture of said five-year old, wouldn't show it to her, removed the memory card, acted younger than the youngest child, threw a temper tantrum...
Our waiter, Evan, was there with a stack of napkins, fresh beverages, a fork to replace the one dropped into the ketchup on the floor... He was graceful and made sure every age was satisfied by the end of the meal.
I saw a lot of families here, cooking together, laughing together, and doing what families do together. I saw an engaging bartender entertain 5 hungry children with his sleight of hand as we were waiting for our drinks to arrive. Magical.
You come here for the entertainment of watching family and friends cook large slabs of great meat themselves... family style sides, family style atmosphere. The only one you have to blame for a bad steak is yourself. You want it Medium Rare? Eight minutes a side. You cook it. You want a $120 bottle of red wine at the fine wine price of $60 (sounds like "turducken") that you can sip on during the entire cooking-eating-observing-ketchup-temper tantrum time? You drink it.
Skip the salad. It is included with the entree and all-you-can-eat but I took one glance and kept walking. Uninspired light green lettuce not befitting the history of Minturn (in the 1920s Minturn was known as the "lettuce capital of the United States"), bacon bits, chickpeas (as opposed to those fashionable "chic" peas), cottage cheese... YaaaaAAWN! If you are wanting leftovers, eat all you can.
A romantic date spot this is not. I questioned the good judgement of a young couple sitting at the table next to us. Somewhere between our table's squeals of magical delight, the ketchup bath, the temper tantrum... I am imagining either a discussion about birth control or a choosing of the first baby's name, depending on current level of commitment. THEN I SAW IT. The dessert that they had chosen had ALL 20 of our eyes on it... it was as large as a baby's head!
This was by far the best dessert that I never had. NEVER. "The Minturn Tater" named after a large spud, but could have been named "The Minturn Baby Head" ... cookies and cream rolled in cocoa powder, smothered in whipped cream, chocolate sauce, and sprinkled with toasted almonds. They ate the whole thing.
Minturn boomed in the late 1800s because of the Railroad and also the mining prospects long, LOOOONG before Vail and Beaver Creek were a glimmer in any developer's eye. Today, Minturn is a small town of about 1,000 people that is firmly ensconced in tourism.
Six Important Facts:
1. Beaver Creek to Minturn is about 15 minutes and Vail to Minturn is about 10 minutes.
2. Kid friendly, group friendly, family friendly.
3. Full Bar. Bartender is magical. #3 follows #2 for a reason.
4. Arrive between 5:00-6:20 if you do not want to wait for a table.
5. Top 5 meats include a 12 oz Kobe Filet ($44.95), 16 oz USDA Prime ($38.95), a 16 oz USDA NY strip, 22 oz Porterhouse T-bone ($35.95) and a very Large Filet Mignon ($38.95) but you can also get slow cooked baby back ribs that THEY cook ($21.95), Lemon Chicken Breast ($11.95)...
6. Best sides include Side Sweet Potato Fries ($3.50), Onion Rings ($3.75), and Twice Baked Potato ($3.75).
MY COMPLIMENTS TO THE CHEF.