Robert M.
Google
I really want to love this hotel. It is a beautiful old building, with lots of amenities that are quite nice. It has great old architecture. Every room is different. The location is great, you can go for walks and go to a variety of places within walking distance. The pool and gym are quite good. The food and drinking options on site are pretty good.
But as a hotel, I would say give it a pass, unless you can sleep like the dead. I have been here many times for work, so it's not like we have a choice. It is a great old building, but that does not make it a good hotel. If you are trying to get sleep, or get anything done, you will be in trouble.
There is zero sound isolation. That's probably expected. It's an old building without updated windows or anything, so bring ear plugs and a sound machine or whatever you need. But even for an old building, it is extremely bad. Just right now, I keep hearing something rolling above me and it literally vibrates the floor in MY room.
The sound is one thing, the air conditioning is another. Many hotels, especially older buildings, have pretty weak air conditioning that just can't keep up. This one can keep up, but it is throttled severely, and I have tested this in multiple rooms and multiple stays, Even if you set it at 60, it cuts off at 71 to 72°. Ask any sleep expert, you should be sleeping in a cool room in the '60s for adequate sleep, especially if you have to be up early.
Minus another star for non-fitted sheets. So when you are tossing and turning at night because it is too warm / clammy and noisy in the room, you're going to get tangled up in the top sheet as a bottom sheet.
The final nail in the coffin, the Wi-Fi. 1.7 Mbps Is the best I have seen so far. Usually it's less than one. That's bad for even DSL. And this isn't an old building problem with dense walls or whatever. Clearly they aren't dense given the noise issues. But the signal of the Wi-Fi itself is strong enough. They just have horrible internet here. So when you're laying awake trying to sleep in the warm, noisy room, you'll have to hope your cell phone can perform on its network, were you will have nothing to stream either.
Oh, before I go, the bathrooms. They aren't updated, that's not a problem. But some of them have windows... IN THE SHOWER. Frosted glass privacy windows? Nope. I had one where the window was just at head level, so I could look out on the street, okay fine. Hope no one has a drone flying around. But one of the last times I was here, there was a full size window in the shower. It had a super thin curtain hanging over it. But if that thing falls, the people in the pool are getting a nice view. I also suspect that your shadow is quite defined seeing as the curtain is right next to you.
I hate to be the detractor of the good review scores, but I have to believe that most of them aren't from people who actually stayed here.