Mitchell's Fish Market

This place is great! I’ve been here multiple times each time the food is great, environment is enjoyable, the staff for the most part are very friendly! On this specific occasion when we went our waitress Kristy, was phenomenal, very quick, very personable, great people person which makes for an outstanding experience, you’ll be really lucky to have her as ur waitress! I definitely suggest coming here for dinner!

Mitchell's is my favorite restaurant in the Pittsburgh area! I just relocated from Boston and the service, food, and vibe has been amazing and reminiscent of Boston minus the weather of course. The prices cannot be beat, and everything is good on the menu. The staff are amazingly friendly, and attentive. The decorations and seats are comfortable, and the food is delicious. They have a wonderful rewards programs, daily deals, and great happy hour drinks. If you are in the area, this restaurant cannot be missed! I have gone weekly for the last three weeks, and I'm even more impressed with the food, friendliness of the staff, and service every time! Please come check out this lovely restaurant in the Galleria!

We had a fantastic experience at Mitchell’s Fish Market! From the moment we walked in, the service and atmosphere were warm and welcoming. A special shout-out goes to Cassie, the manager, who stopped by our table to check in. She was so genuine, personable, and clearly cares about making sure guests have a wonderful time—we really loved talking with her. Our server, Laura, was equally outstanding. She was knowledgeable about the menu, gave us great recommendations, and made everything feel effortless. Her friendly, attentive service really elevated the evening. The food was excellent—we started with the artichoke dip, which was creamy and flavorful, and then tried the new lobster ravioli, which was absolutely delicious and perfectly prepared. All around, it was an exceptional dining experience. Between the delicious food, attentive staff, and Cassie and Laura making us feel truly valued, we’ll definitely be back!

I was surprised at the size of the restaurant. I feel the dishes need to be updated. My fish was dry, frankly needed to have some sauce and the mash potatoes were simply below par. The two desserts were really good. With a little care in execution this restaurant could be back up to the top.

Always have an amazing experience when I dine in! The lobster bisque is flavorful and has a nice balance of bisque and lobster pieces! The Lobster & Shrimp Stuffed Cod is delicious, and is complemented by melt-in-your-mouth mashed potatoes and perfect asparagus! I also paired it with three pieces of the Bacon Wrapped BBQ Shrimp, which has a hint of spice but packed with flavor, enhanced by the sesame seeds. My experience is always delightful! Excellent staff, great food, and awesome atmosphere! Highly recommend!

Recently had dinner at Mitchell’s at the bar. I had the house salad with a crab cake ( not on menu so make sure you ask for it). So delicious! The bartenders Teri and Jay were exceptional. They were very attentive with their service despite the bar being completely full. Dez was the manager on duty who made sure everything was to our satisfaction. The entire staff went above and beyond. Highly recommend.

Christian was a fantastic server from the get-go and we truly enjoyed his humorous banter throughout the evening. The Spicy Crispy Shrimp appetizer started the evening off perfectly and the drinks were sufficient. The Crabcake and Shrimp and Stuffed Cod entrees were fantastic although the potatoes were somewhat stiff and room temperature. The chocolate Buttercake and Creme Brûlée were wonderful...thank you for an excellent "date night" experience! The only disappointment was that Happy Hour didn't apply to the dining room, but we understand the premise.

We did the Mother’s Day entree special, and got the dynamic duo, and the seared scollop risotto. The food was good, but nothing particularly good to write home about. There was ZERO deviation from the menu allowed at all. I ordered a salad, and wanted to order an extra soup on the side. That was not allowed. The only menu allowed for the day, was the Mother’s Day menu, which was much smaller than the regular menu. Our waitress was not rude, but we did feel “rushed” every time she came by our table. Yet, despite that, our order took forever to come out. We got seated around 2pm, and our desserts did not arrive on the table until it was 4:27 pm. (The final course of our meal). The long wait, with the level of service provided is disappointing.