Malcolm J.
Yelp
I'm not sure what happened but I thought I posted my review of Mitch's earlier today but it seems to have gotten lost, or maybe I didn't actually post it or YELP did not print in when the owner complained.
So here it is again to the best of my memory.
The shrimp cocktail was the hit of the night while the sea bas was the sour note of the night. We all loved the very delicious shrimp cocktail and the wonderful red sauce accompaniment. As to the sea bass, fish is supposed to be served with a flaky texture. Unfortunately, this sea bass was a big disappointment as it had very little flavor and no texture. Much has been written about some restaurants serving "Sea Bass" that is not real sea bass but just some white fish. While I certainly can not say whether or not this sea bass was real sea bass I can say it was unworthy.
JUST ADDED on 11/10/2025."I did some research on the internet and found a large number of sites, including AI, all of which described sea bass as "firm and flaky". This fish at Mitch's was anything but firm and flaky. It practically melted in your mouth as soon as it hit your tongue. No chewing required." That leaves only three possibilities in my opinion for the lack of texture and firmness and it could be any one of these three or any combination of them. 1) The fish was improperly cooked; 2) The fish was not fresh; 3) The fish was not genuine sea bass.
FYI: "Sea bass is a marine fish in the family Serranidae and order Perciformes. There are about 475 species in this family."
My wife ordered the pork chop which she said was delicious, juicy and properly cooked. And she loved the potato it came with. However, it was my opinion that, while the pork chop was a good cut it was poorly seasoned. It is also my opinion that Mitch's does not employ trained chefs but uses off the street line cooks. Again, I cannot say for sure as I am only guessing.
BELIEVE IT OR NOT, somehow the owner, Mr. Epstein(SP?) got a hold of my post which I don't think was posted, and called me on the phone.
I assumed he wanted to discuss my review, which I was happy to do, as two adults, and thought maybe he called to apologize for the fish. I initially felt like this especially as my review was measured and definitely said some good and some bad things about his restaurant. Was I ever wrong!
After telling me who he was his tone changed to angry and he began yelling at me (my wife witnessed this as she was in the room) and said he was very insulted that I said his fish was not real sea bass which I NEVER said. As I did not appreciate his yelling at me or the fact that he outright lied about my review I hung up on him.
While Shakespeare wrote,... "The lady doth protest too much, me thinks"., I think this is an appropriate thought for Mr. Epstein. And, I think Mr. Epstein would benefit greatly from an anger management class and learning how to properly and appropriately deal with dissatisfied customers..
I don't know if YELP intends to publish my response to Jamie S although they published hers so I am adding my response below.
I'm not sure why you found my comments and thoughts "both offensive and disrespectful to suggest that our culinary team--made up of highly trained and experienced professionals--are "off the street line cooks." but I think "disappointing" would not have been insulting as your words were. I have eaten at many restaurants with highly trained and experienced staff and their names, previous restaurants where they cheffed, their accomplishments, awards and accolades are almost always prominently displayed on the menu. There was no such display on yours. Restaurants tend to want to brag about their staff when they can. Again, as with Mr. Epstein, I felt attacked by you just for voicing my opinions. While I definitely intended no disrespect or offense, at the same time I'm certainly entitled to my opinions. Also, I noticed that you did not include any certificates for your staff as to cooking schools attended and completed or a list of their culinary backgrounds and experiences. Basically, your statement that your staff are "highly trained and experienced professionals" is just your opinion, just like my comments were just my opinion. I never claimed to be an expert on either subject and allowed for the possibility that I was wrong on my assessments. While your reply was assuredly at least somewhat acceptable, unlike your boss, Mr. Epstein, whose attitude and words were completely unacceptable, it is my opinion that you both need to learn better communication skills especially with customers who voice some disappointments with your restaurant.