Chris C.
Yelp
Having respect for locations that are sort of upper crust and provide a view and good ambience in addition to good food, I understand the appeal of the Montgomery Inn. It's sort of well known locally that ballplayers will come over after games at Great American Ballpark to eat there (although the maitre'd said they typically hide them in a secluded area so fans can't see or interact with them). I'd heard people rave about the food. So I went.
I don't want to say I was woefully disappointed, but this was not a very good experience. It's a nice enough place, but the only parking is valet, which adds to the price. It was a very overcast, cool, rainy day, so the view of the Ohio River from the upstairs room wasn't all that great. The service was ok.
I guess my big beef is that I really enjoy BBQ, and this just wasn't all that good. I eat at various BBQ places near where I live, and I've had it in Memphis, St. Louis, and throughout Texas. So I know what real BBQ is. This was good - the rib meat tasted fresh. But honestly the ribs, the sauce, the macaroni and cheese on the side, the iced tea, it was all just ok.
And the rib platter was an entree priced at $27.99, and that's not for a full slab.
So I will probably never eat here again. That's a ridiculous price for fairly mediocre ribs. I'd rather find a hole-in-the-wall kind of place, have the real deal, and probably spend 25% less on the check.