Rod S.
Yelp
This place was a bear to find. The sign above the place was burned out and it gives a different name on the door. Not such a good start. However, this place just has to have the best food in town.
Interestingly, we had to work to get drinks and wine with dinner, but when we did, they did a great job. The "wine" list may just be several generic names, but the "Chianti" was not some jug wine. It was quite good and went well with the food. I can tell the whole COVID thing has thrown the bar part for a loop. My wife got her drink just fine. I asked for a Manhattan and asked what choices I had for a top shelf drink. They said they had some Booker's. Great. When it came, it was pretty small and even though it was in a cocktail glass, there was some ice placed in it as though it was kind of on the rocks. Weird. When I tasted it, it was strong, and I didn't taste any real sweet vermouth flavor, or bitters. The drink was made by our server, and I asked what was in it, and he said the right things. I was thrown off. I'm going through this because it has an interesting ending.
This appears to be a pretty standard red sauce Italian joint. In Ely, you only expect so much. Then, they started bringing the food. The calamari appetizer was very lightly breaded and not overcooked at all. It was a pleasure. The pasta dishes were properly al dente. The shrimp never overcooked. Everything was a pleasure.
The real treat was dessert. They had cannolis. These were not huge things that are getting soggy. They don't stuff them with ice cream. This is a proper cannoli. I don't think I've had one of those since being in Manhattan, and that's been years. It was a perfect end to a meal. But it got better.
I just couldn't let the Manhattan thing go. I asked if he used high proof Bourbon instead of regular Bourbon. He said he wasn't sure. It was the end of the bottle and he went over to the bar and looked. I had almost fogotten Booker's is all cask strength. I have some at home, and it's strong. Sure enough, it's 126 proof. That will throw off any drink. It may not have tasted standard, but it was very good. It was a $90 a bottle Bourbon.
I'd come back in a second. They are a treasure.