Mr Softee - Nathan's Famous Hot Dogs - Arthur Treachers

Little piece of my Long Island childhood only an hour away from where I live now. Nathan's and Mr Softee it doesn't get any better than that. Had a Dad-children day on Long Island on way home took them here. The ice cream and milkshake were like I remembered. Great time has by all 3 of us. Highly recommend and you will see us again.

Overall nice experience, food was as good as expected and staff were friendly. The dining section did seem a little dirty however, the high chair for example, was too slimy to use. Prices are too high.

We ordered six takeaways of vanilla Mr. Softee; however, the flavor did not match the original Mr. Softee taste. This suggests the machine mix was not prepared properly.

First time going to this new spot and I am extremely disappointed and don’t think I will be returning again. I asked for a small cup of ice cream with hot fudge and the server told me he needed to put it in a larger cup so it did not over flow. I was given the smallest single scoop of melted ice cream that I was charged 6.50 for. I should have handed it back and walked out! Completely shocked. This was a joke. Was basically the size of a pup cup from Starbucks.

Went in close to closing for some Mr. Softee and Curtis was phenomenal! Absolutely amazing to talk to, what a great guy! Will definitely be back soon for more Softee and probably making an ice cream truck call very soon!

So excited that I can eat ice cream all year round now lol. 🥰 Bronx born Bronx raised Mister Softee is a must.

Been here a few times. Great food. Super clean place. Super clean bathroom. Lots of menu options. I'm glad this came nearby.

Crispy Nathan's hot dogs just like I was craving. Next Time Arthur Treacher's. :)