Sara
Google
I was really looking forward to dining at MSSM Yorkville after seeing so many positive reviews, but unfortunately my experience was quite disappointing.
I want to start by highlighting the service, because the chef in particular was excellent. The chef was polite, attentive, and constantly checking in to ask how everything was tasting. They took the time to explain each piece of sushi in detail, including what it was, the type of fish, and how it was prepared, which I genuinely appreciated. The chef also kindly asked multiple times if my friend and I wanted to try anything additional, but we declined. From a service and hospitality standpoint, the experience at the counter was very well done.
Unfortunately, the quality of the food itself is where things fell apart. The fish was extremely underwhelming and, quite honestly, unpleasant. Everything tasted overly fishy, lacking freshness and balance. This wasn’t limited to the sushi alone. Even the green tea dessert had a fishy taste, which was very odd and made the ending of the meal even more disappointing. It just wasn’t enjoyable.
For an omakase experience, I expect clean, refined flavours and fish that feels fresh and thoughtfully sourced. Instead, I found myself forcing bites simply to avoid seeming rude at the table. Rather than looking forward to each course, I couldn’t wait for the experience to be over.
At nearly $100 per person, the value simply wasn’t there. I’ve had better sushi at all you can eat restaurants for half the price, and I don’t even consider all you can eat sushi to be good for the most part. That comparison alone speaks volumes.
While I truly appreciated the chef’s kindness, professionalism, and the effort put into explaining each course, the poor quality and strong fishy taste of the food made this experience unenjoyable. Because of that, I wouldn’t return.