Albert T.
Yelp
Woah, this place is popular. We dropped in less than 15 minutes after opening and there was a line out the door. It took us about 25 minutes to make our way to the front and finally have a chance to eat some deliciously sweet ice cream. We were tempted to get the waffle cones, which were being made fresh off the iron, but we opted to get a double in a cup with the Buckeye Blitz and Izzo's Malted Madness.
Double ($5.00) - We started with the Malted Madness on the top. The ice cream is creamy and exceptionally malty. We found the texture to be quite stretchy and almost a little gummy, like it's half way to being a mastic ice cream. Perhaps the malt interacts with the ice cream base to create this unique texture? We found the ice cream to be a bit too sweet for our tastes, and although we were promised chocolate covered malt balls mixed inside, we were unable to find any. There were a small number of ice crystals frozen inside the ice cream. Surprising, given the high turnover. (3/5)
On the bottom, we had the Buckeye Blitz, which we found to be superior (sorry Tom!). The ice cream is exceptionally peanut buttery and absolutely loaded with mini peanut butter chocolate buckeyes. If you like peanut butter cups, you will love this ice cream. The ice cream texture here is more normal, being rich and creamy super premium with relatively low overrun, but still has a bit of that stretchiness. I'd be interested in seeing the ingredients list, because I feel like some of the texture is due to added stabilizers. The sweetness is a bit less than the Malted Madness but still too sweet for our tastes. Again, though, some mouthfuls had ice crystals embedded inside, which is not the greatest. (3/5)
Overall MSU Dairy Store is an ice cream shop that doesn't don't do anything particularly well, at least for the two flavors we tried. It's still a good place to stop by if you're looking for a really sweet treat and can tolerate some iciness. Note they don't accept cash, and no longer offer the change-over tubs due to "allergy concerns." We saw the server using the same scoop for each ice cream flavor, so that was a bit confusing to us.
Note: Parking is currently a bit complicated since the pay-by-plate lot in front is partially under construction and has very limited spots.
Bathrooms: MSU Dairy Store is in an academic building and shares bathrooms with the students.