My Father's Place

I attended a performance of Broken Arrow at My Father’s Place on November 14, 2025. The acoustics in the room are fantastic, allowing me to hear both the music and vocals clearly. The seating was comfortable as well. The band's energy was electric; two brothers (in the first and last shots) and all the band members are lifelong friends. You could sense the immense fun they were having on stage, supporting one another throughout the performance. Broken Arrow introduced new songs to their line-up, making this reviewer wonder what other songs are in their catalog that could make an appearance in the future. Broken Arrow, please do not wait too long to play again at My Father’s Place.

Very nice hidden gem, I'm so glad a came and got a show with new band named The Current, full of energy and talent. The food was food and the drinks too, atmosphere was great.

Intimate supper club with great musical artists.

Not worth the trip. Small tables. The food was inedible. It seemd like it was the staffs first day. The music was loud and at the same time unintelligible.

Intimate and comfortable venue with good food service. All in all an enjoyable experience. I will be back

Entertainment was terrific, hence the 3 star rating. Restaurant was very dark and food was average at best. Additionally, I found a hair in my salad...not that I'd ever be able to see it (very dark in there), but I pulled it out of my mouth with a forkful of salad. Uggghh! And it was very difficult to grab a waiter when you needed one.

Awesome Time @ Gene Loves Jezebel ❤️ Concert!! Great 👍 Place to see a Show!!

Great venue, top talent. The food is average.

Tickets were $33 per person for the show featuring Gathering Time, who performed from 8:00-10:00PM. Doors opened 6:00 PM and seats are first come first served. My Father's Place is a nightclub, now located in the lower level of the Roslyn Hotel, parking was free and easy, the room wasn't large and neither were the tables, but IMHO a big improvement from the original version in the early 1970s. It's cozy, classy, and the sound was perfect, even though we sat in the first row. Of course we were very fortunate to see an extraordinarily talented trio harmonizing mostly folk and soft rock songs from the 1960s and 1970s. We were offered a fixed price ($49) 3-course menu for the night before Valentines Day and dined between 6:00-8:00 PM. The kitchen belongs to the Roslyn Hotel (and you pay them for the food and drink). Kudos to the chef for the impressive quality and preparations. We both started with a traditional Greek salad (no lettuce), light on cheese, lots of peeled crispy fresh seedless cucumbers, some heirloom tomato, olives, etc. in a light tasty house dressing. It was served with very thin, crispy cracker-noodles that came with two little bowls of dips. My wife enjoyed a grilled salmon steak with a light creamy sauce and a side salad of red onion, what seemed similar to pepperoncini, and what looked like arugula. I'm not on a diet, so I took the opportunity to order their pork osso bucco (which was great) that came with mashed potatoes and chopped asparagus. For our third course, we had the whipped ricotta cheese over strawberry (a first and a relatively light cool finish). We enjoyed the food and atmosphere so much that we'll probably be back to take a chance on performers we haven't heard before.

Great venue! Definitely come to see live acts here! A separate club is such a great way to see music. It's a pleasure to spend the evening with a nice dinner great cocktails, and a perfect show!

Great venue. Set up like an old fashioned supper club. The food is excellent also! Try the burger, the pasta with shrimp, the tuna steak, the salmon. All very good.

What a GREAT venue for music!!! It's an intimate room with excellent acoustics. Went to see Al Stewart and The Empty Pockets on August 14 for a sold out show (160 capacity). It was a terrific performance, 'up close and personal ' -- the antithesis of the 'arena' experience. Excellent food and cocktails, solid service, but no cover.. eat and drink if you want to (and you will be very happy if that's your choice) but IF all you want is the music experience, go for it. This place is a MUST! It's the contemporary continuation of Long Island music history that goes back decades. Sign up for their mailing list so you don't miss out. I have a strong feeling that they only book solid acts, so you can be confident trying the unknown.

Food was very good. The entertainment was outstanding...Andrew Weiss and Friends. Great local venue

Went to see Leslie Mendelsohn who I've seen before in N.Y.C. with my son who has seen her a few times.Eppy from the original M.F.P. was at the door and for those old enough there was an original M.F.P. which was larger scale and I went to many times.New set-up is nice scale all seats are great so the venue was pretty interesting.My son is vegan and he found something on the menu.Would return if I see someone I haven't seen in awhile.Service staff very good.

Iris, the bartender, is the best thing at this venue!!!! Asked for something they don't ordinarily make and she made it! Best Paper Plane I've had.

if you like live music (AND excellent food and drink) in an intimate setting with great acoustics, then this is the place. Went to see an act I'd never heard of (The Bobcats, who do their take on Bob Dylan's catalog) and they were terrific, as was the (local) opener. I'd been there once before for a 'name' performer and had a great time. So this outing was to test the quality of the bookings where I don't know the artist, and it was great. Recommended 100%.