Mystic Mountain Pizza

Everything we ordered was perfectly cooked and delicious. We got the Chet Styx and a half Meat Lovers / half Mystic pizza — both were absolutely amazing. The restaurant itself is uniquely decorated with quirky alien themes and references to movies and shows, which we loved and made the whole visit even more enjoyable. Despite it being a busy lunchtime with only two waitresses, the staff was incredible. They were friendly, attentive, and handled the crowd like pros. Highly recommend stopping by Mystic Mountain Pizza!

Stopped in for lunch today. We thought getting there around 2 PM would beat the busiest time, but we were wrong. We waited just about an hour for the two pizzas we ordered, Thai dye and Pickle. We didn’t mind the wait too much as we passed our time playing Pac-Man and eventually figuring out the wi-fi password so we could browse the web. The pizza was great. We both thought the pickle was the better pizza. I thought the pizzas were personal pan, but we quickly realized they were full size pizzas. 1 pizza will easily feed 2 people. My only recommendation would be to give people bread or something when the wait is as long as it is. Also, advising people of the wait. We were not told that when we were sat, but as I was browsing their little shopping area I heard them telling others the wait was going to be over an hour. Had I known that when we sat down, we would have gone elsewhere.

Very gimmicky decorations, that may appeal to some. The breadsticks seemed store bought with extra cheese thrown on top. Marinara was ok. Pizzas were not to my taste because the pizza sauce was on the tart side (toppings were good though), and we ordered a buffalo pizza without blue cheese crumbles and still ended up with it on the pizza. They were nice and apologetic. If you want something besides chain pizzas give this place a try, but overall I won't come again. Edited: I was being generous while making this review, and initially gave it 3 stars, having received the note from the owner despite being polite over the experience as "good!" for saying I wont be coming back, I will change it to a 2 star and also add that the waitress even told the owner who was in the back, chewing on food with an open mouth, that the pizza was supposed to be without Bleu cheese, to which, with no gloves seen every time the cook and owner leaned on the counter, picked off the large chunks of Bleu cheese and told the waitress to send it. The waitress was polite, a quality someone who owns a business should have and obviously based on all of her responses to reviews lacks. Pizza hut serves better pizza which is sad.

Absolutely fantastic! Our new favorite pizza joint. Great service and great food! We went at lunch during a festival downtown. Seated immediately and food and service were impeccable.

I loved everything about Mystic Mountain Pizza. The atmosphere is so endearing with all kinds of pizza themed and psychedelic decor. The service is attentive and friendly. We got the meat lovers pizza and they were able to accommodate switching up an ingredient for us. The pizza was amazing with generous toppings and a crust which was crispy on the outside, and tender on the inside. It was cooked to perfection without being burned as some wood fire pizzas are. The sausage on the pizza was the best I've ever had...almost as if it was homemade. It was an all around great meal.

Great little spot we found on vacation! Pizza is amazing! Fresh, delicious and done perfect with a great crunch. The kids got a couple of sandwiches that were very good as well.

We had dinner here last night and it was fantastic! We ordered one veggie pizza and one Mediterranean, and both were exceptional — perfectly crispy crust, fresh toppings, and incredible flavor. The service was just as impressive: friendly, attentive, and welcoming. The atmosphere inside had a great vibe, making the whole experience even better. Highly recommend if you’re in Blue Ridge!

A must do when in Blue Ridge. Family owned pizza joint that makes amazing pizzas. We had a meatball appetizer, greek salad and 1/2 Chicken Thai -1/2 supreme pizza. Always fresh and delicious. Cool atmosphere, awesome service with Jules. It's our favorite pizza place in town. Thanks Brannan for another great meal!!!

After looking at several pictures of pizza from the local restaurants, we finally decided to go to Mystic Mountain. Traveling these areas, there's a mountain called Mystic Mountain, and I am not sure if there is a correlation here but ... I thought I just mention it. This pizza place is hippie funky, with lots and lots of decorations. There's a small shop at the front with clothing, home decor, crystals, a bunch of hippie/bohemian/spiritual knickknacks. At the back, there is a game room, so this is a great place for families. I got my hands busy at the pinball machine. We ordered a pizza and a salad, and we were offered the option to split the pizza so we got half supreme and half buffalo chicken. Everything was really good. We liked that this place is well decorated and that we got to roam around and feel like kids. The staff is very friendly and this place had a constant flow of people and families. It's a nice place to visit. Finally, this place is family owned.

Surprisingly good pizza in the wilds of Alaska. Garlic and artichoke is a combo topping you must try. The employees are terrific considering they are swamped with orders from all the locals. Place is where it's at on a Friday night. Customers spill out into the street socializing.

We were starving when we walked into the friendly Mystic Mountain pizza place. Music was playing and the server/hostess, Ana was lovely and helpful! We ordered a couple beers and had supreme pizza. We ordered the cheeseburger pizza - OMG both pizzas were insanely good.

On March 21, some roommates and friends of mine went to this pizza restaurant in Blue Ridge, GA for one of my roommate's birthday. She was turning 23 that weekend and wanted to go to Blue Ridge, since she has been to Blue Ridge before with her family. Upon walking into this restaurant, it gives the vibes of Mellow Mushroom and has shirts and other gifts to sell. A local band was playing live and they sounded good. A little hard to hear what people were saying around you, but they sounded good. Service was a little slow, but that's okay, there were plenty of things to do while you waited.

Not my favorite pizza. Crust was thin, cheese was light, and toppings were near non-existent. It had a fun vibe but that was about it.

Got two pizzas to go Both were tasty We enjoyed them fully Staff is nice Plenty of parking Great Halloween decor Clever decor

We stopped by here for lunch after running some errands and I was thrilled to see this place is just a fun and funky pizza hippie hangout place. Our server was friendly and took good care of us. The pizza here is made fresh so don't expect super fast service but that's ok because the end result is worth it. We ordered the gyro pizza and it was delicious. The secret is their crust. I would be happy just eating the crust - crispy, flavorful and light. Fun hole-in-the wall local spot. Next time I'm going to order the pickle pizza. Why not?

We had the pizza supreme two of them and they were excellent. Only thing I could say that they need to improve on as they have no non-alcohol beer.

My wife found this place online and we went for lunch. It is a very unique and eclectic place and interesting experience. The staff is very friendly and helpful. As good as the pizza looked, we opted for their Philly cheesesteak and it was fantastic. We will definitely return!

First time in this place. The pizza was great and the customers sucked. Owner got into it with a customer who was complaining about pizza being slow as it was packed on the 4th of July. Super entertaining. I wish I had filmed it. I'll be back for great pizza and hopefully entertainment.

Mystic Mountain Pizza is a local pizza spot that sits just outside of downtown Blue Ridge and shares a tiny, albeit sad looking plaza with another local business...but what doesn't seem bright on the outside, certainly lights up once you enter the front doors! The vibe of Mystic Mountain is colorful, chill but wild infused with a hippie-ish nostalgia. If you are familiar with Mellow Mushroom, this is similar but on a much more local scale! On night one of our recent trip, we wanted to get something local and easy to take back to the cabin, and naturally we settled on pizza. Mystic Mountain was one of a few in the area, so we attempted to call and order while we were out and about, but were never able to get through. While it almost deterred us, the reviews seemed so good that we swung by and placed a carry-out order. Quoted 45 minutes wait time, which wasn't the best of news, but we had nothing else going on, so decided to toss the order in and wait. We opted for a pepperoni and mushroom pie along with an order of the Grateful Bread. Total came to around $30 for both. The pizza is wood fired and only comes in one size. The menu is your standard pizza place menu featuring several in-house designed specialty pies or you can create your own. They do offer all their pizzas in gluten free and cauliflower crust options as well. In addition to pizza you can grab a salad...or a hot dog, yup, a hot dog! Our order took right at 45 minutes and one we got it home we were ready to dig in. The pizza was solid. The crust was firm, yet soft and doughy while also being a great vessel for the toppings. No sliding here! While we enjoyed the pizza, the Grateful Bread was awful. I am a massive fan of any variety of bread or cheese bread, and sadly these fell flat and to the bottom of my list never to be ordered again. Half of them were clearly burnt and all of them were dry and crumbly, not in a good way. Maybe it was a bad batch, but again, we had two bites and sadly tossed 'em. Overall, Mystic Mountain is a decent place for a good pie in Blue Ridge. Staff was friendly and outside of the breadsticks, our experience was positive.

It's a must if you're in the area. They have some great variety available. They also have some games and pool table that'll keep the kids occupied too! Sometimes the live music can get a little loud if you sit close to the stage. It's not a big deal and there are plenty of other spots to sit. Just keep that in mind and ask if they are having music or not. We've sat close before and then the band showed up... it's not a game changer and we still go back every time we're in town.

I went in at 2 pm Aug 4, 2025 to order a birthday pizza to pick up at noon the following day, Tuesday August 5th. The woman running the order counter told me she wouldn't place the order today. I asked why. She said if she took my money today and they messed up the order, there would be problems and I'd just have to wait for the correct pizza to be made when I came back the next day. This place makes 1 size of pizza, 14 inches. And maybe 6 different types. So this woman doesn't have the confidence that the kitchen staff can get an order correct that I place a day in advance. I took my money elsewhere and won't return to this place.

We tired this place while staying in blue ridge , the pizza was great and they had gluten free crust also. Staff were very nice and the place had a cool vibe. We would 100% eat here when we visit again.

Tasty pizza & good service. We're picky on our pizza but they hit it out of the park.

Absolutely amazing pizza and gyros! We stumbled upon Mystic Pizza looking for a place to eat with our four kiddos and I'm happy we did! The pizza dough is homemade and some of the best we have ever had! You have to try to homemade hummus with the soft pita bread. Service was incredibly fast, we were served our pizza, salad, gyro less than 10 mins from ordering. Highly recommend!!! Their pizza is so good, Big Foot even stopped by for lunch!

Family decided to go here Saturday night -- got seated quick, but waited almost 2 hours for 2 pizzas, and they were not that good. Will avoid in the future.

Amazing pizza, super dope little spot. Pepperoni and the lumberjack were great. A must try if you are in Blue Ridge.

The pizza was delicious. Server was friendly. They have a cool vibe and little gift shop.

While in the area on vacay we decided to give this cool spot a try and we were glad we did. A hippie joint with a laid back vibe with great food and nice folks. We had 4 pizzas with various toppings and 4 salads and everything was fresh and delicious. Definitely recommend this place!

Stopped in passing through town and we were very pleased with the service and the pizza. Pizza is wood fired and absolutely incredible!

Great pizza place! Highly recommend if you are in the Blue Ridge area. We had 1/2 gyro pizza and 1/2 meat lovers both were very good, I personally loved the gyro pizza lots of flavor, my husband enjoyed the meat lovers pizza they do not skimp on the toppings! Very cool vibe on the inside! All employees were very nice and accommodating!

Pizza was very good, we had chicken bbq with bleu cheese, the ambience was eclectic, just a few customers mid afternoon on a Sunday, I liked it. Service was good but a little slow having someone come take our order although we were seated quickly. No one came with the check when we were done so we had to go upfront. I would go back - pizza was very good

Love the vibe, love the food. Great music, hippie-themed, friendly staff and good food. Really, who could ask for more on a cold, rainy February afternoon?

Food, Service, Atmosphere. Small town Pizzeria with international fans. Peace and Pizza On Wayne!

Came from miami and checked out this pizza parlor, pizza and the bread sticks were really good. Fun family friendly place. Staff was nice . We were a party of 8 with children. I recommend you come prepared as the pizza does take little bit to cook since it's wood oven. Picture of the pizza is the meat lovers, very tasty and good. Check it out of your in blue ridge

High times at Mystic Mountain Pizza. Delicious pizza and fun atmosphere. Food is worth the wait.

This place has a really cool vibe. Went during Christmas season. They had the movie "Elf" playing. Had a nice spread of Christmas cookies and cupcakes with popcorn and hot chocolate. The people were very nice. Got the Greek salad. The makings were cold, fresh, and crisp. Nice dress dressing. Unfortunately, the Pizza is not my type. The toppings were really good. It looks great on arrival at the table. I am a more chewy crispy crust, kind of person. This was neither. Very spongy, "bready". So, not enjoyable for me. Wasn't bad though. Just not my type of pizza. So, this gets five stars for vibe, friendly employees. Only gets three stars for the pizza from my point of view.

We just loved this place , great food and service. Love the hippy vibe, great music and amazing pizza. I had a vegetable cauliflower pizza with olive oil and my hubby's pizza was a meat lover. The crust on both was so delicious. Definitely a must stop if passing through.

Great pizza! The crust is the best part. The shop is a hippie themed/grateful dead parlor. Staff is very friendly. Brought the pizza home and it held up really well. Definitely worth a visit!

Interesting decor. Giving a strong nod to it's psychedelic base the store is heavily decorated with tie-dye, peace signs and assorted treasures from The Grateful Dead, The Beatles and so on. It works well being on "hippie row". The food was great. We started with hummus and breadsticks. Both tasty and generous servings. Our large group had a classic pepperoni, plus the lumberjack, mystic and gyros pizzas. All great though the consensus was the signature mystic was the favorite (spinach, feta, bacon,yum). Staff were totally chill and friendly. No lack of attention. One of the owners floated by and asked how everything was. Definitely great.

We have been twice and it was great both times. We ended up coming in close to closing but the staff was kind and accommodating and we really enjoyed the food

Good food and open when most of the town is closed. A good alternative to fast food with a variety of Italian dishes and pizza.

Great little Pizza joint with some very cool decorations! They had live music that was very entertaining. The service was fast and very friendly. The food was good and I can now say I have had a pizza with fried eggs on it!

Super chill atmosphere. Great food and friendly staff. Really enjoyed this place. We will be back.

Unless you are willing to wait for over 2 hours for a pizza, I highly suggest you go somewhere else. The service is terrible, no communication whatsoever about when your food is coming out. Took 1 hour for a salad to come to the table. They were out of breadsticks and then sent our appetizer to the wrong table, only to make the appetizer incorrectly the second time. Eventually walked out after waiting 1 hour and 45 minutes without being able to get a simple appetizer to our table, let alone a pizza. Awful service, awful wait times, poorly run.

We went to what would have been our third time here. We like to frequent local establishments because the chain restaurants you can get anywhere. We thought giving our patronage here would be nice, since we liked the pizza. Unfortunately, we weren't able to get in since the doors were locked at 2pm. Yelp and their website both said they were open. We drove from Ellijay to have a late lunch and I tried to call and the phone was busy. There was someone inside but no acknowledgment to my family or the numerous other patrons that wished to dine here. There were at least five to six other groups who tried and were unsuccessful. It's too bad. Not sure I'll be back because there are other options available now. My money and time are valuable to someone.

We stopped by after a cold-weather hike to grab a couple beers and a few pizzas with the family. I was shocked to see a sign on the front door saying that we do NOT require our patrons to wear a mask. By the time our pizzas were ready the placed was packed. It seemed odd given that Georgia is at an all time high right now and hospitalizations and deaths. We went in and ordered pizzas to go, obviously, and took them back to the rental property. The pizza was above average. The two cheese pizzas were something you could probably get from Publix, but the Mediterranean pizza was pretty decent with a good flavor. While we ordered, I also noticed they had no beer on tap that day. The place looks pretty cool and the staff was very pleasant.

Everything about this place was absolutely horrible. When we got there we noticed a sign that said limited menu. We were told that they were out of all meats except pepperoni. We decided to stay anyway because we just left another pizza place that was at least 90 minutes before pizza would be ready. Mystic was saying to expect a 30 minute wait. I could believe how chaotic and dysfunctional this place was. One of the bathroom toilets was overflowing so instead of cleaning, they put a barstool in front. The waitresses were clearly in the weeds. We finally got our food an hour later and everything continued to go down hill from there. The greatful bread was very dry and tasteless. The pizza looked great, but it was way below average. We couldn't leave this place fast enough.

This restaurant is a hippies dream come true. The interior is like stepping into the 1970s with arcade games, disco balls, tapestry's and other unique decor. While we waited for the menus, we played the ring toss game on the wall that separated the dining area from the game area. This was FUN! The menu had a variety of pizzas and sandwiches, including unique combinations like a Greek Pizza, Philly Cheesesteak Pizza and Fritos Pie! Each pizza can be split in half with two different types of pizza. While different, the pizza wasn't the best we've had. The crust was fluffy and delicious but 5/10 in overall taste. This is a great place to hang out and grab some drinks with friends. Although wouldn't be our go-to pizza restaurant. Pro Tip: Check out the specials wall right when you walk in, we missed some of the unique pizza combinations.

Out of breadsticks at 6:15 on a Saturday. They were clearly having major kitchen/staffing issues and we eventually walked out after only receiving a salad after waiting 1 hour and 30 minutes. Our initial appetizer got served to another table and the replacement was made incorrectly. Servers were very friendly, but could have reassigned customer expectations/wait times rather than leave the entire restaurant wondering. It was also extremely overcrowded since everyone was not getting their food for over an hour.

This place is dirty and cheap looking. The pizza is subpar at best and that's being nice. Yeah, if you're looking for something different, it might be right up your alley, but if you want GOOD pizza, go elsewhere. The owner or manager, whatever she is, seems to be stuck on herself. I've noticed in her replies and screenshots she can't take any criticism. She only likes positive reviews which I have to wonder who actually writes those. EDIT: Awe, look! She's trying to offend me. Unless you post lies about how great Mystic Mountain Pizza is (), she starts throwing around insults in order to offend. GROW UP, BRANNAN. Childish and immaturity are not a good look for you.

We just left Mystic Mountain pizza and it was fabulous! Our Mediterranean pizza was the best, creek salad was great and the Halloween decorations were spooooky! The band was so good!

Mystic Mountain Pizza is a must whenever we're in Blue Ridge. The vibe is chill, the team is friendly and the pizza is fantastic! And that they offer one of the best gluten free crusts is the cherry on top!

Incredible pizza and service. We ordered online for carry-out. We got the Mystic Mountain, pickle with chicken and bacon, and Margherita.

First meal on a vacation in Blue Ridge, pretty good pizza! The fresh mozzarella was our favorite part, the salads were good (although lettuce was barely cut) and the staff was super friendly. Love the interior, it's really fun and welcoming!

What a wonderful place to dine on a weekend if you are looking for a delicious meal and fantastic entertainment while you dine! The service was brilliant and the pizza divine! I ordered the Gyro pizza that tasted exactly like its name and was soooo amazing that I will be back again! My husband had a made to order a Hawaiian style pizza that was equally as yummy! We were lucky enough to be there on a night when the musical entertainment was professionally well seasoned and so very talented it made the evening out extra lovely! Great atmosphere and Ambiance!!! Blue Ridge is so lucky to have such a wonderful casual dining experience among its many choices.

3.5 overall. My cauliflower pizza was really good. The other pizza was not my thing a bit too much flour. Also the pizza was luke warm we stayed about 10 min from the restaurant. We went so we would arrive prior to the pizza being finished. I'm sure going there is a way better experience. Def check it out if you are in town!

Pizza is delicious. A laidback restaurant and family friendly. We always get our pizza To go so I'm not really sure how the service is other than picking up, staff is friendly and quick.