Brian Bottaro
Google
This is the first time I have ever writing a review but I felt compelled to do so solely because of how the owner of Mystic River has responded to my complaint and how she responded to me.
In September 2022 one of my twin 150 Honda engines started running badly. There are not many marina's in my area that work on Hondas but MR does. I had never used them before for service but had purchased parts many times from Lauren who runs the parts, and manages the marina. I had always had a wonderful experience, she is very knowledgeable. I brought my boat to them in early Sept.2022. Dave is the service manager. As it turned out my engine needed a new Head but Dave also told me I needed it to be completely disassembled and all internal parts cleaned and checked. The engine repair was not completed until Dec. 2022 despite being told many times it would be ready much sooner. By this time my relationship with the service department had deteriorated. The delays lasted into the cold weather and despite being told my boat was protected it was not winterized while sitting there in the freezing cold and subsequently my lines froze and ruined one of my pump motors which I did not discover until the following spring. When I picked up my boat in Dec. 2022 I was assured that the engine was thoroughly checked, cleaned and reassembled with new parts where needed. The total repair was just under $7,000.
I barely used the boat in 2023 and put only about 12 hrs on it.
I launched the boat in June 2024 and within 2 hrs of use the engine literally blew apart . One of the piston rod wrist pins (which was removed, checked and reassembled) had let go and the result were holes so large in my engine I could fit my hand into the center.
I chose not to return to MR marina service. I acquired a used engine and paid my new Honda mechanic to install it and within one week was back on the water.
I contacted Lauren with the details of my experience along with photos of my engine including the piece of the piston rod that I literally reached into the side of the engine and retrieved and a request for some reimbursement for their service which I felt was faulty . I asked Lauren to please do the right thing and help me defray the costs that I encountered even tough the repair dated back to 12/22 and the engine failure was 6/24.
A company is only as good as its leadership. Anyone can make a mistake. It's not what happens that's as important as what you do about it and Lauren called me and agreed to help defray some of my expenses as I had requested. She handled this situation with compassion and ethics and I am very happy to write this review to tell my story.