Mythic Pizza

Super tasty the mythic slice, great price for size of slice. Super fast delivery. Def coming back!

Wow! My new favorite pizza joint! Slices of pizza are piled high with fresh-quality ingredients! Great for a late-night bite and great AA fellowship here on Wednesday nights after AA meeting across the street at the Peacock Lounge! Good service and clean facility!

I ordered a half and half XL pizza from here yesterday. This is my new spot from here on. The pizza took about 25 minutes to make, and was perfectly cooked. I’m not typically a pepperoni person but in this case, I was impressed. As for the crust and cheese, I appreciated that it did not have a sour or play dough flavor that I often find. An updated photo for the menu would be helpful. The prices have changed and the XL pizza is now $33.

Great spot for a slice, or a whole pie. Staff is great. Prices are fair, and they're open late. Everything is made fresh, unlike a lot of other places nearby.

I used to write this place off but they’ve changed their firing process and it now hits - near perfect thin crust slices. Best with a beer from toro next door

I had a great dinner at Mythic Pizza tonight. I ordered two slices, the Tijuana and the Mythic. Both slices were piled high with toppings and I felt like I got my money's worth. To be clear the toppings didn't overwhelm the crust or leave the crust soggy infact its one of the tastiest crusts I've ever had (I normally discard the crust) it was crispy and buttery and reminded me of morning toast I used to have as a kid. The picture is a slice of the Tijuana 🤤🍕 I'm excited to try their other offerings and would recommend their pizza if you're in the lower Haight!

The pizza was terrible. The crust was poorly made, and when I ordered a slice a few months ago, it fell apart the moment I picked it up. I asked the guy at the counter why it was so sloppy, and he said it was NY Style Pizza, not realizing I used to live there and knew it wasn’t authentic NY Style Pizza at all—just badly made. I never went back and wouldn’t recommend it. Instead, try Seniore's Pizza, just down the road.

Great place to grab a quick slice. They have a huge menu of pre-made slices or you can make your own. I always see the same people working and every time they they are extremely nice.

I love a good pizza spot in San Francisco! Came here late last night after a night out with some friends. Wanted a slice of pizza that had vegetables and that was semi healthy. I ordered the "Athens" - (Pesto, Artichoke, Garlic). It was very delicious. The place is small on the inside but there is seating. 4 stars because the slice to price ratio is a little expensive for my liking AND ranch cup was $1-2 which I never seem to comprehend. However, that does not take away from the quality of the pizza. Slice was cooked to perfection and flavor was amazing.

In a neighborhood with real drinkers' bars, you need places like these. As our pal, Sean, who sets up the BBQ in front of Malatov's, knows and steps up and delivers. But when you want pizza, you might think of going here. I like the crew, they've been running the place consistently for years if not decades, and there is value in consistency. But this is no Tony's. Not really a Domino's (if you order properly, Domino's is still in the game). But stick to the ready-to-eat slices and you'll not be too unhappy. I get pepperoni. The Athenian is not a bad choice. Chicken does not belong on or near a pizza, so my wife's choices shall be omitted from this review. But if that's your thing, she LOVES this place, so have fun. Also, because my wife loves this place and we live 2 blocks away, we ordered a whole pie for delivery once. Once being the operative. The stakes were high: I wanted anchovies. Seemingly the last person to want anchovies before me was in the 80s--these anchovies were rank. I would have walked my half of the pizza back to the shop and requested a refund, but I accept the risk I took ordering anchovies, and this time, I lost. But I might also add that my onions, which were red onions for whatever reason, seem to have been forgotten in the original prep. They were raw and crunchy: OK on a salad, but proper white or yellow onions mingle with the bell peppers and minced garlic when cooking and throwing raw ones on after the pizza comes out of the oven is just offensive. To the tastebuds, sensibility, and trust. Never order a whole pizza here. If you don't like Domino's, CostCo is a better option. Or take responsibility for your happiness and get a pizza somewhere that smells good and has a proper brick oven. But if you are in the neighborhood at this moment, check Sean out in front of Malatov's. Tell him Tim and Krista sent you. He'll set you up. Alternatively there're 2 sushi joints--one better than the other, so see their reviews. I think the cheaper one is the good one, but.... also, dumpling city, the Korean bbq. The Bar at Pierce and Haight has an entirely gross food menu. A common situation in top notch bars like this one who want to discourage food orders and focus on the drink. I'm told Otra is one to try. Walk up to Divisadero and the Hotel Metro has Italian but closes early. Horsefeather is fun the first and second time. But if you're wasted and in the neighborhood (although I doubt such a person would get this far in the review), then get the pizza. It's cheap and it'll do the trick. Or there are a few markets right there--get a pair of Hostess cupcakes, a strawberry milk, and a snickers. You can't go wrong.

Pizza slices are huge. I ordered two but it was probably the equivalent of three standard sizes. They have lots of topping choices, but it seems like they just put the toppings on when it's time to warm up the slice. Maybe some are already made. But no matter, the value is great and it's pizza slices so set your expectations appropriately.

I don't understand all of these high and flattering ratings. How many relatives and friends does the owner of this place have? The first red flag is that most of the writing on the chalk board is basically gone, and they haven't bothered to print out any paper menu, so I had to look it up on my phone. The man behind the counter said the wings are spicy, so that took care of that. I went with a slice of pepperoni, that must have been the Weight Watchers slice, it was so thin. Back in the day, a slice of pizza was actually two slices, so it seemed like you got a really great deal. There were a lot of pepperonis on it. I appreciated it, and the crunchy crust. The sauce was nothing to write home about, but it was edible. I really just needed something in my stomach before I went to Safewaay, so I wouldn't buy the whole store. The slice and a can of root beer were enough for that at least.

Pizza arrived soggy. Ordered a Greek salad. Received a lousy house or mixed salad. Disappointed.

Always delicious and fresh. This is our new go to place when we want pizza! I love the thin crust and I'm not normally a fan of it so that tells you something.

Mythic Pizza is my late-night hero! Where else can you snag a slice of pepperoni, pineapple, and jalapeño pizza at 1 AM? It's the perfect mix of cheesy, spicy, and sweet. If you're on the hunt for the ultimate late-night snack, Mythic Pizza is the place to be. I love it!

If you like thin crust this is the place. I love how juicy and flavorful the pizza is.

My boyfriend raved about this pizza spot (Mythic Pizza) that he had stumbled upon with his friends. We finally got around to ordering a medium cheese pizza with pepperoni to-go. The restaurant itself is quite small and definitely gives hole in the wall vibes. I'm a huge pizza fan so I was already being hypercritical. We got our pizza fresh out the oven and took it home to enjoy. Upon opening the box we were pleasantly surprised at how large the medium pizza was. And for the price, it was well worth it! The crust is probably my favorite part, the bottom was light and crispy which is just the way I like it! The outer crust wasn't as fluffy as I thought it'd be but it was still delicious nonetheless! I do wish there they had added on more pepperoni but that's just my personal preference. I did make a note to myself that next time we ordered, we should get light cheese rather than regular because the regular was quite a lot of cheese that we ended up picking some off. I also really enjoyed their pizza sauce as it was much more seasoned than others I've had in the area. Mythic Pizza definitely has a couple of new fans in my household and since we're local, we'll be visiting again when we're craving pizza! If you're hosting a party or get together then I highly recommend ordering a couple large pizzas from here because the price, taste and portion size is well worth it!

One of my favorite restaurants in San Francisco! I came here a couple times during the summer and each time I was so blown away by the pizza. All of the ingredients tasted so fresh and when it comes right out of the oven, the cheese and bread is just so chewy and melts in your mouth. It is just so delicious! It's not as good when it cools down so make sure to eat it right away :) The portions were also really big- 2 medium pizza fed 5 of us.

I can see this really hittin after a night of drinking but otherwise....it's very light on the cheese and the dough is non existent. This is like the thinnest crust pizza I've ever had. Shouldn't thin mean a lot cheaper cause less ingredients? Hmmm someone gots some explaining to do

Best late night eats! Their pesto is to die for! Pretty decent size of slice. Sometimes they don't understand what you are asking for.

Favorite late night pizza when in the city. Love the thin crust that is airy and the variety of toppings to choose from as well. Have never had an issue with an order and delivery through a third party delivery service of your choosing is always prompt.

Ordered two slices with one extra topping, $5.75 each then the extra topping for $1.00 each and then told it was $14.00. Don't add the roasted garlic, it was a rip off.

So it may not be the best pizza in the world, but it's not bad and they're always friendly here. I usually stick with the plain cheese slice but occasionally although crazy and vegetarian. In the end, this is what I consider to be my favorite drunk slice in the lower Haight.

Got a large pepperoni delivered. Delicious. Great cheese pull, crispy but not burnt, and cannot argue the pricing. 10/10

This place is not far from where I live, and I hadn't been there in many years since I got a little stomachache from the food, but idecided to give it a second chance and it was decent quality pizza. For late night hunger it's a good place to go. They're open till like 2 AM almost every night. The downside of this place is that they don't keep it well maintained....Advice; when it's not busy you could clean the windows ....maybe wipe down the tables? how about painting the interior?

Pretty good thin crust pizza especially late in the night. It really hits the spot for post party food. Even though the cheese pizza was simple, service was fast and overall above average slice.

My go-to pizza joint when I go to the city. Although, a bit pricy compared to some other Bay Area suburb pizza restaurants the pricing is super reasonable for San Francisco. Well worth the money spent for good pizza.

I traveled to this city today for a meeting, and I was fortunate to have a lot of free time on my hands in the afternoon to check out the city. I did a lot of walking all over the city, up and down, and up and down these massive hills which took up a lot of my energy. Earing was super necessary and I soon discovered how expensive this city really is. This pizza restaurant was on my way to the Bart metro station so I figured it would I ld be the most economical to simply buy a slice and canned soda. Thunk again! The slice canned soda combo came out to be nearly $7.00. The slice was large and tasted good but I think the next time that I come to this city, I will bring a bag lunch! The employee behind the counter prepared the slice quickly and he was friendly enough. The inside of the restaurant was very casual and I found a table without any problem.

Classic simple local hole in the wall pizza. Did not disappoint, was exactly what I was in the mood for. Prices aren't bad and food came quickly so I'd for sure come back again for take out.

They require a $10 minimum to use a credit card, which is EXTREMELY annoying if you plan to stop in for a slice a pizza (what Bay Area restaurant still does this?). I had to order a salad too so I could get my daughter the pizza. It was completely unedible. It was just a bucket of dressing with some leaves in it. It was disgusting. I took the Caesar back to the counter and he asked me if I wanted him to put more lettuce in it. No thanks. Obviously he didn't give me a refund. I was coerced into spending money on something I didn't want and then out $9 for the gross bucket of dressing lettuce.

Always satisfied with their pizzas and hot sandwiches. Their pepperoni deep dish is off the chain, delicious.

I had a regular cheese pizza and I don't think I have ever had such a basic ass pizza taste so good omg

This place doesn't look the best but it sure tastes the best!There's not a better place to get slices of pizza from in the city. Always open and pretty great service.

Mythic Pizza is fun. I wanted to visit the sausage shop on Haight Street, but it was shut down around noon. I decided on pizza and I picked pesto pizza for $3.50 or so. It was greasy and dabbed it with a napkin. The crust was good and it was easy to pick up. Put the chili on the pizza.

The food is always delicious no matter what I get from this folks. Service is even better when I stop in.

The man shamed me for not tipping more. ...bro, I bought one slice of pizza what do you want for me?!

I think this is a solid drunk spot. Just to be clear, I was really drunk when I ate here, so I can't be totally trusted, but it completely hit the spot! It's a good sized slice, and it's really doughy to soak up that alcohol. They have a ton of options, which is frankly a little too overwhelming if you don't have a clear head. Considering there isn't a ton of drunk food in the area, I expect I'll be back.

Yeah, I go here, pizza is okay.. One night had drinks across the street,late night. The guy a Mythic Pizza wanted to charge me ($9.25) for pizza w/two topping!!! When the other evening I had (the Haight) slice.. I didn't pay as close!!! I just left out. They need to check their prices!!!

Great spot for a late night slice. I got the Grecco (pesto with olives) and it was so good! The slices are huge - definitely the best bang you'll get in the area.

Stop by for a late night snack, the service was fast and friendly. They were very helpful. The slices kinda looked like they might have been sitting there for a while. But we got a slice of cheese and added toppings and ordered a small pizza and wings. The slice was just ok, don't think I would order it again. The pizza that I ordered and that was made fresh was really good. I would come back here again and order a fresh pizza for take out. The wings were just ok.

I order the Greco calzone from here every time! I discovered this cute little place while I was working with my dad and we decided we would have a calzone from here. The calzone was about 14' for a medium and it was only $14 and fed us both and we were both pretty stuffed, they cook it there it's nice and fresh for you and you get a nice hot slice of whatever it is you want. The people were very kind and gave us extra sauce and made the food extra thick for my dad and I :) best place I 100% recommend this place for a nice hot calzone

Never again--I ordered two deep dish pizzas last night and with tax and tip for delivery it cost me $70. The dough was raw due to undercooking. I called immediately but I was told the manager wasn't in. I called two times today and finally got the manager. They said I have to call Postmates who delivered last night,for them to pick it up and bring it back. I told them Postmates was unwilling to do so.They refused to do anything about it and I told them I would take them to court. BTW, avoid Postmates since they are just as culpable in the situation.

Can't wait to visit SF again just to get high and eat here again, the dough was cool. The sauce was good and the cheese added the finishing touch to it

Love this place. A total dive , their own take on pizza and they have the best topping combinations!

My love for the sandwich shop nearby, "love and haight" brought me to try this place on a late night before driving back to my town. I was excited for this place. It's veg friendly with various exciting options. I took it to go for the road and what do you kno. As I bit into my slice all I tasted was a smoky burnt taste. The bottom of my pizza tasted burnt. Although it was packed with toppings... I propose the pizzas are half cooked then extra toppings are added and it's baked again fully. That's kinda gross. The pizza was burnt and I was disappointed to the max. Never going there again when I visit. Better to stick to the basics and "Love and Haight" sandwich shop owns this heart.

Affordable, good pizza. The flavors and toppings were definitely there but the crust was pretty floppy and lacked crispiness, which made it kind of hard to eat. Decent pizza for a decent price though!

I don't know why there are so many terrible reviews. I have lived in SF for 3 years and this is the ONLY delicious pizza place - delicious EVERY time I have had it - hands down. People complain about "too much cheese," as if that is a thing??? If you want shishi-fufu garbage then go find any of the numerous places in this city for that. Light cheese, toppings, and whatever other horrible excuses for PIZZA you can find here. To each their own. For those who want really delicious ACTUAL pizza, with a fantastic crust, flavorful sauce, lots of cheese, and more than plentiful, fresh toppings, then Mythic Pizza is the place to go. Out of towners from cities that actually HAVE good pizza should come here. SF, the food here in general is not that good. The arrogance of the people who think it is, is quite astonishing. It took me years to find good pizza here and it is Mythic. The people have always been nice when I go for pickup and the delivery driver is fantastic. Always very sweet and prompt. Thank you, Mythic, for making real pizza. All y'all pompous, cheese hating, vegan loving people who have these "fluffy" concepts of pizza, you have lots of choices where the pizza is bland, boring, and basic. Leave Mythic to those who love really good pizza!!

It really shocks me that this place doesn't have 5 stars. What more do you people want from a pizza joint? I get their pizza literally anytime I'm out drinking past 10pm and it's the best. The Haight Pizza is my go-to and I usually just pick it up, and they're quick!! Delivery is pretty quick too (however I live around the block and I had it delivered by accident so that's probably why it was fast). Either way this place is the bomb.com and their pizza is excellent and I'm pretty sure the staff think I'm hilarious since I'm usually showing up drunk and talking to my dog.

I have been trying to find a good late-night slice place in the area but unfortunately, I don't think this is it for me. I got a slice of their veggie pizza to-go. When I took a look at it though, it was so obviously a cheese pizza slice with some raw uncooked veggies placed on it (uncooked mushroom was the biggest giveaway). I mean... if they only had cheese pizza I would have been more ok with that then this. Or even just reheat the pizza with the veggies on? That being said, we live nearby and ended up taking the pizza slice home and rebaking it after that and it tasted fine. But there are certainly better places in the area (though I am still on the hunt for the perfect late-night slice). Overall, I cannot recommend for a slice but hey maybe their full pies are better.

The crust was light and airy,sauce was good and pizza was delicious. We ordered a deep dish pepperoni and it came out in about 20 minutes. The small is good enough for 4 I would say. Little hole in the wall kind of place.

Voted the worst pizza in sf. The pizza is a step up from frozen pizza from the store! Frozen sausages the salami look l brown and old.

Good pizza, but they got my order wrong :( I was really excited for the deep dish Mythic pizza I ordered, but they just sent over a regular Mythic pizza instead (which is less expensive than the deep dish too, even though I was charged for the deep dish). The order also took nearly an hour. The pizza itself was decent, but really heavy (the box felt like a weight to carry) and dense.

After a crazy sweaty night at Vertigo, we stopped to grab a bite at Mythic. Thinking I was the smarter of the bunch, I went next door to Love N Haight and ordered a huge sandwich drooling with sprouts. But as soon as I caught a whiff of the freshly made slices from Mythic, I knew I'd made a mistake. My bf relucantly let me have a bite of his, and I have to say for late night food options, Mythic is by far, one of the best in the area. I could actually taste the toppings, the crust was doughy (the way I like it) and cheesy slice was piping steam. I'm planning on birthing an additional star to this review - once I get a big slice just to myself.

I'm from out of town and I was looking on Google maps for a pizza place near by that had a affordable price. I got to say I was skeptical about how big the pizza was going to be. I ordered a large Haight pizza and added pepperoni and sausage to it. Man was I impressed the delivery was on time, the delivery guy was very polite, the pizza was very tasty, and big. No complaints whatsoever, I definitely recommend this place for great pizza.

While I find that many patrons come from the bars across the street, Mythic Pizza boasts a customizable pizza menu with plenty of options. While I find that many people seem to like the place, I have found that the flavor and the dough failed to be more than just home made pizza. Knowing how many options I have in the area, I have continued to opt out of Mythic Pizza after my first try. I just can't say it was anything special, which included the wait time for a pizza nor the customer service.

Care for some rich - overloaded with cheese - greasy pizza?! Mythic Pizza is next door to my favorite bar in SF, Toronados. After a night of drinking some good brew we were starving for something savory & cheap. We walked in next door... ordered a few slices and we were set. I could barely finish a piece - so much cheese! Every inch of that pizza was scrumptious! Service is slow & not the friendliest, but most pizza joints are (to-go service/call-in orders) I was staying in the Haight/Ashbury neighborhood so I was happy I found this little spot. Definitely check it out if you're in the area.

Location, Location, Location. This place is only worth mentioning because of its location. Their lease is worth it because it's definitely located for your convenience when the drunk munchies hit after you've been drinking in the Lower Haight. The majority of their business must come during these times. I couldn't imagine people stopping here for a slice in the middle of the day. I ordered a slice with pesto and ricotta. I was disappointed since it wasn't a true pesto slice. They simply drizzled pesto on top of a pre-made cheese slice, so there was tomato sauce and pesto. Adding ricotta as a topping definitely made it a little better. In conclusion, I'm no better or worse for ordering from here. It was very mediocre and forgettable. I wouldn't order from here if other places were open, but I can't say I wouldn't get a slice from here again if it was the only spot open late at night.