Nancy's Pizza Midtown

We came here for Father's Day. It was pretty quiet when we arrived and we have the place to ourselves for a bit. It was busier by the time we left. Our server was very friendly and helpful. Quick service. We ordered a Caesar salad, garlic bread with cheese and a large Chicago deep dish that was half Tony and the spicy one. Everything was delicious. Lots of cheese. Good ingredients. Tasty sauce. Firm crust to keep everything together. Salad and cheesy garlic bread was also good. I recommend the pesto sauce...it was super yummy! This is a big space with lots of seating. If you want, there are tvs for sports and a bar.

I have to say this is the BEST pizza I've ever had, hands down! The wings too they were perfect!! WOW is all I can say. My husband and I make this a for sure destination for our date nights now! Great & friendly staff!

We visited on a Wednesday evening about 6 pm. It wasn’t busy in the restaurant but their online/to go area was busy. The food was delicious. The environment was welcoming and friendly. The music was right….the vibes were definitely there! Perfect midweek wind down. KD the bartender was amazing. The drinks he made were 🔥 it was a $5 peach lemon drop. We ordered pizza and wings. Our waitress was super nice. Will definitely be back! Please go visit and go see KD. He’s so personable and inviting! You won’t be disappointed with the food, service, or atmosphere.

We went as a family to adventure into the city for a craving of deep dish pizza. Maybe there was a time when this restaurant was “it” but Not anymore. The food was average and disappointing. Decor was dated, Restroom unkept, dirty. We ordered Side of meatballs that came out cold, a side of sausage that were giving poverty and came out without the sauce listed on the menu and a $14 Caesar salad that was small as well and dressing was charged separately 🙄 strange; Pizza was Pre-fab deep dish but let’s face it, “We aren’t in Chicago” Overall the flavors of sauce and cheese were good, kids liked it. This review it’s an opportunity for areas of improvement, because in this business You are only as good as Your Last Meal !✌🏽

This place definitely has potential but has some work to do. The service was great. Our server was pretty much serving the whole place during the dinner rush and was doing a great job keeping up. One thing that started our experience out a little disappointing was the silverware and plates coming out dirty with a piece of hair on it. We ordered garlic bread with cheese and mozzarella sticks for appetizer. 6 mozzarella sticks for almost $12 were overpriced considering how small and soggy they were. We got a medium deep dish pizza which was pretty good. They definitely use fresh ingredients and you can taste it. We will definitely be back to give this place another shot. The thin crust pizza looked really good; I think we will try that next time!

I have been to Nancy's for years. The first time was about 15 years ago and I still go and bring my friends and family when I come to Atlanta and now when we stop for lunch in Atlanta they ask to come back here. They are consistent in their taste, and it keeps me coming back. I have also had their wings as well, and they are SO good. Crispy on the outside but tender when you bite in. The parking deck is not far away either, so it's not a long walk to your car, so that's nice. Their menu does tell you how much each pizza feeds and it's accurate so pay attention to it. You may think that the pizza is small. But each slice is about 2.5 to 3" thick. It's a lot and we always take pizza home. If your looking for a solid pizza and place that you will keep coming back to, look no further. Nancy's is the place to go to.

I’m a big fan of Nancy’s Pizza and eat at many of the locations . We were downtown ( Atlanta ) so we ate at the Ponce location for the first time in quite a while. There were several miss-starts . The waiter was brand new … as in we were his first customers …and no one was helping him . The mozzarella sticks at the Roswell location are huge and round and crispy and delicious . The mozzarella sticks here were simply awful . Small and square and pale , they tasted like raw breading , I believe they were bought in the grocery store and microwaved . Just awful. We ordered a Large stuffed and medium thin crust . The thin we ordered half pepperoni and half cheese, but ended up with pepperoni and Italian sausage . That was to the good because the Italian sausage was absolutely delicious . The stuffed pizza made up for everything , just cheesy , saucy deliciousness . We tipped the poor waiter quite well . The neighborhood is seedy and the service needed some work , but the star of the show is the stuffed crust and it was on point .

Visited with a few friends this weekend and had a great time! We got a large deep dish sausage and pepperoni pizza and it was phenomenal. More than enough for three people - we had leftovers. We also got the italian breadsticks, which were a bit disappointing but still okay. Would definitely visit again!!