Nancy's Pizza

Pizza restaurant · Irving Park

Nancy's Pizza

Pizza restaurant · Irving Park

1

3970 N Elston Ave, Chicago, IL 60618

Photos

Nancy's Pizza by null
Nancy's Pizza by null
Nancy's Pizza by null
Nancy's Pizza by null
Nancy's Pizza by null

Highlights

Nancy’s Pizza serves up iconic Chicago-style stuffed-crust pies that pack in the cheese and toppings, all in a casual setting perfect for a slice.  

Placeholder
Placeholder
Placeholder

3970 N Elston Ave, Chicago, IL 60618 Get directions

nancyspizza.com

$$ · Menu

Information

Static Map

3970 N Elston Ave, Chicago, IL 60618 Get directions

+1 773 267 8182
nancyspizza.com

$$ · Menu

Features

Last updated

Mar 6, 2025

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2025 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@eater

"The Irving Park location of Chicago stuffed pizza pioneer Nancy’s Pizza is closed." - Ashok Selvam

Chicago’s Restaurant and Bar Closures for 2019 - Eater Chicago
View Postcard for Nancy's Pizza

ShuklaZ S

Google
Aged out place, not well kept. The owner clearly doesn’t have intentions to improve the quality of food or ambience. It’s quiet here at peak time which means people know this place sucks ... for new customers this may be first and last visit

Paul N.

Google
I ordered a Nancy's special stuffed pizza to be delivered. There was supposed to be sausage, green peppers and onions. There was so little sausage on it that it could hardly be tasted. Nancy's was my go-to place for stuffed pizza but I won't be ordering it again. This city is too full of decent pizza places.

Charles BigCheese

Google
Ordered from this place and the manager had a nasty attitude because I asked for fresh pizza. He wanted to serve me pizza that was left under a heat lamp for hours. My last visit was leftover pizza and I tried to allow him to redeem himself. Much of the same. Old pizza and nasty attitude. I will never eat there again and I will encourage friends to never eat at this dump.

Shawn P

Google
In town on work and stopped here for a quick bite to eat. The pizza is very bland.. It truly tastes like store pizza that you purchase for 1$ a box.. Really a sad shame that they consider themselves a pizza restaurant.. Would not recommend anyone come here for pizza.. Can't speak on other item's on the menu, but definitely skip the pizza!!

Kenneth Ponton

Google
Pizza crust is cheap, sauce is ok. You can obviously tell that corners were cut. Message to owner: Sucks because the pizza has potential, just stop being cheap with the ingredients its better to build your business on repeat customers than ripping off first time visitors. BTW your medium sized xlarge is a joke!

P Kurz

Google
These guys were one of the early pioneers in stuffed pizza, it's usually a one piece and your full affair with this very cheesy and filled with a huge list of ingredients. I have ate this pizza for almost 35years and it is one of the best

John Gibbs

Google
Good pizza for the most part but the customer service isn't very good. And they will deny you a pizza if you call to close to closing time. I tried on Sunday night to call for pizza at 820pm, they close at 9. But they wouldn't take my order.

mc smarto

Google
Best stuffed pizza in Chicago. Forget about that other place. The sauce is so good here you may need to ask for extra!