Nate’s Detroit Pizza

Really solid Detroit slice. I had the hot honey, pepperoni, and bacon combo, + cheese and they both hit just right — crispy edges, great balance, and a bold, rich tomato sauce that stood out right away. They even hooked me up with an extra pepperoni slice, which was awesome (pretty sure that was Nate — thanks again if so). Definitely one of the best square slices I’ve had. I will certainly be back. Highly recommend checking these guys out.

Randomly stumbled into this pizza spot and was for sure the highlight of the night. Nate was absolutely amazing and allowed us to choose a vinyl on the wall to listen to while we ate. The pizza was SO good! One of my favorite slices so far in the city

🔥 Top 3 slice in the city, no question. Nate’s Detroit absolutely delivers! Crispy crust, perfect sauce to cheese ratio, and always fresh out of the oven. The vibe here is on point too. If you talk to the employee behind the counter, they might throw on a record while you eat. Can’t beat great pizza with some vinyl spinning in the background.

If you're lucky enough to live near Park Slope, consider yourself even luckier now — because Nate’s Detroit Pizza just rolled into the neighborhood like a rock band you didn’t know you needed. We first found Nate’s down at Industry City, and it was love at first slice. Now they've set up camp right here at home, and it’s an absolute game-changer. The pepperoni? Criminally good — those perfect little grease-cupped discs that sing when they hit the oven. The crust? It's the kind of thing you’d cross a city for: light, crispy, unapologetically rich. Each bite feels like a small rebellion against the ordinary. But it’s not just the pizza. Walk through the door and you’re met with a kind of warmth that feels rare these days. A place that welcomes you like an old friend, hands you a slice, and reminds you why food matters. Nate’s isn’t just a pizza joint. It’s a new go-to. It's a good reason to be grateful you live here. Kiddos to the pepperoni. Cheers to Nate’s. Welcome to the neighborhood — you fit right in.

Look man. Let’s keep it honest. Here’s the scenario, I’m going through a breakup, the weather was a tad cool bleak and dreary (not ideal for a upbeat day;) just for me to be walking west on Atlantic and stumbling on “Nate’s Detroit Style Pizza.” Upon walking in I knew I had stumbled upon a gem here in Brooklyn. Vinyl records of some of the most classic albums of all genres were nestled on the wall. Fitting once I got to the register the pizza laid behind the glass like shiny penny on your dresser. Nate, the owner greeted me and asked what I wanted. He made some suggestions I took his word for it-and look, here I am in a review telling you about! The pizza is some of the best in the city! You get a chic cozy vibe with a few good slices to go with it. If you’re like me maybe just stay in the store and just vibe out while improving your day and having some of the best pizza out in the city right now. Check them out! P.S. try the hot honey on one of your slices, ya diggg

i didn't like detroit style pizza and this changed my mind, i love how the crust is crispy but the inside is soft. really good pepperoni too

This place is like velcro…total ripoff! $9.00 SOAKING WET for the smallest tastiest piece of pizza in town. I had to take this to the boys at CERN to perform electron microscopy to see this thing. yes, it was delicious, but imagine if you paid $90,000 for a beautiful car and they just give you one delicious tire. Do better Nathaniel!

Place is unreal. Pizza is even better. Fresh herbs on every slice. Can’t say enough good things about this spot. LGRW

I'm not the biggest fan of thick crust pizza but this place serves up some delicious squares! I had the hawaiian and truffle vodka, which was really good. Although my daughter had the truffle and you definitely taste more truffle than the one mixed with vodka sauce. It's a small hole in the wall with 2 tables and 4 chairs so definitely grab and go. The downsize is the size and price point. It's $8 per piece and it's about the size of a 4x4 so do the math of how much you need to spend to be full. The staff was friendly and service was quick.

Ordered a large pepperoni pizza (13x9) and received a very small cheese pizza (9x9). When I called and explained the mixup, the person on the phone asked me if I wanted to get a refund or if I wanted to get the pizza that I originally ordered and I picked the later. He mentioned he would send it right away, but asked me to be a bit patient because he had a lot of orders. We waited over an hour and when I called, the same person claimed that my phone wouldn't accept any calls and so he simply refunded me for half of what I paid. When I asked him if he was going to send the pepperoni pizza I originally ordered he said no, and that I had to place another order through Seamless. So I ended up having to pay for a small pizza a never ordered. The pizza itself is also nothing to rave about. Maybe the pepperoni one is better...who knows.

Great service, would definitely recommend the pizza pizza I got the marina and pepperoni

This is the best pizza in Brooklyn. I live around the corner from it and can't stop coming here. I'm not going to go into a super long review because it's simple. Try it out. P.S. - I thought another squared, Detroit style was amazing until this place opened. Now I'm an evangelist for them.

Pizza is delicious, but the crust isn't quite thick enough for Detroit-style pizza. Also they don't offer ranch dressing for the pizza, which feels sacrilegious and takes away from the whole experience. Good if I'm in a pinch, but otherwise I'm going to Jet's.

Giving 5 stars bc I'm not in the business of screwing over nyc small businesses, but listen - the magic of pizza is that it's affordable and for everyone. This pizza is really good, but I won't be rolling through at this price point. It's a shame because I live on the block and would love to enjoy/support, but $5-8 for a slice the size of my (small!) hand is outrageous. I think you'd be doing way better business if you upped the size or lowered the prize a little. I wanna love it!!!