John P.
Yelp
This is a great little store that carries pretty unique and nice items. Pretty nondescript storefront, in a not-very-touristy part of town, close by the Bailey House Museum.
There are pieces at a number of price points, from low-medium to quite high. This is not a bargain souvenir shop carrying the usual mass-produced t-shirts and tikis (in fact, I can't remember if they even had any tikis on display).
Nor is it a pricey boutique that sells high-end Western stuff like Swarovskis, or even local oil paintings, which you could buy anywhere else in the world. Except probably cheaper.
These are island sourced items, inspired by local culture - lots of really nice wooden pieces, mostly elegant and simple designs, which you probably wouldn't find elsewhere.
Got 2 really nice t shirts and a cow-bone & koa wood spiral pendant, very simple and sparse, where the bone looks like ivory. About $80, so by no means cheap, but looks quite stylish. And, yes, by taste I could have spent quite a bit more, had I had the budget.
By far one of the more interesting shops I saw on Maui.
p.s. one of the other reviewers was all bummed that the staff ignored her. I got a slightly different take - the saleslady initially pretty much left me to browse on my own, which I actually prefer, rather than bugging me to buy stuff. However, as soon as I asked for information, she was very helpful and quite available to explain details about the pieces I was looking at.