New York Grilled Cheese Wilton Manors

A Must try. Tomato soup was really good. You get one with every grilled cheese. We got 3 different grilled cheese and two types of fries. Some better than others but all were good. The New York was our favorite but the classic was pretty good. The pizza fries were just ok. Kinda hard to eat. Overall worth it. It's a fun place and our service was good. They kept out waters full and did it with a smile. You can park in the front or out back.

We happened to stumble upon this cute little spot and decided to treat ourselves to some afternoon grilled cheese sandwiches. The worker was such a sweetheart—so helpful and incredibly attentive. We ordered the Gramercy Garlic Cheese Fries (absolutely to die for!), the Brooklyn Porkster, and our favorite, the Fifth Avenue melt. Everything was delicious, definitely a gem worth revisiting!

The Midtown Truffle Shuffle and tomato bisque were very good. The owner was polite and friendly. It is a small place with some tables inside and a couple outside. I will definitely be back to try some of the other sandwiches and the mushroom bisque.

Amazing! Server was very nice and informative. The food was beyond what I could imagine. The fries had that perfect crisp, the bacon-dog were delicious, and the sandwich was out of this world. I will be visiting here every time my husband and I are in town.

If you're in Fort Lauderdale, you have to check out New York Grilled Cheese! This restaurant exceeded our expectations with a menu full of homemade grilled cheese creations that are bursting with flavor. Every sandwich we tried was incredible—perfectly toasted and made with fresh, quality ingredients. Each bite was a delicious experience that left us wanting more. The staff was fantastic as well—friendly and attentive, making us feel right at home. We can't wait to return to New York Grilled Cheese! If you haven't been yet, make sure to visit—you won't regret it!

Some Of the best grilled cheese I have ever had. I had the fith avenue and it was to die for. Definitely recommend.

One of my absolute favorite places to eat. The food is amazing and never disappoints. Can be a little pricey but so worth it in my opinion and it’s very filling. I’ll never stop coming here and recommending it to people. The staff is great as well and the variety of beers are endless. The tomato soup here is better than any other place I’ve tried.

*** The Best Grill Cheese I Ever Had *** This was my first time at New York Grilled Cheese. The service was great but be prepared to wait a while for your food. After eating here and tasting my grill cheese sandwich, I can see now why it was so crowded. The food was definitely worth the wait. I had the Village Vegan sandwich. It literally melts in your mouth. I've had many grill cheese sandwiches in my life and this one was absolutely the best I've ever had. Highly Recommend. 5 stars!

It was love at first bite at New York Grilled Cheese in Wilton Manors . Granted, it was midnight on Halloween night, but thats besides the point . The grilled cheese I ordered with chicken is something I think about to this day. Need to go back for some more deliciousness! : 1. Meatpacking District ( )

Where all the grilled cheese lovers go in Wilton Manors. If grilled cheese isn't your thing, get ready to change your mind because this place made me an avid fan. When I find myself in the area, I automatically crave NY Grilled Cheese (and any of their waffle fries.) My favorites are the Midtown Truffle Shuffle and the Sweet Potato Fries with the marshmallow dipping sauce. YUM. If you love mushrooms, I definitely recommend the Truffle Shuffle. And for both sweet potato lovers and not lovers, I recommend giving these fries a try. There is a paid parking lot behind the biz as well as street parking around. You can either dine in or take the food to go. Every time I've visited the service was super friendly and food came out pretty quick. Can't wait for my next visit here to satisfy my grilled cheese craving writing this review induced.

Slap yo' Grandma Good Vegan Options! The mushroom bisque, Village Vegan and Vegan Poutine were legit! Jules provided knowledgeable and kind service. Clean with good music (not too loud). Highly recommend!

New York Grilled Cheese is one word: indulgent. They take classic comfort food completely over the top. We stopped in for a late dinner on a Saturday - service was friendly and the food came out quick. The place is small and parking is definitely limited (like most places in Wilton Manors) but there is a metered lot in the back. It was honestly so hard to choose what to order, because even though they specialize in only a few dishes, there's tons of variety available between them. My table ended up ordering the Harlem Hot and Wall Street Grinder sandwiches, the Gramercy Garlic Cheese Fries, and the Hell's Kitchen Sweet Bake. We loved everything! The Harlem Hot wasn't super spicy, but had a pleasant kick that paired well with the pickles. The Wall Street Grinder was a super rich breakfast sandwich, and would be perfect after a night out. The garlic fries were really good too, and I loved that they were tossed in the sauce instead of having it drizzled on top so that the bottom was coated too. The dessert was like if you combined a bread pudding and a funnel cake - it was really sweet and rich and definitely gave that nostalgic carnival food feeling. I think the biggest surprise of the night was the tomato soup though. I like tomato soup well enough, but I wouldn't call it a favorite. This one though? So good! It wasn't too acidic at all, and had great basil flavor that paired really well with both sandwiches we got. I would order a full-size container of this next time to bring home!

I came here with two friends for a late lunch on a Saturday afternoon. We were all pretty hungry, and one of my friends recommended this restaurant. I ordered the Fifth Avenue, which was Muenster and American cheese, chicken tenders, and bacon on white bread. I'm pretty sure that I will continue thinking about this sandwich for the rest of my life-- it was that good. All their sandwiches are pressed in a waffle iron, so the outside of the bread becomes incredibly crispy. They are also served with a small container of tomato bisque, which was a bit too sweet for me, but definitely a nice touch. Our waitress was also really cool and recommended both items on the menu and things to do in the area, which we appreciated!

This is by the far the best grilled cheese I've ever had. The grilled cheese I have here is what sets the bar for grilled cheese sandwiches for me. Just the classic grilled cheese sandwich is enough to travel over 30 minutes here to get. But the best thing here isn't even the grilled cheese or the sides. Its the tomato soup. The tomato bisque, I would order by the bucket if I could. Always size up, when ordering your grilled cheese, the tomato bisque. If I said, I would travel 30 minutes for the grilled cheese, I would travel an hour for the tomato bisque alone. The service is also pretty exemplary. It is a smaller style restaurant but the staff was always attentive and always made sure I had what I needed. My advice: skip the other grilled cheese spots and go straight here!

Was the only thing open got here at like 12:00 PM a very long way had high expectations. Looks good in the picture but was definitely a letdown. She was not melting sandwich like it was just throwing together. Everything was cold. Do yourself a favor don't order the chocolate waffle.

Great service, and late night eat. Definitely satisfied the craving of some comfort food. The place was a little dirty but it was also 3am on a Saturday night! It was very busy so can't blame them!! Very fast lots of options.

I loveeeee this place! We were greeted by Aaron, and he is just the absolute BEST! The food is amazing with many options of grilled cheese sandwiches and the fries are fire. I opted for the basic one, but basic it was not! I paired it with glass of Prosecco and had a great time here. It looks small from the outside but it extends all the way to the back. A cozy and fun environment with friendly people. I enjoy coming here anytime I'm in Wilton manors.

Love coming here :) the grilled cheese is good of course but the tomato soup!!!! It's my favorite part of getting these sandwiches. That tomato soup is a must try and for sandwiches I recommend the one with Brie or the Wall Street grinder. The sandwiches with chicken tenders are a bit much for me so I stick with the ones that just have bacon. The service is nice and quick and this location also plays good music. The restaurant size is good compared to the Wilton manors location which feels much smaller. Prices have gone up as they have at all places but they aren't outrageous ((yet)). Definitely check this place out!

I have been to New York Grilled Cheese many times after a long night of drinking at the beach but today I went sober. I ordered the Broadway Melt with tomato bisque, and boy, was it a showstopper! The combination of gooey, perfectly melted cheese, and the crunch of the bread was pure perfection. Each bite dipped in the tomato bisque soup was like a symphony of flavors. Please do yourself the favor and upgrade the 4oz soup to 8 or even 16! I also couldn't resist trying their poutine, and I must say, it was a deliciously guilty pleasure. The crispy waffle fries, smothered in rich gravy and topped with generous cheese curds, took me straight to Canadian flavor heaven. The service at New York Grilled Cheese was nothing short of exceptional. The gentleman that greeted us, took our order and served us was attentive, friendly. Whether you're a grilled cheese aficionado or simply looking for a fantastic meal, make sure to stop by, you won't be disappointed!

Amazing spot to eat at! The grilled cheese options are all amazing. My friends and I have tried almost the whole menu! The service is amazing too they are super nice and funny. Great vibe and great music.

Ok at first glance late at night I walked into what looked like the aftermath of a pride event. Drunk couples sitting around waiting for their grilled cheese. So my first impression is this will be drunk food and mediocre. I was wrong! This place for late night drunk food was out of this world. Outstanding grilled cheese, don't let the late night gay night club vibe make you believe this place doesn't have grilled cheese creations that are Michelin star level. I loved it, and I'm also thrilled they are open late when nothing else is. Absolutely will be back!

I came here with a buddy on a "treat yourself" evening out! I haven't been here in a few years, so I was struck with how different it was. They seem to have pivoted to a much more take-out friendly model, which cuts down on the amount of seats for dine-in costumers, but we were able to get a seat anyway. We started out with an order of the vegan poutine! I live a strictly anti-vegan-cheese lifestyle, but my friend wanted to try it so I gave in. I was very pleasantly surprised; the poutine was delicious! There weren't really enough fries to go around for the amount of toppings, but it was yummy nonetheless. I ordered the Wall Street Grinder melt, which had waffle fries, bacon, eggs, caramelized onions, and aioli inside! Also a delicious choice. And let's be honest, the best part of any meal at NYGC is the tomato bisque! Mouth-watering! We finished up our meal with a Hell's Kitchen Sweet Bake, which was topped with berries and white chocolate drizzle. It was very sweet, but I don't know if I would call it the best dessert I've ever tasted. Overall, this experience was about the same as every other time I've been here! Good food, good service, good ambiance, but none of them great.

Amazing. I said wow after my first bite. This place is exceptional. Shout out to Jules. She rocks. Enjoy your trip home after 34 years.

This place is a must go ! Everything here is super delicious the food is so fresh ! The service is as good as the food . Great ambience because this is the the after party place to go and eat ! If you love cheese everything on the menu will have you fall in love . Please do your self a favor get the tomatoes soup and you must Dip your grill cheese. You're welcome

Warning: This place has a plethora of cheese. Hope that's your thing. My dish did not fall short in the cheese department! My Mac and Cheese w/bacon Grilled Cheese Sandwich was hot, ooey gooey, creamy, fatty, scrumptious, and CHEESY! The waffle style bread was crunchy and perfect. My waffle fries on the side were crunchy, but was missing seasoning. A 98 yr old man once gave me advice to "Toast your bread and add ingredients to it". I think I did that today. Also, I will add this place is in dedication to an unforgettable spirit "Magic" Michael Entenza, he passed too soon at age 24. I was greeted immediately when I walked in the door, and was free to seat myself. My server made recommendations on the menu and was personable throughout my visit. The menu has plentiful choices and shows considerations for dietary needs suck as vegan, vegetarian, and gluten conscious. Dining room may be petite, but the environment and decoration on the walls keeps your mind busy. I love this neat little place!! Can't wait to come back.

It's just a unique place, in a unique town, selling unique food. It's great tasting, excellent customer service and a gooey cheesy bite to remember.

Who is one of the best app ever been in a long time? I wish I can get other people to see what I

Would you believe me if I told you that I drive an hour for these grilled cheeses? I've been obsessed with this location for about 5 years now. I wish they had a restaurant here in Miami but at the same time I don't cause I'll be living there literally! It's a small welcoming restaurant the minute you walk in you're greeted with a smile and I love the Mural of all the grilled cheeses on the wall! I always start with their creamy garlic and sweet potato fries! (yes both because it's too hard to pick one lol.) I ordered the fifth avenue and add caramelized onions and all sandwiches come with tomato bisque. This combination is so delicious and cheesy and savory. Every bite is different experience. My boyfriend tried the Truffle Shuffle and let m just say if you're a truffle lover like me that one is going to knock your socks off! I honestly can come at any time of the day and the food is always fresh and the ambiance is always fun and cheesy! I cant wait to go back and try more different grilled cheeses or come back for my fifth ave :)

I don't think this is a place to get from Uber Eats. The food had all the potential of being absolutely incredible but getting it to go is not the vibe. The tomato bisque was incredible. The grilled cheese sandwich I order had apple slices and Brie and was good, but room temp by the time it got to me. You can tell the restaurant took care in wrapping the food and trying to make it as secure as possible, which was great! I want to try it again in person to really give it a fair review. All in all, the flavor was there, it was a bit pricey (2 sandwiches, an appetizer and dessert with delivery fees was about $100), but I'd give it a shot again bc I love a good grilled cheese.

It's my favorite spot for grilled cheese !!!! I always go for the classic but there many options to choose from ! Has enough sitting on the front and the back ! The waffle fries are just amazing ! Great casual hangout!

Aaron made our experience amazing! Not only was the food amazing but the service couldn't be better! What an amazing team! thank you all

The only problem we had at this eatery is that my hubby and I wanted the mushroom bisque instead of the tomato, and my daughter only wanted white cheeses in her Brooklyn Porkster. All substitutions happily were made. But when we got the bill we were charged $2.95 (the full price for a small bisque) for each mushroom soup and $2.50 for the Swiss cheese on the porkster. Whatever happened to an upcharge for substitutions instead of the full price of the item? (The small soup is $2.95 on the menu.) We complained (because we were never told about the extra charges) and they quickly and gladly removed the excess. Done with the bad. The rest is all good. My daughter had the Brooklyn Porkster, hubby had the Fifth Avenue, and I had the MPD (meat packing district made with brisket). Of course, we tasted each other's sandwiches. We all agreed that the MPD was the best. We also had an order of sweet potato fries, that looked divine but had no taste (skip it). While they are not cheap (average $14.95), the sandwiches are filling and delicious and come with a small tomato bisque. The mushroom bisque was my absolute favorite thing at the meal. Next time I am getting a bowl to go with my sandwich (no matter the cost). The servers were superb and very friendly. (Shout out to Andrew and River.) After seeing my social media posts, a friend suggested some sides. So, we will return to try those along with some different sandwiches (paired with the mushroom bisque). One negative, parking is cheap enough (public meters and app parking) but very difficult to find. It took us about 15 minutes and we had to walk about 2 blocks back to the restaurant. But the minor hassle was well worth it!

I haven't been here in 3+ years, they redid the layout. We all had the brie grilled cheese which comes with onions and bacon. You can choose from sourdough bread, oatmeal wheat and white. The grilled cheese sandwiches were yummy!! We also shared the waffle sweet potato fries that come with a marshmallow dipping sauce. There are lots of cheese sandwiches and fillings (meat) to chose from.

literally the greatest sandwich of all time, i order the fifth avenue all the time and its just perfect literally sensational its worth the crazy prices yall trust

Me and my girlfriend come here whenever we can, we love this place, it has never disappointed. I have always loved this place the food is delicious, even if you're not a grilled cheese person like me, you have to try these sandwiches. The regular fries and bacon lollipops are also amazing every time. I have only tried 4 of the sandwiches on the menu and I liked all of them, my go to is the 5th Avenue and my girlfriend always gets the Time Square Melt. They serve them with a bit of tomato soup which, to everyone else I've been with is great, but to me is an acquired taste. Still once I got use to it it was great. The service is good, the waiters are generally nice but they're not like Disney nice how some other places are. They're very quick to get you what you need even when it's busy and since the restaurant is small you can always wave them down and they'll quickly come which is nice. The atmosphere is chill, there is sometimes a weird smell especially near the back of the store but once your food comes it'll overpower that smell. Alternatively, just sit in the front of the store to avoid it altogether. Also the wait times are pretty quick, I would say maybe 15 minutes tops but usually the food comes out quicker. Only downsides is that it is a bit pricey, for two sandwiches and a shared fry it comes out to like 50 with tip included. Though the sandwiches are big enough and heavy enough that you can split one and be full. On that topic, the food is heavy, but I mean they serve cheese and bacon mostly so you have to expect that going in. It's definitely worth it to go from time to time, my girlfriend and I drive from Miami to eat here, that's how good the food is. P.S if you park across the street where the plaza is the parking is free, and it's usually fairly empty on the weekdays. On weekends it'll be harder to find parking but you can also pay to park behind the restaurant. Also the photos aren't the best I promise they look better in real life, and this was on a busy time for them.

One of my favorite places to go in Wilton Manors when I'm craving something a little heavier too. Soak up the alcohol. I always get the village vegan and the vegan poutine but everything on the menu is absolutely delicious. Staff is always very friendly and are great with helping you pick something out if you're not sure what to get.

The truffle shuffle is to die for! Probably the best tomato soup as well! My husband really likes the meat packing district.

Best grilled cheese ive had in a long time. Want a late night snack?! They got ya covered. Very friendly staff! Even at 1am the food and service were great! Seating was crowded during that time but it was also raining so lots of people were huddled inside. Gotta stop here if your in the area!

You all have no idea how excited I have been to write this review. I am an avid New York Grilled Cheese fan. To the point that I paid $40 for an Uber just to be able to try it. I don't regret a damn thing because New York Grilled Cheese is where it's at. I was dropped off and got seated right away. I was a bit shocked with how big the inside actually was. It didn't seem very big but there was a pretty lengthy hallway that takes you to the back, with more seating. I am not going to lie, I do wish I would've ordered something else for my grilled cheese. I got a bit confused with the menu and pictures, and my grilled cheese ended up having egg on it. Which wasn't really my thing at all but in the picture, I thought the egg was cheese lol. I picked apart the egg but I should've paid better attention and chose something else for a better experience. Regardless, the flavor and texture was still very much there. The bread was cooked perfectly and the melty cheese was amazing. The bisque was also really good. It was full of flavor and I loved the thickness of it. Now for my favorite part...something that I have laid in bed dreaming about. Those truffle fries. Holy cannoli, I don't even know how to describe how wonderful they were. They were out of this world good and I took some home and had them later--they were still incredible hours later. I would book a flight and pay the $40 uber just for the fries all over again. They had some ranch that I was able to try as well but it wasn't my favorite. I preferred the flavors that came on the truffle fries. The service was awesome--the guy that was helping me was so sweet. He was also really awesome about filling up my drink. The prices were honestly really fair for what you got. I couldn't have had a better experience and I am so glad I visited here!

There are some nights in which you sit at home, the TV on, not knowing what to watch and not knowing what to do. Suddenly, you also realize you're also hungry. You've been so busy all day, doing things, accomplishing things - conquering the world - that you have forgotten a bit about the most important person in the world - you. Usually, in those moments, a run to the refrigerator to grab whatever you can will suffice - an underwhelming choice by all means. But not that Friday night. Instead of the refrigerator, I opened my Yelp app and instructed my girlfriend to pick a place she liked. And there it was New York Grilled Cheese. I must admit. I had not heard of it, but the moment she saw it's image pop on screen it'd been decided. Nothing I could've said, no other proposition was going to change her mind. She simply said they make the best grilled sandwich in the world, and with that, the die had been cast. There was only one location. It was 16 miles away. A little bit far for a Friday night after a long week of arduous work and with the TV already on set on Netflix. But nothing would stop her. We drove the 16 miles under some light rain. It was already 10:30pm. The parties in Wilton Manors were in full swing as we marched in our pajamas into New York Grilled Sandwich like zombies in search of brain. What we had as soon as it touched our lips woke us up and immediately reminded us of the celebration at hand, and the parties outside, and most of all, reminded us to wake up to enjoy the moment. The grilled sandwiches were delicious. They were an assault of taste and flavors which engulfed the tastebuds in a never-ending dance. We also ordered the Truffle Cheese Fries, to get started, along with wine and a Purple Haze beer. The stars of the night were the Brooklyn Porkster and the Meat Packing District. Both amazing. But the center piece - their pièce de résistance - was the soup. That delicious Tomato Basil Bisque they add to every order is to die for. To close the night we also had their New York Minute Pumpkin Sweet Bake to go along with the season. Now, I too know why she was so immediately hell bent on NGC. It was a perfect choice. There was no contention, no double thought, and no hesitation. It was a momentous this is it, this is the best, and we're going. So, don't think about it. This place's food will change your day, or night for that matter. It'll remind you of the best things in life. In the least, in all honesty, it'll change your grilled sandwich experience- forever.

This place sells the best grill cheese in the area! Their combinations pair so well with each other! You MUST TRY! You will not be disappointed and you will be full! Casual dining. Clean restaurant. Friendly staff!

I've loved NY Grilled Cheese for years. Super unique grilled cheeses and the best tomato bisque soup. I always order a larger soup than comes with the combo bc it's SO GOOD. The buffalo chicken grilled cheese is my favorite. Also amazing sweet potato waffle fries with marshmallow sauce!! 10/10 when I want a greasy, delicious meal. I will say you should be prepared to smell like a fryer when you leave though lol.

This place is very interesting the staff was very friendly and I had no idea how many different combinations of grilled cheeses they have

They launched the seasonal special today l. The Bronx! Excellent. Get it with bacon. Jules (the waitress) was awesome. We stop here everytime we are in the Manors.

Honestly, the food was SO good that everything else doesn't even matter! I've never tasted a more savory grilled cheese. It's served with a super rich tomato bisque that makes it a crime to not dip before ever single bite! I'm just blown away. I had the Wall Street Grinder, which has eggs and this amazing aioli...mouth watering. No complaints. This is a chill spot. I noticed a lot of people order to go, though there's inside and outside seating. Go for the food and just forget everything else! Worth every single second of the experience!

I love coming to this NY grilled cheese location and having Aaron as our server. He provides great recommendations and made us laugh every time. The food is amazing, and my favorite thing to get is the Soho Sweet. Highly recommend!

I don't know if this place is going downhill or what. But after a stressful first week back to work, I was excited to let all my worries drown in a delicious grilled cheese sandwich. The good: the restaurant is newly renovated and looks totally different from the last time I entered a few months ago. It was a pleasant surprise and the renovations were aesthetically pleasing. The bad: Placed a take out order. Arrived before estimated ready time. Still waited about 20-30 mins post estimated ready time and my food was still cold. How is this even possible you may ask? One man was the cook, waiter, and answering the phones. He even had to leave to get change while my food just ... sat ..... there. I was soooo disappointed because I love my food fresh and hot. I don't even blame him. The store is just badly managed. I really Hope this was a one time experience as I never experienced any thing like this after eating here so many times. I couldn't even finish my food that I paid $16 for AFTER not eating alllllll day. So, that says a lot.

It used to be Good place to eat after the club .. staff tonight Nov ,18 2023 was rude uninterested to be at work and impatient .. food was cold both sandwich and soup .. the place was empty the least they could do is provide a hot sandwich for $25 . It used to be my go to after the club but it's ruined now . McDonald's It is ...

Adorable little place. Super nice service. Mac and cheese is so good with some nice garlic flavor. Meat packing district sammy with tomato bisque dipper, out of this world

Love love love their tomato soup and grilled cheese. They are a little expensive but when it's 3am out of the club or 11pm before the club they are bomb honestly bomb at anytime.

This place is conveniently located on Wilton Manors main drive however it isn't really worth the $13 for a single grilled cheese. The tomato soup please eat with caution because they do use chicken broth in it they didn't used to have that on the menu but they do now but just a note for those vegetarians that want a grilled cheese sandwich don't eat the tomato soup

I bought the standard grilled cheese sandwich and it was better than I thought it could be. Been back several times for it, its that good. Good kitschy ambiance and excellent, friendly service.

A must in Wilton Manors! This place might not look huge from the outside, but as you walk in, it has plenty of seating both in the front and the back. The prices are reasonable, ranging from $12 - $15 depending on toppings. What's great about each grilled cheese is that it comes with a side of tomato/basil soup, a nice touch for extra flavor! We ordered the Soho Sweet Cheeses, which I recommend for sweet and salty lovers.

The food is awesome the service is good too. The owner is kind of stuck on himself and an overall douche but that doesn't take away from the awesome food. I'd recommend it and have to anyone visiting Wilton manors.

The service here was amazing. The server knew the menu and was so nice. The place is super nice I got a pizza grilled cheese and it came with tomato soup, it was really good but the sandwich was a little salty, otherwise it was super good. Definitely have to give this place a try. Lots of good options

Oh my grilled cheese!! Soho Brie grilled cheese was unbelievable!! We ordered a side of yankee waffle fries! Wow!!

We stopped here after bar hopping and WOW. The food was delicious. Very flavorful and definitely made with love. The sandwiches were very filling. The best part was getting the tomato bisque with your meal. A few friends don't like bisque and that wasn't an issue for me. I ate them all....