Next Door Pub & Pizzeria

Wonderful Irish stew soup and Spinach and Artichoke dip with Parmesan flatbread crisps!! If you LOVE butter and mushrooms you’ll love the portabella mushroom ravioli! And my son loved his burger!! It was busy but we were seated right away, service was fast and staff were friendly. Prices very fair! Last year we ordered a pizza to go and we loved it!! And we are from the Chicagoland area if that tells you anything!!

I came here for the first time in almost a year. The spinach and artichoke dip is hands down the best around. Absolutely fantastic food. Excellent pizza. Been going here for years and yet to have a bad meal. Thank you to Jean for taking great care of me and being top notch with everything. It has been a rough week and I'm thankful to have been treated so well. One of my favorite pizza places!

To start, the food was very good, but the service was not. We ordered the pretzel, bone in wings, cheese curds and Italian beef with fries. All of it was very fresh and tasty. Our service was not very unpleasant - our server was Grace. She came around maybe twice throughout, didn’t refill our sprite, didn’t ask us if we needed anything, literally nothing. We pretty much had to flag down every other waitress to get us what we needed. What was even more frustrating was that she would go to nearby tables many times and ask if they needed anything, but acted like we didn’t exist. It was only two of us, a low maintenance couple, so it made us feel very unwelcome. Because of this, not sure I would come back and if I did, it would only be for carry out.

The food was absolutely superb!! We had the clam chowder, ceasar salad, calamari, pizza, brisket ravioli, fish fry with fries, and brownie bites with ice cream! All of it was so delicious!! Will be coming back!! The waitress was incredible and the chefs knocked it out of the park! Thank you for blessing my night!

The restaurant had great variety of food. From salads, pizza, lasagna, pasta, burgers, desserts & more.. it was all very tasty. The dessert was enough to share for two. Glad we stopped. Service was wonderful too. Waiting 30 minutes for a table was worth it. If there is a packed house the place has to be good. It gets a bit crowded and noisy, like any good restaurant.

We had the best time here today on the patio! Everyone was so nice and our server Alan was great! The food and drinks were amazing! The spinach dip is a must have!!!! Cheese curds ,salad, kids tenders were also great! We loved the spinach dip so much we got another to go as well as a grilled chicken sandwich that was awesome too!! We got the blue Hawaiian and the Bloody Mary and they were great! Thank you for a fun time for my daughters 22nd birthday!

Some of the best pizza I've had in a long time! Took a while to get the food but it was worth it. They were very busy.

My husband and I, first timers on a little weekend vacation here and we got recommended by an awesome tattoo artist that we met about this place and she was right! Best pizza hands-down, appetizers amazing, pasta amazing, drinks amazing, service was amazing. Our waitress Susan was awesome. Definitely our favorite spot when we come in town.

Fk'n fire! (That's all I had to say but yelp won't let me post just that so I guess I'll ramble about... garbage pizza is super awesome if you don't like it it's your moms fault. The perch is perfect. Beers f me up every time especially the Lakefront IPA's... my kids only eat chicken tenders.... My wife's car is white, i would love to vacation more, bought another boat but kids could care less even though I've owned boats since I was 8.... My dog died years ago, now we have a cat... opp, says this is my stop! Have a good night everyone! Enjoy your meal!!!

We visited Next Door Pub & Pizzeria with a large group while staying in Lake Geneva. We arrived right when they opened for lunch so we had no issues being seated. The atmosphere was nice and our service was good. The staff was friendly. We chose Next Door Pub & Pizzeria because it had good reviews and a large menu. They have a little bit of everything which worked well with our large group of adults, kids, and someone who eats gluten-free. They are also centrally located between downtown (where we were spending the day) and Timber Ridge Lodge (where we were staying). The prices are also reasonable. Unfortunately, between a plethora of different drinks, and dishes (including pizza and several fish fry options), no one in our group thought the food was anything great. It wasn't good or bad, but suffice it to say when we were looking for a place to eat on a different evening no one wanted to return there either. If I were back in Lake Geneva I'd probably give this place another whirl and try something else on the menu (I had a cod fish fry) but at this point, I don't feel like it lived up to the hype/reviews.

The parking lot was packed on a Thursday at 630. We had to park in the back of restaurant. Once inside we were immediately seated. It is very small inside and loud. I ordered a burger and my husband ordered ribs. My burger was juicy and the ribs were tender. I give it 4 out of 5 stars due to no Prosecco available and we waited quite awhile for our food.

Awful just awful, food was decent. Horrible service had tons of problems. Would not recommend, especially if you have a large group. Tale your bus elsewhere.

Great food!! Always consistent each time we eat there. Service is always good! Prices are very reasonable and the portions are good.

If you're in the Lake Geneva area and looking for some good pub and pizza, this is a great go to place. They have a great family atmosphere and the ambiance is lively! The service is great and attentive without being overly annoying. The indoor and outdoor seating areas are so inviting and vast. We ordered the spinach and artichoke dip accompanied with flatbread. The dip was so creamy and the hint of parmesan on top just did it. The flatbread could have been an appetizer on its own. We also ordered some onion rings which were crispy and tasty. For dinner, we ordered a personal spinach pizza for my daughter which she absolutely loved. I had the bourbon chicken flatbread and chicken sandwich which were both excellent.

My family and I were visiting the Lake Geneva area for a long weekend and stumbled upon this gem. Next Door Pub has an old-school rustic vibe. They have a small patio outside and also a waiting area where you can order drinks. Service was good. Everyone was super friendly except for the hostess. Now to the food! Everything was so yummy! I was pleasantly surprised! We ordered a spinach pizza, bbq chicken pizza, a grilled chicken sandwich, spinach artichoke dip, and onion rings. The pizza was delicious, and the crust was perfect ( I didn't try the bbq one, just commenting on the spinach)! The spinach artichoke dip with the Flatbread was amazingly good. I can still taste it! Haha! I couldn't get enough of it! And the onion rings were awesome, perfectly crispy. If we ever end up back in Lake Geneva, will definitely go back!

I continue to take guests to NDP and they are fully impressed. Next Door Pub Lake Geneva and NDP Lakeshore

ordered for delivery while in lake geneva and would recommend! We got a couple pizzas and loved the Hawaiian. Lots of sauce and nice crispy thin crust. Very quick delivery and arrived about 15 minutes after ordering!

The food is good and the portions are big. The pretzel is very big! We ordered some sandwiches and burgers, so everything was pretty standard American fare. They have a kids menu with crayons for the little ones. It was very busy when we came for dinner, around 5:45-6pm on a weekday. The dining room is very dark and noisy. There's not much extra room, because there was nowhere to put our stroller or the chairs that had to be removed to accommodate high chairs. They do have an outdoor seating area, but it was too cold when we visited.

Excellent Pizza . A must have if you're in the Lake Geneva area. I've been eating here for 30+ years. Love it

We ate outside on a recent trip to Lake Geneva. I liked the menu options and prices. Lake Geneva is expensive so I did some research beforehand and am happy with my decision. The large pretzel was so yummy as was the non cheese sauce although my 5 yr old liked the cheese. I loved my salad and their blue cheese dressing. My 5 yr old finished her burger and shared a few bites with her picky 3 yr old brother. I'd return if back in Lake Geneva and probably order the same thing!!

3.5 We were told 45 min-1hr wait but we got seated a bit earlier which we appreciated! Our server was very nice but the reason why I docked it a couple stars is because the food took SO. LONG. to come out. To be fair, we were a larger table but we waited well over an hour since we gave our order to get our food. Ambiance is very pub-hole in the wall- family vibes. The food itself was decent in terms of taste but the food took absolutely way too long to come out. I might come back with a smaller table to see if the experience is different.

I love coming here for lunch. Dinners okay too, but I like their many choices of luncheon specials. I've had the beef cheesesteak for lunch with extra crunchy crispy onion rings. This Monday I enjoyed the chicken wings for $2 off 10 wings and I like the Korean inspired BBQ sauce. I wanted a hearty salad with no meat and the wedge salad was perfect! Their soups are also good and my husband likes the Wisconsin cheese soup. When my grandkids are here, they enjoy the pizza here, too. Restrooms recently updated and very clean tidy and amenities are touchless! Very casual atmosphere, but occasionally there will be a very loud conversation that can be very disruptive, but the person being so vocal often isn't aware of it. The wait staff is awesome, quick to refill drinks and quick to clean off dirty dishes.

Next Door Pub is an iconic Lake Geneva gem with a rich history, and my husband's family has been coming here for years. The pizza is undeniably one of the best in Lake Geneva, and the salads are equally amazing. The service is consistently friendly, creating a welcoming atmosphere. Keep in mind that they can get very busy, especially on weekends during the summer, leading to potential long waits. While the interior has a classic bar-restaurant charm, a little remodeling, particularly with the carpet, could enhance the overall ambiance. Despite this, our love for this place persists, and we will continue to be regulars. As a vegan, I appreciate the gluten-free vegan crust option on the menu - it's delicious with sauce and veggies, even without cheese.

We ordered the pizza and it was one of the best. We are from Chicago and have tried lots of different pizzas.

I had the meat lasagne and my wife had the build your own pasta bowl. The serving sizes are so generous we were able to have the leftovers for lunch the next day. We were there for lunch and that are always busy yet they manage to be very friendly and accommodating. Everyone working there chipped in to help each other out. We will definitely be going back there again.

They have the best pizza ever. The chicken wings are to die for. Everything is good The staff are friendly and wonderful

I just want to start off by stating that I am a larger older gentleman with a thick southern accent despite the fact that I'm from the great state of Wisconsin. I love everything about Wisconsin. The cows, cheese, packers go Favre! I also enjoy a ride on my tractor, the brewers & the large number of Wisconsin ladies who have enough armpit hair to warm a dozen heifers during the cold winter nights. Yum. Now, I am a man of Jesus so just know that. I witnessed a younger couple stealing a bottle from hot sauce. When I told the bus boy he told me to let him know when I wanted my burger wrapped up. I wasn't even eating a burger. My wife was & she plowed through that burger like the kool aid man through a brick wall. I was eating a bowl of soup & a pretzel with those adorable little sauces. 3 per order! Anyway, the food is nice but the bus boy doesn't care about stolen hot sauce bottles. I even called the local police to inform them but since all I had was an out of state plate they said they couldn't help. Those thefts were smuggling stolen merchandise across state lines! Lord help them & god bless the Green Bay packers.

In town for a short getaway ...food was great, Carter our waiter was amazing friendly & very attentive. The location was easy to get to and the ambiance was nice. I was able to tell it was going to be good food when every table was full & had a packed parking lot. Next time I'm in town am definitely going back!

We really enjoyed our dinner here while we were in town for the weekend. We were sat right away even though the place was mostly full. The server was very friendly and attentive. We had a delicious supreme style pizza. It was just the right amount of toppings to cheese ratio. I had a very good French Martini!

We have moved to the Twin Lakes area about a month ago and we're looking for a good pizza place. We order carry out and drove about 10 miles to get the pizza. It was well worth the drive. The pizza was awesome. Just like the pizza we used to get in the Chicago area. I am definitely going back to eat at the restaurant. Great pizza.

Went Monday evening the week of Thanksgiving. They were pretty busy but sat us (party of 6) right away. Our server was very friendly and brought carafes of tea and water so we always had drinks. My Italian Beef Supreme was so good!! The beef was piled on, tender and full of flavor. The Giant Pretzel was amazing and the Mac n Cheese pizza was a hit at our table. Will most definitely return when in the area.

Excellent food and service. Our server was Jessica and she was AWESOME!! We had the Italian beef sandwiches and OMG, melt in your mouth delicious. 100% recommend!!

Great for pizza and pub grub. There's a big bar area that's separated from the two dining rooms which is always hoping. Salads are fresh with the Oriental chicken being my wife's favorite. Garlic bread is super tasty. My favorite is the Italian beef and sausage supreme which is served with cheese and red sauce on it. The Italian beef is home made and very good, served with a side of au jus for dipping. If you still have some room the lemon cake is superb.

Great service! Our server was on top of it for our big group. Cheese curds and giant pretzel were okay. Pizza was good, highly recommend the Maui Wowie if you Iike spicy. Yeah it has pineapples on it, get over it!

Very crowded so we were able to sit outside and it was beautiful out. They got us in quite quickly considering the crowd. The burger was unfortunately one of the worst I've had - the jalapeño popper burger. I love cream cheese as much as the next but a slab of it on top of my burger, not spread in to the bun or anything, is gross to me. Our friends had a pizza that came out with a raw crust so the waitress touched the crust all over, took it back to cook more AND THEN brought the same pizza she had touched back, still with a raw crust. We know it was the same pizza because our friend had taken a tiny corner piece and realized the crust was raw. The waitress said it was because the green peppers on the pizza make the crust too wet. Okay, don't serve pizza with green peppers, pre cook the crust, do SOMETHING different. The Brussels sprouts with pulled pork for an appetizer were AMAZING though. The pizza was just ridiculous and you should never touch a customers food then bring it back to them and think that's okay.

BEST PIZZA AROUND...always busy..the true locals favorite pizza..hands down. The staff are professional and quick always seem to be attentive while being incredibly busy. Their other dishes are great as well. Always busy during a football game and has always been a solid place for me.

Great food for a local pub! Pizza is always a hit, we love the Geneva Meat Monster. Sandwiches and apps are delicious too. Love the chicken sandwich and meatball app!

Good food, good portions, good service and good variety on the menu. Had the fish & chips plus a wedge salad. The salad was a meal in and of itself. The fish was perch and was tender, flaky, juicy and done just right. Will Definitely come back here.

The food was beyond expectations. The service was beyond accommodating. We got: 12'' pub garbage pizza. Enough to feed 3 hungry hippos 2 cocktails bbq pulled pork nachos Our total bill was $40! My girl and I were fighting over who pays the bill. She said she would take the bill because it's my birthday. The waiter/bartender said happy birthday and came with a huge price of chocolate cake. This place was completely packed when we came in and they still kept up better than 80% of restaurants in Milwaukee. I swear by this place and hope you have as great of an experience as we did.

Greasy deep fried, melted cheese, gavy... heart attack on a plate! Service is great. The ambiance is alright.

Great neighborhood pub with a million food choices and a better-than-average beer list. The pizza is good (as in picky Chicagoan good). Be prepared to wait. They have a great bar in its own room, so the noise is contained in there. And it can get noisy, especially when a dozen guys fresh off the golf course come in to wait for their table! The regulars are generally friendly, and there's lots on the walls to look at. TIP -- try this place on a night other than the weekends. It's so close to Lake Geneva it fills up with weekend tourists fast!

Fantastic food and a shout out to their wait staff, especially Destiny. We were a table full of people which always makes me wonder if someone's order is going to be wrong, and that certainly was not the case. The food was fantastic, and the atmosphere was fun and family friendly. I will certainly be back

Super pizza and beef sandwiches. You can't go wrong with the rest of the menu either. Great food, atmosphere, and prices too!

Horrible!!! Omg! So gross!!!and the service sucked! Curbside pickup. And I was going to feed,14 peeps! They hung up on me, didn't even give them my full order. The girl said once I payed that's it. But I was willing to buy more. And the hold time on the phone, is ridiculous. For shity food. And or any response. Why endorse a shit hole! Captured audience. They really suck!

Great pizza and beer! The service is quick and attentive. It's in a great location and far enough from all the tourists downtown.

This place is terrible. Their website promises delivery but in fact they don't deliver. But they will call you and tell you to pick it up, cold pizza, yum! Never again. Over priced and over rated

Excellent gluten-free menu! The cheeseburger pizza is delicious and unique. We will definitely be back to try other options.

Came in with 20 people for a 50th Birthday get together. Alex, Maria and all staff were amazing. Made room for us! Pizza here is my favorite for the last 20 years and my husband knew that. Thank you!!!

This place was delightful! We went for a road trip and this restaurant was top rated so we decided to check it out and it was beyond the expectation. Food was incredibly delicious and fresh ingredients. Prices were insanely low and drinks were beautiful crafted. Best pizza! Definitely worth the stop!

Cool spot, good food and good vibe. Ate at the bar, bartender was a pro...old school. It's a great off the water Lake Geneva place, always a good stop to escape the hustle and bustle of lakeside spots

Great food, something for everyone and reasonably priced. My family's new Lake Geneva stop.

We ordered some chicken tenders and fries to go. They put it in styrofoam contains that melted into the food. We sent them a message and they resolved the problem by sending us a gift card. When things happen, it's how the business resolves the issue that makes a difference.

I love their pizza and their service After collecting 20 coupons for a free pizza I was denied After many years of a loyal customer that I believe was not the way to handle my request I will still order my pizza from the pub, but I'm disappointed with their policy from a true pub fan

This is by far the best food place in Lake Geneva!! All their food was amazing and delicious! The waiter we had was friendly and very helpful! The pizza was great, the pretzel was by far the best we have ever tasted!! Every time we come to lake Geneva this will be our place to stop for good food! Do yourself a favor and just go and you won't regret it!

Ordered food to go. Service was friendly. The cheese curds were inexcusably bad! They should have never been served. Completely over fried and dried out. I would have sent back if I was eating there in person. The lasagna was just ok. Some people mentioned it was hard to find the noodles but that was not an issue for me. I liked the meat sauce on top. Although I do appreciate a large portion size this was extreme. I found my meal overwhelming rather than enjoyable. I did appreciate that it came with a breadstick and side of soup. The cheese soup was delicious. My husband had the monster burger. It was your average over sized bar burger. He liked the bacon on it. The chips on the side were very average. I probably wouldn't come back.

Very friendly local restaurant. Service is excellent and food is very good and a lot of it.

I came here expecting delicious pizza, but, not only was the pizza amazing, the ribs, meatballs, lasagna, and salad was all so tasty! The waiters are very nice and accommodating, the food is great and the price is reasonable! My only complaint is the wait, it's first come, first serve so the wait was supposed to be 30 minutes but after we put our name in there was an open table to take which was a bit confusing.

Must stop place while in Lake Geneva area. We have been here many times for sit down. Today we ordered pick up due to the current pandemic. When we would go for dinner or lunch, there was typically always a wait. The wait is never that long though and you can always grab a drink by the bar. Service is always good. They have great bloody Mary's and an abundance of fun drinks to choose from. Appetizers we have tried are great. Burgers , chicken wings (TONS of flavors to choose from), sandwiches, pasta, and pizza are always a great choice and delicious. Prices are reasonable and not overpriced at all due to the touristy area. This is a must stop and you won't be disappointed by the huge menu. Will update with more pics once we can sit down again !