Flora H.
Yelp
*** JBF America's Classic (2014) *** #7 ***
3.5 stars for this James Beard America's Classic. My experience was a lot different than that described by others (great food with bad service). I found both the service and food to be pretty good, and it was a much more upscale experience than I was expecting (white tablecloths to boot).
The previous reviews appear to be mostly to be for the back room, which is more casual than the front, complete with a bar and pool tables. It is nowhere near being "divey" but more of a Buca di Beppo type vibe. If you want to enter the back room directly, you can do so from the alley, but you can also walk through the front of the restaurant (although it is a bit awkward to do so), which has its door on the main road next to a Mexican place (that was quite hopping when we walked by). We were actually a bit disappointed when we saw the white tablecloths and upscale vibe of the front room; we were kind of expecting a hole in the wall type place, a secret gem that the JBF had discovered. But we weren't about to let that disappointment alter our experience, so we moved on to focus on the food and wine.
WINE -
The wine list is out of control. I don't even know how many bottles of wine are on it; it covers the entire back of the menu. But since we didn't want to drink an entire bottle, we were very limited by their by-the-glass selections. With only 3 reds from Oregon available by the glass, those were the three that we tried. Two of them were okay and one was better (the Libra) but none could hold a candle to the Pinot Noirs of Santa Ynez. I'll have to keep hunting for a comparable Oregon wine.
MENU -
The menu changes by season and day. Ours was marked "autumn" and "Sunday". Some of the things we'd seen pictures of were disappointingly not available (dungeness crab lasagna for example).
APPETIZER -
These was a seasonal special, a mixed mushroom medley served in paper, that was divine. It could have been a smidge hotter (it was warm when it came out and cold by the time we finished it) but because I love mushrooms, this medley of various types of mushrooms was still wonderful. The bread is an additional $2 and you have to ask for it. It's served with olive oil and nothing special, but we ordered some to go with the mushrooms.
PIZZA -
The salami pizza was 5 stars. Up there with the best pizza that I've ever had. The salami is house made, and it is thin and cut like pepperonis on the pizza. It is VERY thin, Italian style pizza that is not greasy at all. There is just the right amount of chili flakes and parmesan to complement the salami, which is crispy but not burned. The pizza is perfection. We had a leftover slice that I brought home on the plane as a carry on and ate the next day for lunch, and it was still divine.
MAIN -
Our main was the chicken stuffed with its own sausage. I think because we had asked for our meal to come out in parts (appetizer, then pizza, then chicken), they waited to bring it to until we were done with our pizza, and it was barely warm by the time that we got it. Not sure if that's what took away from the dish, but it just wasn't that great even though the description had sounded amazing. It came with a small side salad that had chicken in it, and that was better than the chicken itself. Not a bad dish, but not a great one and I wouldn't waste an order on this.
DESSERT:
The profiteroles that we got barely had any ice cream in them (very different than the picture that I had seen) and were really just pastries covered in chocolate. Profiteroles are my absolute favorite dessert so I was a bit disappointed. Also, my bf had told them it was my birthday but they didn't put a candle in it or do anything special. Also a bit disappointing.
It wasn't too expensive of a meal at $97 before tax, but the only thing that blew me away was the pizza. I'm sure that the crab lasagna is also spectacular, so I would come back for the pizza and to try that (if it is available) should I visit Willamette again in the future. I probably wouldn't drive out there from Portland just to eat at Nick's again, however.
TIP: If you are driving out from Portland to eat here like we did, try to arrive in McMinnville before the Evergreen Aviation Museum closes... they have an amazing collection elegantly housed (including the Spruce Goose). Unfortunately we arrived after the museum closed, but drove down and took pictures of the Spruce Goose when we saw it from the road.