Matthew S.
Yelp
In a showdown between Nick's and Clemente's, two seafood restaurants near each other, serving almost identical menu items, offering similar experiences, who is better?
Ambiance
Both are right on the marina that empties into the Atlantic Ocean. Both are right near the Belt Parkway. Both have on site parking. This is pretty much a push.
Edge: Push
Service
Clemente's carries a bit of a younger vibe, especially in its wait staff. Generally speaking I found the service younger there and older here at Nick's. The service here is slightly faster but also has a bit less people. Less does not always mean more, but they do a slightly better job moving food across the people. It was starting to get busy as the dinner rush rolled on, whereas Clemente's has a nonstop rush.
Edge: Clemente's
Food
I ordered here the fish tacos and a shrimp scampi. While I ordered less here than I did at Clemente's, Nick's I feel does better justice for our nautical neighbors. The food tastes fresher, the respect is higher, and less of a push out. Clemente's threw it in front of me and hoped for the best.
Edge: Nick's but slightly
Overall
What really makes one better than the other is really up to you. If you want a bit of a party and livelier feel, Clemente's has that. For a more quieter, more family friendly vibe, you go with Nick's. In the end, it is all a matter of preference because the food items are identical in many ways. It just depends on how you want it done and what you want out of it.